Credit Acceptance Corporation

Good day, everyone, and welcome to the Credit Acceptance Corporation third quarter 2025 earnings call. A webcast recording and transcript of today's earnings call will be made available on Credit Acceptance's website. At this time, I would like to turn the call over to Credit Acceptance Chief Financial Officer Jay Martin.

Thank you. Good afternoon, and welcome to the Credit Acceptance Corporation third quarter 2025 earnings call. As you read our news release posted on the investor relations section of our website at ir.creditacceptance.com, and as you listen to this conference call, please recognize that both contain forward-looking statements within the meaning of federal securities law. These forward-looking statements are subject to a number of risks and uncertainties, many of which are beyond our control and which could cause actual results to differ materially from such statements. These risks and uncertainties include those spelled out in the cautionary statement regarding forward-looking information included in the news release. Consider all forward-looking statements in light of those and other risks and uncertainties. Additionally, I should mention that to comply with the SEC's Regulation G, please refer to the Financial Results section of our news release, which provides tables showing how non-GAAP measures reconcile to GAAP measures. This time, I'll turn the call over to our Chief Executive Officer, Ken Booth, to discuss our third quarter results.

Thanks, Jay. Our results for this quarter reflected steady execution with declines in loan performance and year-over-year originations volume balanced by a portfolio that remains at a record high. Loan performance declined this quarter with our 2022, 2023, and 2024 vintages underperforming our expectations and our 2025 vintage exceeding our expectations. while our other vintages were stable during the quarter. Overall, forecasted net cash flows declined by 0.5% or $59 million. During the quarter, we experienced a decline in unit and dollar volumes, though our loan portfolio remained at its record high of $9.1 billion on an adjusted basis, up 2% from last Q3. Our market share in our core segment of used vehicles financed by subprime consumers was 5.1%, for the first eight months of the year, down from 6.5% from the same period in 2024. Our unit volume was impacted by our third quarter 2024 scorecard change that has resulted in lower advance rates and is also likely impacted by increased competition. Beyond these two key drivers, We continue making progress during the quarter towards our mission of maximizing intrinsic value and positively changing the lives of our five key constituents, dealers, consumers, team members, investors, and the communities we operate in. We do this by providing a valuable product that enables dealers to sell vehicles to consumers regardless of their credit history. This allows dealers to make incremental sales to the 55% of adults with other than prime credit. For these adults, it enables them to obtain a vehicle to get to their jobs, take their kids to school, etc. It also gives them the opportunity to improve or build their credit. Our customers are people like Becky, a single mother who has faced significant financial challenges. Her career as a chef meant that her hours and her paycheck were unpredictable. Between this and needing frequent car repairs, she was living paycheck to paycheck and struggling with poor credit after falling behind on her bills. Determined to turn things around, she was eventually able to finance a dependable vehicle through credit acceptance, which gave her stability and relief despite continuing to face financial hurdles. Credit acceptance worked with Becky to come up with a realistic payment plan and provide her the flexibility she needed to get back on track. Becky hopes to be able to purchase a home in the near future and urges others with similar struggles to look to credit acceptance. During the quarter, we financed almost 80,000 contracts for our dealers and consumers. We collected $1.4 billion overall, we paid $52 million in dealer holdback, and accelerated dealer holdback to our dealers. We enrolled over 1,300 new dealers and had 10,180 active dealers during the quarter. We continue to invest in our engineering team, which is focused on modernizing both our key technology architecture and how our teams perform work. The engineering team has made significant strides in modernizing our loan origination system. This modernization has laid a strong foundation for innovation, frictionless dealer experiences, and we've increased the speed that we deliver enhancements to our dealers by almost 70% compared to a year ago. This allows us to innovate faster and accelerate value to our business and customers. During the quarter, we received four awards for our amazing workplace, including being named one of the best workplaces in financial services and insurance by The Great Place to Work and Fortune Magazine for the 11th year in a row. We're proud to be one of the few companies in our industry that offers remote-first work. We work hard to ensure that every team member feels supported and connected, keeping our culture strong. In July, team members from around the country gathered in Detroit to celebrate the company's 53rd anniversary. During this celebration, we recognized eight of our team members, each of whom had been with the company for more than 30 years. Additionally, on a personal note, this will be my last quarterly earnings call. After starting my career over 34 years ago, including the last 22 years at Credit Acceptance, I've decided to retire and embark on the next chapter of my life. My decision wasn't easy. I will miss working with our amazing team members, and I'm so proud of everything we've accomplished together. But I believe the company is in a great position for the future. During his four-and-a-half-year tenure on the board, Linayak has been an invaluable partner as he modernized our approach to the business. His strong mix of experience in technology, marketing, engineering, and product along with a proven track record of driving transformation and growth, will be an excellent complement to our experienced management team. I look forward to both working alongside Vinayak as he transitions into his new role and continuing to serve the company as a board member going forward. At this time, Jay Martin and I will take your questions, along with Andrew Rostemi, our Chief Product and Marketing Officer, Jay Brinkley, our Senior Vice President and Treasurer, and Jeff Soutar, our Vice President and Assistant Treasurer.

To ask a question, please press star 11 on your telephone and wait for your name to be announced. To withdraw your question, please press star 11 again. Please stand by while we compile the Q&A roster. Our first question comes from John Rowan with Jannie Montgomery Scott. Your line is open.

Good afternoon, guys. Your asset-backed securities used to have a covenant in them that said if there was a 10% forecast shortfall that would enter into early amortization. Does the current ABS still have that? And are you close on any of those? I mean, just looking at the 2022 vintage, it's down 8% relative to the initial forecast. Is that the right way to look at it? Just walk us through kind of the ABS forecast.

Yeah, absolutely. We still have that covenant in both our warehouse facilities and our ABS securitization debt. As you know our business well with the pooling concept, we tend to contribute loans to a securitization for our portfolio program. A lot of which are uncapped, so as additional loans are originated, they belong to the securitization. So if you were to look at the actual performance from a collection rate standpoint, they tend to run above 100%. So we have no outstanding securitizations that are close to the 90% trigger. Okay.

And then G&A was still higher than I expected. Obviously, last quarter you had a contingent loss in there. but it didn't go back to the run rate to prior quarters. Can you give us an idea if there's any kind of one-time items in the $36 million G&A expense?

Yeah, I would suggest that you look at the adjusted results. We've used that to eliminate the one-time charges related to the contingent losses. So I think if you look at that, you'll see GNA is fairly consistent the last several quarters as a percentage of average capital. But you're right, if you're looking at just the gap, we had a $23.4 million contingent loss in Q2, and we had an additional $15 million contingent loss this quarter. Okay.

Can you let us know where your repurchase authorization is?

Yep, we've got just over 2 million shares currently under the board authorization.

Okay, and then just last question for you. I was a little bit surprised to see the advance rate was actually up a little bit in the quarter relative to the first half of the year, but unit volume still continues to decline. Obviously, the advance rate's not back to where it was, but can you just talk us through that a little bit? Are you still having trouble, competitively speaking, even at a higher advance rate?

Yeah, I think it's really a little bit of a change in mix in our business. I think there's a higher percentage of purchase loans, and I also think there's a higher percentage of our product that is designed for people with a little bit better credit, and those tend to have higher advance rates. Okay. All right. Thank you.

Thank you. Our next question comes from Robert Wildhat with Autonomous Research. Your line is open.

Hi, guys. Are you seeing any of your peers pull back at all in the industry? I just would love to get sort of the boots on the ground view of what's happening at the industry level in the wake of some of the headlines we've seen around subprime auto in the last couple of weeks.

Yeah, I think overall there have been some that have had struggles and have pulled back. In general, the environment's very competitive right now, so we're seeing a lot of competition out there. I mean, you can look at our volume per dealer and it's down and it's a competitive market.

Why do you think the competitive intensity hasn't really reacted to like the poor credit results that we've seen for the last few vintages? I would have expected people to pull back a little bit more with the delinquencies and losses as high as they are.

You know, it's always hard to tell what our competitors are doing. You know, the market's fragmented. But oftentimes, at the beginning of downturns, it is a competitive environment. We've lived through this before. 2021 was super competitive, and those vintages ultimately didn't turn out very well. 2016, 2007. So there have been times where it's been like this. But I will say, this has been a long time where it's been competitive, and we're seeing underperformance. I will say, you know, we build our business for the long run. Our goal is always to, you know, have a large margin of safety in the aggregate in our pricing. And, you know, we're at a point where our loan portfolio is kind of at the highest it's been. And, you know, we'd rather do less volume at solid margins than do, you know, chase volume. So that's where we're at on that.

Okay. And then just quickly, we noticed that attrition had been increasing in the last few quarters. I mean, could you comment on some of the drivers there? Is there a chance that dealers are pushing back on the scorecard change or anything like that?

I mean, a little bit it could be. The way we measure attrition is that they've done a deal on the period shown. And, you know, given that we've got, you know, our lower volume, we've got some dealers that just aren't doing business with us right now. So... I'm sure a little bit that's the scorecard, but it's also our scorecard relative to what everybody else is doing And like I said before it's a large fragmented markets. There's lots of different options out there Yeah, I would point out though that well, you know, it's been a challenging year for growth for the credit acceptance We're coming off our record year last year and this will still end up probably and we're kind of trending towards it being our fifth best year ever so it's not like We've gone super, super far backwards, but we've got tough comparables.

Yep. Okay. Thank you.

Thank you. As a reminder, to ask a question, please press star 1-1 on your telephone. Again, that is star 1-1 to ask a question. Our next question comes from Ryan Shelley with Bank of America. Your line is open.

Hey, guys. Thanks for the question. I wanted to ask around the impact of tariffs. I mean, obviously, you know, it's kind of on again, off again. But have you guys seen any, you know, profound impacts, whether it's in the marketplace or to your own business, from federal policy? And just going into next year, how do you guys kind of handicap that? Thanks.

Anything that impacts affordability for our consumer, is a negative for us generally you know our consumer already has affordability issues and anything that tends to impact affordability uh will be a negative you know it's hard to say how much the tariffs are impacting things they seem like they they change quite a bit um but anything that puts pressure on our consumers from an affordability standpoint ultimately is generally not good for us and good for people you know in our industry

Got it. Thanks. And then just one more, if I could, on the scorecard change. Forgive me if you've already clarified this, but going forward, is there a potential for any loosening or change back, you know, maybe come next year or the year after, or is that a permanent change going forward?

You know, we always try to price to maximize the amount of economic profit we originate. So we consider recent trends in loan performance and capital market conditions. We adjust our scorecard and our pricing based upon what we think we're going to collect and how we think we can maximize that economic profit originated. So I don't know what the future will hold, but it's not like this is probably the permanent scorecard from now until the end of time. As the situation changes, we make updates to it. Again, we always try to maximize economic profit originated.

Got it. Thanks for the questions.

Thank you. Our next question comes from Moshe Orenblatt with TD Cowan. Your line is open.

Great. Thanks. Maybe just to talk as you come back a little bit to the volume story and market share because I guess, do you attribute it to, you know, supply of vehicles being down? Or are you just, are there cars being sold and just some competitor is financing them? Because, I mean, you know, you fully, by October, you fully anniversary the, you know, the scorecard change and still down double digit, maybe not as much as in Q3, but still down pretty hard. Anyway, kind of any way to think about that?

Your question's a great one. I mean, we are, I would say, anniversary down the scorecard change for sure by October. I mean, while it happened in Q3, there's a little bit of a lag, but by October, it's more apples to apples. You know, I will say that Q4 last year was one of our better quarters. It was second best Q4 in the history of the company. So it's still a little bit of a tougher comparable, but You're right, you wouldn't have expected it to be down as much as it is other than the fact that, you know, the intensity of the competitive environment is probably higher. I do think, as you mentioned, affordability of vehicles has been a detriment to us. You know, our consumers are challenged by prices and they kind of get squeezed out. If you were to look at the size of the subprime market, you know, it has declined over the last four or five years. It seems like it's kind of stabilized somewhat right now. But our consumer has a lot of pressure on them in order to try to make purchases, which I think is impacting us negatively because we tend to be a little bit deeper in the subprime space than some other companies.

Got it. I guess from the competitive standpoint, because the other aspect that's been an issue this year in the last three quarters has been the fact that your prepays have slowed significantly. I mean, you've still got a full quarter of the 22 vintage still on the books, right, at the end of September. Wouldn't it stand to reason that if competition were higher, there would be somewhat more prepays, not less? Can you say the question again?

I didn't quite understand what you had. Sure.

Yeah, I mean, one of the phenomena that you've observed this year has been that, you know, that You know, the loans are staying on the books longer. I think you had said, you know, in the second quarter call that that was an issue that that there was just fewer people were able to either refinance or trade into another vehicle. I guess wouldn't a competitive environment be easier to do that as opposed to harder?

Yeah, I think generally, over time, what you've seen is sort of a lag effect of when competition heats up, prepays tend to speed up because obligors have other options. And I think what you're pointing out here, Moshe, is that we're not really seeing that It's tough to say. There is always a natural lag. I just think we're in a unique environment right now. Got it. In terms of your leverage... If history holds true... I was just going to say, if history holds true, then we should see prepays tick up if competition continues. Got it.

Maybe could you... This, you know, that $15 million contingent loss that you talked about, I guess it said it related to previously disclosed legal matters, but I guess the dollars are coming because you're making settlement offers in the lawsuit, right? I mean, that's what it says in the 10-Q, which I think is the first mention of that. You know, is there any way you know, for us to kind of think about whether there are other terms that we should be aware of that might be part of that settlement.

You're correct. This is the first time that we've mentioned that. I would tell you since it is an ongoing legal matter, though, we can't comment beyond the disclosures we've included in the 10Q and the earnings release. We can't provide any more detail than what's out there.

Gotcha. I appreciate that. And then just last one for me, maybe just talk about your your leverage and your, you know, kind of outlook given, you know, what you're seeing both from a growth and, you know, and how that impacts your thoughts on share repurchase.

Yeah, our current leverage on an adjusted basis is at the high end of that historical range. We've tended to operate in that two to three times adjusted debt to equity range. As we've talked about, you know, all else equal, you know, we tend to generally repurchase more shares when our leverage or growth rates are lower. I would also say that our leverage is modest relative to other industry participants. So I don't think there's – I would tell you there hasn't been a wholesale change in how we view the leverage on our balance sheet, but as we think about repurchasing shares, leverage is certainly a key aspect of that dialogue. Got it. Thank you.

Thank you. Our next question comes from Kyle Joseph with Stevens. Your line is open.

Hey, good afternoon. Thanks for taking my questions. Just wanted to get an update from you guys on kind of capital markets activity, you know, given things that have gone on in the auto space and just want to get a sense for what credit markets are doing. Are they really, you know, differentiating between quality operators and whatnot and kind of the investor appetite in the fixed income market?

Sure. Yeah, happy to take that one. You know, it's generally been a fairly favorable environment for ABS issuers this year. And I'd say ABS issuers, those of our peers, including ourselves in the subprime auto ABS market, where aside really from a couple of weeks around Liberation Day, where everything's everything kind of froze, spreads have been pretty tight. I will note that in recent weeks, we have seen some widening in spreads, really on the back of the Tricolor bankruptcy, but that's mostly been deeper in the capital structure than where we issue. We actually have an ABS deal on the market right now. We began marketing this morning and we're seeing a lot of demand at, levels that I think you'll see comparable to our recent deals. So feel good about our access there. And we'll just point out as well that we think we're pretty well positioned regardless with the amount of liquidity that we keep on the books. So right now, as of quarter end, we have $1.6 billion of unused availability on our revolving credit facilities.

Very helpful. I appreciate the update. Thank you.

Thank you. With no further questions in the queue, I would like to turn the conference back over to Mr. Martin for any additional or closing remarks.

We would like to thank everyone for their support and for joining us on the conference call today. If you have any additional follow-up questions, please direct them to our investor relations mailbox at ir at creditacceptance.com. We look forward to talking to you again next quarter. Thank you.

Once again, this does conclude today's conference. We thank you for your participation.