speaker
Operator
Conference Call Operator

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for standing by, and welcome to the American Electric Power third quarter 2020 earnings release conference call. At this point, all the participant lines are in a listen-only mode. However, there will be an opportunity for your questions. You may ask a question by pressing 1, then 0 on your touchstone phone, and you can withdraw your question by repeating the 1-0 command. As a reminder, today's call is being recorded. I'll turn the call now over to the Managing Director of Investor Relations, Ms. Darcy Reese. Please go ahead.

speaker
Darcy Reese
Managing Director, Investor Relations

Thank you, John. Good morning, everyone, and welcome to the third quarter 2020 earnings call for American Electric Power. We appreciate you taking the time to join us today. Our earnings release, presentation slides, and related financial information are available on our website at aep.com. Today, we will be making forward-looking statements during the call. There are many factors that may cause future results to differ materially from these statements. please refer to our SEC filings for a discussion of these factors. Joining me this morning for opening remarks are Nick Akins, our Chairman, President, and Chief Executive Officer, and Brian Tierney, our Chief Financial Officer. We will take your questions following their remarks. I will now turn the call over to Nick.

speaker
Nick Akins
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer

Okay. Thanks, Darcy, and welcome, everyone, to American Electric Power's third quarter 2020 earnings call. The third quarter has been another strong quarter for AP. Despite the continued challenges of COVID-19 and its effects on the economy, we continue to be optimistic about our ability to execute and provide the consistent quality of earnings and dividend growth our shareholders expect and provide focus on our customers and communities we serve to get past the multiple challenges we face as a result of the pandemic. I know many of us have had the feeling during 2020 with its multiple challenges that Lenny Kravitz sang about in his song, Fly Away, singing, oh, I want to get away, I want to fly away, yeah, yeah, yeah, probably figuratively and literally. But there is a lot at the end of the tunnel. As we move through this memorable year, AEP continues to drive firmly within the guidance range with targeting the midpoint as we move to the last quarter. We're accomplishing this by executing on cost control in response to the pandemic, keeping our employees safe through the crisis by taking all the extra precautions, and working with our customers to alleviate the economic pressures during this time. We are also learning a lot during this crisis, the value of efficient work from home environments, the focus on capital and O&M management, the acceleration of our Achieving Excellence program, and the focus on social issues that drive a cultural brand that brings everyone into the journey of being the premier regulated utility AAP strives to be. In fact, AAP just made the Forbes Just Capital 100 list for 2021, being the highest-ranked utility on the list. We've also been involved with two major storm events, Hurricanes Laura and Delta, in SWEPCO's Louisiana Territory. I'm proud of how our employees stepped up during these major weather events in the midst of COVID-19 protocols to effectively and efficiently return service to our customers in a safe manner, just as they do every day to keep the lights on. And now it's even a more important service during work-from-home and stay-at-home environments. Financially, our operating performance continues to be strong in the face of these challenges. AAP's operating earnings for the quarter came in at $1.47 per share versus $1.46 per share last year, bringing us to $3.56 per share for year-to-date 2020 versus $3.65 per share last year at this time. We continue to be firmly within the stated 2020 guidance range of $4.25 to $4.45, and we continue to be optimistic regarding our progress going into 2021. We are reaffirming our current guidance range and our long-term 5% to 7% growth rate. And as I have said previously, I would be disappointed not to be in the upper half of that 5% to 7% range. Our board just approved a dividend increase of approximately 6% in line with our earnings in the middle of our targeted payout ratio of 60% to 70% and consistent with our long-term growth rate of 5% to 7%, an incredible accomplishment given the headwinds we expected we were facing in the first quarter and the second quarter of this year. Even with this success in turbulent times, we are not out of the woods yet, but we are seeing improvement in industrial and residential load. However, commercial loads, such as churches, restaurants, hotels, and schools, not surprisingly, are still challenged. Bron will get into more detail on the economy later. We could not have achieved the outcome that AAP has achieved thus far during the year without our employees' attention in cutting our costs to compensate for losses from the COVID economy. Our Achieving Excellence program is going very well, and not only has it helped us compensate for the revenue losses due to the pandemic, but it has set an excellent catalyst for the future in terms of continued O&M cost control. More to come on this at November EEI. Most economists believe the 2021 economy will improve, and while we are seeing positive progress going into fourth quarter, industrial and commercial progress has slowed, perhaps until after the election cycle or during the second wave of the COVID cases or during the pendency of upcoming therapeutics and vaccines. With all of that said, it has been a very productive quarter, and we expect improvement to continue into 2021. We continue to adhere to COVID pandemic related protocols of temperature testing, mask requirements, social distancing, and hygiene related activities. Our confirmed cases are increasing with the apparent second wave, and we are doubling down on messaging around practicing safeguards outside of the work environment as much as inside. Thankfully, we have not lost anyone due to the virus, but vigilance and fighting complacency is key here. We also have continued our outreach to employees and the communities we serve regarding racial injustice. As I mentioned last quarter, our Seize the Moment initiative is important to reach a deeper understanding of the racial divides that exist and gain perspective from one another about actionable next steps. Before I get to the regulatory updates, I'll just head this off with the past questions about HB 6 in Ohio. I'll just say flatly that we have nothing new to report from AP's perspective. Any potential legislative change is not imminent, particularly given a noisy election cycle, so perhaps we'll hear more after the election. As we have said earlier, any change to the existing legislation is likely to be financially insignificant to AEP, and we will still be pushing for forward-looking legislation regarding clean energy options, energy efficiency, and other technology enhancements at grid scale and with our customers. Regarding the legal issues surrounding HB6, also nothing new to report, and my previous comments stand on this subject. Now for the regulatory update. If there is one observation that has become apparent through this pandemic, it is the acknowledgement of the criticality of the service that we provide to our customers and communities. This year, we have weathered through the effects of the pandemic and overcome significant storm activity that have challenged our system and our workforce. As we work with our regulators to position the company to be able to continue to meet the expectations of our customers and communities, we are stressing the fundamentals of a strong balance sheet. Now more than ever, it is essential for our operating companies to be well positioned to have the cash flows and returns needed to attract the capital necessary to meet the ongoing needs of our customers and communities. And as you all know, we have a number of regulatory proceedings pending before our state regulators this quarter, most of which are needed to conform with previous regulatory stipulations, stay-out provisions, or to address the timing needs of critical investments. Ohio filed its most recent base case June 1st as required under the terms of our prior ESP4 settlement. We are seeking a 41 million rate increase with a 10.15% ROE. A procedural schedule has not been established yet on that case. APCO filed its base rate case in March as required by Virginia law. We have completed hearings and the case has been submitted to the Commission for a decision. Our Virginia residential customers have not experienced a rate increase over the past 10 years. In this case, we have asked for $37.9 million net of depreciation with an ROE of 9.9%. We were disappointed with the position taken by both staff and the AG, which fails to recognize our need to have an opportunity to earn our authorized return over the next tri-year period. We remain confident that the Commission will see through these arguments and recognize their obligation under the law to allow the company an opportunity to earn a fair return. A decision is expected in November. Kentucky was subject to a stay-out provision until June of this year. We subsequently filed our base rate case on June 29th, where we asked for a $65 million increase and an ROE of 10%. The company has also sought to use the remaining unprotected AFDIT funds in Kentucky to offset bills for customers who cannot afford to pay their bills. The Commission elected to combine this request with a base rate case following, and we expect resolution by year end. Last but not least, in our SWEPCO jurisdiction, we received approval from the Commission to create a regulatory asset for the costs associated with Hurricane Laura. We will ask for similar treatments for the costs associated with Hurricane Delta, and we are hopeful that we can put this year's hurricane season safely behind us. In Texas, SWEPCO made its base rate case filing on October 13th, where we are seeking a $90.2 million increase with an ROE of 10.35%. We are also seeking to increase the storm reserve and increase our vegetation management expenditures to minimize the risk of future outages to our Texas customers. We continue to make progress on our north central wind projects, which will benefit our customers in Louisiana, Arkansas, and Oklahoma. Foundation work has commenced at the Sundance facility, which is expected to be in service by the end of first quarter 2021. Invenergy is currently completing final site preparation on both the Maverick and Traverse locations. We continue to expect to acquire the Maverick facility by December 21 and the Traverse facility in the December to first quarter of 2022 timeframe. We have followed our settlement true-up in Arkansas and are finalizing our settlement true-up in Oklahoma. We are looking forward to the benefits that these projects will bring to our customers by providing access to some of the nation's richest wind resources and helping SWEPCO and PSO advance a greener energy future. Okay, so now to the equalizer chart. I'll talk about that. I think it's on page five of the presentation. So our current ROE is about 9%, and we generally target these returns to be in the 9.5% to 10% range. The ROEs below are not weather normalized, and certainly keep in mind that we're also thickening equity layers as well. So I'll talk about AP Ohio first. I just mentioned the rate case there. It's above authorized primarily due to favorable regulatory items, partially offset by the roll-off of the legacy issues that we've been talking about for years regarding the PER and the RSR. But we also expect the year-end ROE to trend around the authorized levels of 10%. For APCO... which I had mentioned earlier, is slightly below authorized due to lower normalized usage and higher depreciation from increased capital investments, partially offset by continued management of the O&M expenses. Effective January 2020 costs associated with the last 17.5% of Wheeling Power's interest in Mitchell Platte became recoverable through APCO and Wheeling rates. And then I already discussed Virginia's tri-annual review. Kentucky, already discussed the rate case there, but they're below, as you can see, well below, authorized due to loss of load from weak economic conditions and loss of major customers along with higher expenses during the stay-out period. So we have a lot of work to do there. The ROE for IEM at the end of third quarter was 10.4%. Its ROE was above authorized due to continued management of OEM expenses, reduced interest expense, and rate true-ups, partially offset by lower commercial industrial sales. IEM's ROE is projected to trend slightly below 10% by year-end, consistent with authorized ROEs in Michigan and in Indiana. PSO. Its ROE is 8% at the end of third quarter. It was below its authorized level, primarily due to lower normalized usage and unfavorable weather in 2020, partially offset by continued management of O&M expenses. PSO's 2019 base case, as you recall, approved a transmission tracker, a partial distribution tracker, and an ROE of 9.4% authorized. So we'll continue to make progress there. SWEPCO, the ROE for SWEPCO is about 7.4%, and as you recall, much of that is related to the Turk plant not being in retail rates in Arkansas, and that impacts it by about 110 basis points. SWEPCO received an order in its Arkansas base case settlement in December 2019, and effective 2020 approved a $24 million revenue increase in ROE of 9.45%. In October 2020, we also filed a rate case in Texas, as I mentioned earlier. In AP Texas, its ROE is around 7.5%. It was below authorized due to lag associated with the timing of annual cost recovery filings. We did not make those filings during the pendency of the previous rate case. and, of course, one-time adjustments from our finalized base rate case itself. Favorable regulatory treatment allows AP Texas to file annual DCRF and TCOS filings, and we've since filed many of those at this point. I think there's been three cases that have been filed. And while earnings should improve in 2020 with the base rate case finalized and annual filings now resumed, continued levels of investment in Texas will impact the ROE. The expectation is for the ROE to trend towards an authorized ROE of 9.4% in the long term, but be around probably 8% by the end of 2020. As far as the transmission company is concerned, AP Transmission Holdco was 9.8%, and it was below authorized, primarily driven by the annual revenue true-up in the second quarter of 2020 to return the over-collection of 2019 revenues. Transmission is forecasted an ROE of 9.8% to 10.1% range in 2020. It is also interesting to note that when you look at the average equity in our operating jurisdictions, the transmission holdco is now the largest. which that's happened for the first quarter. This first quarter, that has actually occurred. So making a lot of progress. But at the same time, though, the investment being made relative to transmission is certainly improving the quality of service to our customers. So very happy with the progress we're making around our T&D investments and its ability to improve customers' experiences. As I close, I'd be remiss in not thanking our employees at the Oakley Union Power Station that was officially retired from service a couple of weeks ago after several decades of providing generation resources in meeting the needs of our customers' electricity demands in Texas and Oklahoma. Oakley Union was under construction about the time I joined AEP out of college. And when you see people and assets retiring, it just further illustrates the resiliency of AAP over the last 114 years. But also that change occurs, and we have to change with it. Thanks again to all the Oakley Union employees through the years. So all in all, a solid quarter for AAP, and I can't resist when thinking about AAP's future post-COVID with the latent value of the need for resiliency and reliability of the grid to support work-from-home environments, Moving forward with the transformation to clean energy resources, which we at AEP are in the beginning stages of, and the further electrification of the economy, we would say in the words of the late Eddie Van Halen, it's about time. This time is our time. And right on, we'll let it shine. I am convinced in overcoming the challenges of 2020, this company will be even stronger as we move into 2021 and beyond. Brian?

speaker
Brian Tierney
Chief Financial Officer

Thank you, Nick, and good morning, everyone. I will take us through the third quarter and year-to-date financial results, provide some insight on the load in the economy, review our balance sheet and liquidity, and finish with a preview of what we'll present at the EEI conference. Let's stop briefly on slide six, which shows the comparison of GAAP to operating earnings for the quarter and year-to-date periods. GAAP earnings for the third quarter were $1.51 per share, compared to $1.49 per share in 2019. Gap earnings through September were $3.56 per share compared to $3.58 per share last year. There is a reconciliation of gap to operating earnings on pages 15 to 16 of the presentation. Let's turn to slide 7 and look at the drivers of quarterly operating earnings by segment. Operating earnings for the third quarter were $1.47 per share, or $728 million, compared to $1.46 per share, or $722 million, in 2019. Operating earnings for vertically integrated utilities were $0.85 per share, down $0.04. This was driven by unfavorable weather, primarily due to warmer than normal temperatures last year, particularly in September. Other drivers included lower wholesale load and other operating revenue, as well as higher depreciation and taxes, primarily due to timing that were reversed in the fourth quarter. Favorable items included lower O&M, favorable rate changes, and higher transmission revenue. The transmission and distribution utility segment earned $0.31 per share, up $0.04 from last year. Favorable items included higher rate changes and transmission revenue, as well as lower O&M. These favorable items were partially offset by unfavorable weather, depreciation, taxes, and interest expense. The AEP transmission holdco segment continued to grow, contributing $0.28 per share and improvement of $0.03. This reflected the return on investment growth as net plant increased by $1.5 billion, or 16% since September of last year. Generation in marketing produced operating earnings of 13 cents per share, down 3 cents from last year. This was driven by timing around income taxes and lower wholesale margins. Finally, corporate and other was up a penny from last year, primarily driven by lower taxes related to consolidating items that were reversed by year end. Let's turn to slide eight and review our year-to-date results. Operating earnings through September were $3.56 per share, or $1.77 billion, compared to $3.65 per share, or $1.8 billion in 2019. Looking at the drivers by segment, Operating earnings for vertically integrated utilities were $1.90 per share, comparable to last year. Favorable items in this segment included lower O&M, the impact of rate changes across multiple jurisdictions, and higher transmission revenue, primarily due to true-ups. Weather was unfavorable due to warmer than normal winter temperatures this year and a warmer summer in 2019. Other decreases included higher depreciation and tax expenses, primarily due to timing, and lower revenue items and AFUDC. The transmission and distribution utility segment earned 84 cents per share down a penny from last year. The negative variance was primarily driven by the 2019 reversal of a regulatory provision in Ohio. Other smaller drivers included higher depreciation and interest expense, the roll-off of legacy riders in Ohio, prior year Texas carrying charges, unfavorable weather, and tax expenses. These items were mostly offset by higher rate changes, the recovery of increased transmission investment in ERCOT, and the impact of the Ohio transmission true-up on both O&M and transmission revenue. Other O&M was also favorable due to the concerted effort to decrease O&M expenditures through one-time and sustainable reductions. The AEP transmission Holdco segment contributed $0.75 per share, down $0.07 from last year due to the impact of the annual true-up and prior-year FERC settlements. Our fundamental return on investment growth continued. Generation Marketing produced $0.31 per share, up a penny from last year. The renewables business grew with asset acquisitions more than offsetting lower wholesale and retail margins and timing around income taxes. Land sales and other one-time items offset the impact of weaker wholesale prices on the generating business. Finally, corporate and other was down two cents per share due to higher interest in taxes related to consolidating items that were reversed by the year end and offset by a prior year income tax adjustment. Partially offsetting these items was lower O&M. Overall, we are pleased with our financial results and are confident in confirming our annual operating earnings guidance of $4.25 to $4.45 per share. Turning to slide 9, let's review the assumptions we shared during the first quarter earnings call to reaffirm guidance. Starting with the top line, we recently updated our retail sales forecast. Third quarter sales came in higher than previously projected. We now expect 2020 normalized sales to come in 2.7% below last year, which is 7 tenths of a percent better than the load forecast from the first quarter. While the outlook has improved, it is still below the pre-recession forecast used for our original guidance. The favorable sales mix in 2020 has helped to mitigate the impact on earnings. The second item was the impact of weather. While the first quarter weather produced a significant drag, the second quarter and third quarter weather impacts were slightly favorable. In the second quarter presentation, we mentioned that July's weather was quite favorable. However, August and September weather was mild. As a result, we have revised the weather impact on 2020 earnings and now expect an eight-cent drag to 2020 results. The next item was on-track O&M expense. We had originally planned to drive O&M costs down to $2.8 billion from $3.1 billion in 2019. In response to the expected sales decline, we identified an additional $100 million of savings from both one-time and sustainable reductions that are on track to hit this lower expense target. Finally, we identified approximately $500 million of capital expenditures in the first quarter that could be shifted out of 2020 and into future years. We made this decision to support our cash position through the expected downturn during the pandemic. As we discussed at the second quarter earnings call, results have come in better than expected, and we have reinstated approximately $100 million of the $500 million back into 2020. Given the progress we have made on these key assumptions, we are able to reaffirm our 2020 operating earnings guidance range. Now let's turn to slide 10 to provide an update on our normalized load. Starting in the lower right corner, our third quarter normalized load was down 2.6%. This was slightly better than the forecast we shared with you in the first quarter. Through September, our normalized sales were down 3% from last year. In the upper left quadrant, our normalized residential sales increased by 3.8% in the quarter. Year-to-date residential sales were up 2.6%. We saw significant increases in our residential load at the beginning of the pandemic. The growth in residential sales has moderated as people return to work over the summer. Weather normalized residential sales are up across all jurisdictions. Moving clockwise, our normalized commercial sales decreased by 4.6% in the third quarter, bringing the year-to-date decline to 4.9%. As expected, the biggest declines in this class came from schools, churches, restaurants, and hotels. Finally, in the lower left chart, industrial sales decreased by 7.8% in the quarter, bringing the year-to-date decline to 7%. A number of factors have changed the outlook for this class, but the biggest driver is overall economic activity. The industrial sectors that posted the biggest declines for the quarter were mining, oil and gas extraction, and primary metals. By contrast, plastics and rubber manufacturing posted a strong quarter related to the recovery of the automotive industry. Overall, load growth across the service territory followed the pattern we anticipated earlier in the year. During the second quarter, residential sales peaked and commercial and industrial sales hit their lows. Since then, our service territory has been working its way back to more normalized levels. Because some businesses will continue to work remotely, we expect our residential sales to continue at higher levels for some time. Let's take a deeper look into why we raised our outlook for normalized load on slide 11. The solid bars represent weather normalized load growth by quarter in 2020. The green lines represent the updated load forecast we shared during the first quarter earnings call. At that time, there was still a lot of uncertainty regarding the depth and duration of the economic slowdown and how customers would respond. While that forecast accurately predicted the depth of the contraction in the second quarter, our third quarter results indicated a better recovery than forecasted. Our latest view anticipates a continuation of this trend, barring another shutdown of the economy. Now let's move on to 512 and review the company's capitalization and liquidity. Our debt-to-capital ratio remained unchanged in the third quarter and stands at 61.1%. Our FFO to debt ratio decreased 1.3% during the quarter to 12.8% on a Moody's basis, primarily due to timing of fuel recovery, storm cost deferrals, and a pension contribution. Importantly, we expect this metric to end the year in the low to mid-teens consistent with the guidance we have provided. Our liquidity position remains strong at $3.8 billion, supported by our revolving credit facility. Before providing an update on pension funding, I would like to discuss the plan to finance the North Central Wind project. As a reminder, we have stated that we intend to use equity to finance approximately two-thirds of this $2 billion project. We plan to issue equity in coordination with the completion of the three individual projects that comprise North Central Wind. For this reason, we will take a flexible approach which could include an at-the-market mechanism asset rotation, as well as traditional secondary offerings. This approach avoids unnecessary dilution and helps us deliver on the 5% to 7% earnings growth rate. Turning to our pension, I am pleased to report that funding increased 3.6% during the quarter to 97%, and our OPEB funding increased 5% to 141%. Strong equity returns was the primary driver for the increases. The pension plan also benefited from a company contribution in the amount of the plan's annual service cost of $111.5 million. Let's wrap this up on slide 13 so we can get to your questions. We are reaffirming our existing 2020 operating earnings guidance of $4.25 to $4.45 per share. Our message at EEI will be that we are leading the way forward as a premium regulated utility with an ESG focus, delivering 5% to 7% earnings growth with dividends growing in line with earnings. Our plan includes the $2 billion North Central Wind Project in Oklahoma, benefiting our customers in PSO and SWEPCO as we transition to a cleaner energy future. We will provide detailed drivers for 2021 earnings guidance by segment and updates to our capital expenditure and financing plans. We look forward to talking with many of you at the virtual EEI conference in a couple of weeks. One final item. In 2021, we will release 2020 fourth quarter and full year earnings in late February, coincident with the filing of the 2020 10-K, like we did last year. With that, I will turn the call over to the operator for your questions.

speaker
Operator
Conference Call Operator

Thank you. And once again, ladies and gentlemen, if you wish to ask a question, please press 1, then 0 on your telephone keypad. You may withdraw your question at any time by repeating the 1, 0 command. And if you're using a speakerphone, please pick up the handset before pressing the numbers. And again, if you have a question, you may press 1, then 0 at this time. And one moment for our first question. And we will go to Julian Dumoulin-Smith with Bank of America, Merrill Lynch. Please go ahead.

speaker
Julian Dumoulin-Smith
Analyst, Bank of America Merrill Lynch

Good morning, Julian. Good morning. Howdy. Thanks for the time, guys. Perhaps just to kick things off, you know, you talk about rolling out and reaffirming or perhaps preemptively reaffirming in the EEI of the 5-7. Can you talk a little bit about what's backstopping that? And specifically, in the last few months, we've seen some pretty substantial changes from some of your peers in Virginia and How can that play into APCO and perhaps also similarly in Indiana? Many of your peers have talked about opportunities. You all have perhaps Rockport. Just curious if you can talk about or perhaps foreshadow some of the conversations here on that roll port, if you don't mind, at the outset.

speaker
Brian Tierney
Chief Financial Officer

Julian, I think a lot of the things that we're going to talk about are renewable opportunities in addition to North Central Wind, how we're transitioning from you know, a carbon-based generating fleet, much more to a lot of the renewables that the Virginia Clean Energy Act enables and legislation in Indiana enables as well. So we're going to provide a lot more detail on that at EEI. take you through what that looks like.

speaker
Nick Akins
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer

You know, we do have the renewable requirement in Virginia. You mentioned APCO. We've got the requirement there. And also, Indiana and Michigan, we continue to do renewables in various areas there. We're also doing renewables. We just did Fort Sill in Oklahoma. And then we also have renewable applications here in Ohio that are brewing as well. So we'll have plenty to talk about. And I think, you know, we don't... span and that we should spend more talking about uh... uh... the opportunities we've got available to us for a renewable standpoint but the way i see it is that that uh... uh... you know we we're just on the precipice of of uh... a massive transformation to renewable resources and a t uh... uh... if you if you look at the runway uh... this is pretty substantial so i and i don't know continue particularly as we do individual relationships with customers, but also in terms of the regulated side as well through the integrated resource planning process. So we'll certainly talk more about that at November. Got it.

speaker
Julian Dumoulin-Smith
Analyst, Bank of America Merrill Lynch

Thanks for entertaining me there. Perhaps if I can get more detailed here, if you don't mind. I know you all provided a little bit more of a view on 23 here, but in tandem, You gave an updated view on FFO to total debt under Moody's definition of low to mid-teens versus perhaps prior characterizations of mid-teens. Is that simply a factor of rolling forward here, or how are you thinking about this at this point?

speaker
Brian Tierney
Chief Financial Officer

Julian, the low to mid-teens is completely consistent with our prior messaging on FFO to debt. And that outlook was incorporated in Moody's when they made their adjustment back in August.

speaker
Nick Akins
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer

And remember, that will continue to improve as some of this accumulated deferred income taxes that is being repaid to the regulatory jurisdictions are occurring much more quickly than we thought. I mean, we originally think in 10 years, and it turned out to be five years. And that's occurring more quickly. So that FFO debt metric will pick up as that rolls off. Got it. Excellent.

speaker
Operator
Conference Call Operator

Thank you. Our next question is from Dirgesh Chopra with Evercore ISI. Please go ahead.

speaker
Dirgesh Chopra
Analyst, Evercore ISI

Hey, good morning. Hi there. Good morning. Hey, good morning. Thanks. Great. Hey, just digging in a little bit into 2021, and I appreciate you'll share more color at DEI, but could you quantify for us what that 2%, 2.7%, Sales degradation was year-to-date, part one. And part two, should we assume some of that 51 million year-to-date O&M savings to be carried forward into the next year?

speaker
Brian Tierney
Chief Financial Officer

Let me start with the 2.7% load degradation. It's what you would expect. It's largely commercial and industrial sales decreases being offset by residential. What we've seen is it takes more than just looking at the raw numbers on residential, commercial, and industrial. It's really the mix. You remember we make more margin on residential sales than we do on commercial and industrial. And that mix has come in better than we had anticipated at the beginning of the pandemic. So it's not been as dire as what we thought it might be because of what's happened with the sales mix rather than just the overall decreases. So that's been positive. Looking forward on O&M, you know, we have for a number of years been tightening our belt and been very, very tight around untracked O&M in that $2.8 to $3.1 billion range. And with what we're doing with Achieving Excellence and everything else we're doing with sustainable and non-sustainable O&M cuts, I anticipate us being towards the lower end of that range going forward.

speaker
Nick Akins
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer

When we look at the... the load forecast, I mean, if you assume 2021 is going to be better, which we believe it is, and you look at that mix, We don't see residential. I mean, obviously, it'll moderate as the economy comes back on the industrial and commercial side, commercial in particular. But still, you're going to have a continued longstanding remnant of improved residential. support just by virtue of what companies have learned from the work-from-home environment. So I'm a little bit bullish on the load, at least a financial picture associated with the load. And then when you look at the O&M, this Achieving Excellence Program, I don't know. It has truly been a fundamental change for us, an augmentation of all the lean activities and other things that we did before, and it really is focused on a regular part of our budget process to ensure that we're capturing savings in every step along the way. So I'm feeling pretty good about the continual progress year on year of achieving excellence.

speaker
Dirgesh Chopra
Analyst, Evercore ISI

That's great, guys. Thanks. Thanks for that color. Maybe just, you know, initial thoughts. And I appreciate the devil is going to be in the details, but initial thoughts and elections, taxes, climate plan and implications for AP.

speaker
Nick Akins
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer

Yeah, so I guess, well, first of all, the election certainly is a noisy election cycle, and who knows what's going to happen here. We never know. But we've got 114 years' history of managing between the goalposts here, so we'll continue to do that. And our focus is on moving to that clean energy economy. So really the only difference, obviously, is maybe the pace at which the change will occur if there's a Biden administration change. versus Trump, but nevertheless, it doesn't change that much for us because we're focused on moving that clean energy economy as quickly as we can to ensure that we are making that transition into the future that we know it's going to happen. Now, who knows where technology will go, even for fossil fuels, but nevertheless, will continue that transition to renewables and certainly some natural gas to ensure that we are delivering for our customers in the future. So from a climate perspective, we have an excellent record. As a matter of fact, that's why we get... I've seen from the ESG community, they know what we're doing. They know what our message is. We're making continual progress, and we'll continue to make that progress. And then when you think about, as I said in my original write-up, I used the word latent because it is somewhat of an undeveloped or emerging activity around electrification of the economy. certainly around OEM and what we find with digitization and automation. And then, of course, as we move forward with the transformation, the generation transformation that we see ahead of us. So that's why I'm feeling pretty good about where this company is heading.

speaker
Brian Tierney
Chief Financial Officer

Just a quick update on taxes. If we were to have an increase in taxes, we anticipate that our commissions would handle it really one of two ways and not dissimilar to how they handled tax reform three or four years ago. We anticipate that they would either allow the increase to be deferred until the next rate proceeding, or we anticipate that they'd have kind of a one-issue order come out where they would allow us to adjust rates just to reflect the new expected higher income tax rate. In any event, we wouldn't expect it to be a significant driver

speaker
Dirgesh Chopra
Analyst, Evercore ISI

uh to earnings or cash for the company going forward right uh thanks but could be a modest deal with the cash flow like given sort of a reset in adit and um and amongst other things they could help if i voted yeah yeah again we we don't anticipate it to be significant one way or the other understood thanks brian thank you nick thank you yep

speaker
Operator
Conference Call Operator

Our next question is from James Thalacker with BMO Capital Markets. Please go ahead.

speaker
Nick Akins
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer

Good morning, James.

speaker
Operator
Conference Call Operator

Hello. James, is your line on mute possibly? Your line is open.

speaker
James Thalacker
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

Hey, thanks, guys. I apologize about that. There you are. Good morning. Good morning. Two real quick questions. You know, just first, I guess, Brian, just addressing, you know, North Central Wind. I noticed in the slides that Traverse looked like potentially the in-service could be pushed out maybe, you know, by a quarter or so. Could you talk a little bit about is that just a supply chain issue related to COVID or is it something else that was kind of driving that extended outlook?

speaker
Brian Tierney
Chief Financial Officer

Yeah, a lot of it has to do more so than – more so than actual physical things. It's our ability to get permitting and the like done. And so during the shutdown, it was hard to be able to get into the offices, do land acquisitions, title searches, and things like that. And that just pushed us, potentially pushed us back a bit, James. We're not anticipating anything material there. We still anticipate late this year to early next year, but just wanted to signal that due to some of those unanticipated issues largely associated with COVID, that that project could have a range of when it would come online.

speaker
Nick Akins
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer

Hey, James, we feel like it's still going to be the end of December, but obviously it could fall into that range in the first quarter. We're confident of that particular range. But remember, we're not making any progress payments either. It's sort of a we require it when it's done. So from a financial perspective, it's fine.

speaker
James Thalacker
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

Okay, great, thanks. And I guess just following up on that same issue, Brian, you talked about three sort of potential ways to finance the final acquisition of those, and this has been beaten to death. But as you guys look to give 2021 guidance, obviously an ATM would be something that would be kind of spread over the full year, but asset rotation or even block equity would be probably something I think as you were saying, sort of coordinating it with the final close would be something maybe closer to the end of the year. How are you guys, I guess, thinking about that from a modeling perspective as you present 2021?

speaker
Brian Tierney
Chief Financial Officer

You know, it kind of matches what Nick was saying, is that the projects don't... We don't get the projects until commercial completion is done. We then get the project, and given the discrete nature of them, we can really time the equity issuance very closely with when the project comes online. And... James, the reason we need that flexibility, you look at Sundance, which we're anticipating in the first quarter of 2020. That's about a $300 million project. We'll be able to time the equity issuance, if that's what it is, closely with when that project comes online. The next one, which we're anticipating at the end of 2021, is about a $400 million project, Maverick. And then the last one is Traverse, which is about $1.3 billion. And we talked about that being late 2021, early 2022. We believe that whether it's an at-the-market program, a follow-on issuance, or asset rotation, we're going to be able to time those very, very closely with when those discrete projects come online. So from a modeling standpoint, the timing that we're talking about really is going to be insignificant to 2021.

speaker
Nick Akins
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer

and um and it's just you know i'll start repeating myself it's significant to 2021. james bryan mentioned the options john bryan mentioned the options we're looking at and rest assured internally we're also being at the death so so um we'll we'll make sure that we're making the right decisions relative to uh the timing associated with those investments no no no worries i understand uh i understand the in-service space and it gives you guys a lot of flexibility

speaker
James Thalacker
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

The last question I guess I just had, and you kind of answered my initial question, was going back to the trailing 12-month FFO, it kind of dipped down. You guys are looking for that to sort of trend back into kind of where you guys were thinking sort of, you know, low to mid-teens, I guess. Are you still targeting that in the sort of, you know, 21, 22, 23 timeframe? I know you just updated your cash flow forecast for that recently.

speaker
Nick Akins
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer

Yeah, we are. It's that timeframe, yep.

speaker
James Thalacker
Analyst, BMO Capital Markets

Okay, perfect. Thank you so much for the time.

speaker
Operator
Conference Call Operator

Thanks, James. And next we'll go to Michael Lapidus with Goldman Sachs. Please go ahead.

speaker
Michael Lapidus
Analyst, Goldman Sachs

Hey, guys. Morning, Michael. Morning, Nick. Thank you guys for taking my question. And, Nick, sorry about your LSU Tigers. Yeah. Rock, man.

speaker
Nick Akins
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer

Yeah, Alabama's doing good, though. I'm sure you're happy with that. Yeah, let's hope Nick keeps coaching.

speaker
Michael Lapidus
Analyst, Goldman Sachs

I want to come back to tax a little bit and who the heck Uncle Sam's going to do in the next year or so regarding corporate tax rates. But if there's a change in administration, if there's a higher corporate tax rate, I think we've seen numbers floated around of 27 or 28 percent. I get that it's probably not much of an impact on the earning power one way or another for AP. But if you're talking to state commissioners or staff at the PSCs or PUCs or others, it is a rate increase on the customers. And it's a double whammy because the cost of service goes up due to the higher tax rate, and that just kind of flows through rates. But also the flowback of ad fits kind of slows down or declines. It just strikes me as a, if I'm a utility commissioner or a public policy maker in given states, you're asking for what could be pretty decent-sized rate increases on customers coming out of an economic downturn. How does that get offset? I think about it from a customer standpoint. What's the give-back?

speaker
Nick Akins
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer

Hey, I think there's no doubt that, you know, and again, I think, you know, There was a lot of advantage taken with the tax reductions that occurred. And you're right. There's no doubt that there will be headroom that is reduced because it is certainly going to be an impact to put those back in. Now, the question is how it's put back in over what time frame and that kind of thing. But also, that's why it's so important for us to move forward as quickly as possible and accelerate achieving excellence. so that we can mitigate that impact as much as possible. But still... You're looking at it in the face of a definite need for rehabilitation and continued capitalization of the grid to ensure that we have reliability and resiliency of supply, particularly dealing with hurricanes, wildfires, cyber, all those kinds of issues. We have to respond to that. So there will be rate increases associated with... with the implementation of new taxes. I think it's unavoidable, but certainly it's incumbent on us to make sure we mitigate that as much as possible with our Achieving Excellence program and other measures. And we'll have discussions with the commissions just like we had discussions when tax reform occurred. And, you know, it's unfortunate we didn't do it over a longer period of time like we had suggested because then it would mitigate even the return of taxes. And if we continue vacillating back and forth like this, That's going to be a continual issue for our industry that our regulators need to recognize. We do have to keep some reserve there to ensure that we're not moving customer rates around as much as could be if it becomes pretty volatile. So your points well recognized, but we'll do what we can to mitigate the effects, and we'll have those conversations. But I think one thing that's also come into play here, though, is the nature of the importance of the service that we provide. For everyone to be able to watch their Netflix or do all the things they need to do at home, work from home, All those types of activities will change the nature of how we look at residential supply. And there's no question that that's going to change going forward. And that's why I'm always troubled by commissions saying that AMR versus AMI, for example, the investments we want to make in AMI, it's not because AMI is, you don't just look at the cost of the meters of AMI and the undepreciated balance of the associated AMR. You've got to look at what you're leveraging into, and that's the customer's ability to to adjust to their own energy picture and be able to drive energy efficiency and all those things and give the customer the opportunity to do that as opposed to the system just deciding that for them. So I think there's just a lot of things we need to have discussions about. with our regulators to really focus on what that future actually means. And with electrification of the economy, that's clearly going to be an issue that we need to deal with to make sure our customers are more resilient, more reliable, and as economic as possible, but also give them the opportunity to make adjustments on their total bill as opposed to dealing on a headline on rate increases.

speaker
Michael Lapidus
Analyst, Goldman Sachs

Got it. Thank you for that, Nick. And then one other question, totally unrelated. I'm thinking about states where you've not really talked about sizable rate-based growth in investment. One of those that stands out a little bit is West Virginia. How do you think about going forward the pace of generation transformation in a state like West Virginia?

speaker
Nick Akins
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer

Yeah, I think, well, we're looking at all of our states now and all our state jurisdictions, and it's really sort of our resource planning on steroids, and even the dog likes it. And I think there's no question that we are in the process of moving forward with that transformation as quickly as possible. making significant T&D investments, and you see that based on the changes in capital. But then when you look at states like West Virginia, I think the first step is going to be how we run coal-fired capacity, for example. Will we have other forms of energy coming in and have lower capacity factors on coal units? But still, they'd be available at those times where you have severe cold weather or really warm weather in the summer. So it's the way we run these facilities during the interim, but then it's also that transition that we make going forward. I think that's true for all of the jurisdictions. And our jurisdictions have been fairly conservative in making that transition. I think that pace can quicken, though, as a result of even the bipartisan focus on continuing to lower emissions at our plant. So I think the catalysts are there. And actually, post-election, who knows what will happen, but I still see you're already seeing some Republican and Democrat democratic legislation that's being proposed that tries to answer that question. And if you have that from a national standpoint and the states are moving forward with their own resolutions, then we can be particularly helpful in ensuring that occurs as quickly as possible.

speaker
Michael Lapidus
Analyst, Goldman Sachs

Got it. Thank you, Nick. Sorry about the dog. My dog, Memphis, and I both appreciate it. Thanks, guys.

speaker
Nick Akins
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer

No, no, that's fine.

speaker
Operator
Conference Call Operator

Our next question is from the line of Sophie Karp with KeyBank. Please go ahead.

speaker
Sophie Karp
Analyst, KeyBank

Hi, good morning. Thank you for taking my question.

speaker
Nick Akins
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer

Yeah, sure thing. Good morning.

speaker
Sophie Karp
Analyst, KeyBank

I'm curious. I want to go back to kind of the load composition and the rate case activity. So as we move forward and the load dislocation, you know, continues to be, continues to persist where we have this unusual situation where residential maybe is higher, but CNI is suppressed and that's not really a normalized future. So as you go through your rate cases now and the future rate cases where this period becomes your test year, right, how do you address that? Do you attempt to normalize or do you just go with what the actual looked like? So that's my first question, I guess.

speaker
Nick Akins
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer

Yeah, so we have multiple utilities, right? So we have the opportunity to move around capital investment, to time it with relative rate case activity to ensure that we are spending on the right things at the right time. Not to say that we're trying to load the budgets or anything. What we're saying is that when we go through the rate case filings, it's important to not only have discussions with the commissions about what we're spending on, but what the results of that spending will be. So if a load is not increasing, obviously it exaggerates, it certainly challenges the rate impacts because the denominator is not growing. Now, if the denominator is growing, obviously that's helpful. But if it isn't, you're still having to make choices about what the priorities are for each regulatory jurisdiction based on discussions with the commissions to help us determine, okay, number one, what are we willing to pay for? Number two, what are those priorities that exist? And some of those are absolute priorities, and some of them are things that, yeah, we'd like to do, but it may be that we have to work out for a longer period of time before bringing that in. So there's all kinds of dialogue that occur relative to what that prioritization should be, and we'll continue doing that with our commissions. And we have done, whether the economy has gone well or whether the economy has been in a downturn. I think we're moving toward an upturn, so that's going to be helpful.

speaker
Brian Tierney
Chief Financial Officer

Sophie, we also have some jurisdictions that have forward-looking test years, so we'll be able to incorporate a forward-looking view. And then we have places like Ohio where residential and small commercial are already decoupled. There are lots of mitigants to unusual load circumstances that we find ourselves in right now.

speaker
Nick Akins
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer

And some of these things are known and reasonable adjustments, too. So you have to look at the 2020 test year and say, hey, we had to make these changes because of COVID, and COVID is going to be – sort of a unique circumstance. I mean, we had to react. And actually, the commissions themselves, we had moratoriums on customer cutoffs. So there's adjustments we all made in that process, and I think we'll make those adjustments coming out of that process as well.

speaker
Sophie Karp
Analyst, KeyBank

Right. Thank you. And then if I may, a quick follow-up on North Central Wind. You mentioned asset rotation, I guess, as a part of considerations for equity, part of finance in there. What might those be? Is this more of a runoff situation with certain assets in your portfolio, or could we be looking at something more strategic here? Thank you.

speaker
Nick Akins
Chairman, President and Chief Executive Officer

Well, so when we talk about potential assets, you know, we look at everything, and we look at sources and uses, and obviously we want the use part of it right now is how do we finance North Central when a major project, and the sources can be anything on our uh... in our portfolio and that's where portfolio management to be a key part of what we do in the future uh... i'm not gonna say you know specifically uh... uh... what were what were uh... looking at uh... or or anything like that at this point but what i will say is that that that uh... It's incumbent on us to be looking at everything from a source perspective and then focusing on how we deploy capital in the best way and transfer that into really projects like North Central and be able to fund it in the best way to ensure our shareholder value. And we'll continue to do that. So I think you sort of have to let the year play out.

speaker
Sophie Karp
Analyst, KeyBank

Thank you. Yep.

speaker
Operator
Conference Call Operator

And with no further questions, I'll turn it back to you. Great.

speaker
Darcy Reese
Managing Director, Investor Relations

Thank you for joining us on today's call. As always, the IR team will be available to answer any questions you have. John, please give the replay information.

speaker
Operator
Conference Call Operator

Certainly. And ladies and gentlemen, this conference is available for replay. It starts today, October 22nd at 1130 a.m. Eastern Time. It will last until October 29th at midnight. You may access the replay at any time by dialing 866- 207-1041 or 402-970-0847. The access code is 822-2465. Those numbers again, 866-207-1041 or 402-970-0847. Access code 822-2465. That does conclude your conference for today. We thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect.

Disclaimer

This conference call transcript was computer generated and almost certianly contains errors. This transcript is provided for information purposes only.EarningsCall, LLC makes no representation about the accuracy of the aforementioned transcript, and you are cautioned not to place undue reliance on the information provided by the transcript.

-

-