This conference call transcript was computer generated and almost certianly contains errors. This transcript is provided for information purposes only.EarningsCall, LLC makes no representation about the accuracy of the aforementioned transcript, and you are cautioned not to place undue reliance on the information provided by the transcript.
spk03: Thank you for standing by, and welcome to First Dib's second quarter 2021 earnings conference call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. After the speaker presentation, there will be a question and answer session. To ask a question during the session, you will need to press star 1 on your touchtone telephone. Please be advised that today's conference may be recorded. Should you require any further assistance, please press star 0. I would now like to hand the conference over to your host, Head of Investor Relations, Kevin LaBuz.
spk02: Good evening, and welcome to First Ibs Earnings Call for the quarter ended June 30th, 2021. I'm Kevin LaBuz, Head of Investor Relations. Joining me today are CEO David Rosenblatt and CFO Tu Quyen. David will provide an update on our business, including our strategy and our growth opportunities. And two, we'll review our second quarter financial results and third quarter outlook. This call will be available via webcast on our investor relations website at investors.firstdibs.com. Before we begin, please keep in mind that our remarks include forward-looking statements, including, but not limited to, statements regarding guidance and future financial performance, market demand, growth prospects, and business plans. Our actual results may differ materially. Forward-looking statements involve risk and uncertainties, which are described in our SEC filings. Any forward-looking statements that we make on this call are based on our beliefs and assumptions as of today, and we disclaim any obligation to update them. During the call, we'll present GAAP and non-GAAP financial measures. A reconciliation of non-GAAP to GAAP measures is included in today's earnings press release, which you can find in our investor relations website, along with the replay of this call. I'll now turn the call over to our CEO, David Rosenblatt.
spk04: David? Thanks, Kevin. Good evening, and thank you for joining us for our first earnings call as a public company. Before we begin, I'd like to thank our wonderful sellers, buyers, and employees for helping to make First Dibs a leading marketplace for connecting design lovers with highly coveted sellers and makers of vintage, antique, and contemporary furniture, home decor, art, jewelry, watches, and fashion. I'd also like to thank our public and private investors for their support. Since many of you are new to our story, before discussing second quarter highlights, I'll touch briefly on our history and our strategy. First Dibs was founded in 2000 to bring the magic of the Paris flea market online. Today, we're a classic two-sided marketplace with over 4,200 highly vetted sellers globally. Our sellers are small businesses, makers, and artisans. Our buyers are both consumers and professional buyers, interior designers and architects. Our mission is to enrich lives with extraordinary design. Over the past 21 years, we've built a reputation for helping collectors, design lovers, and interior designers alike discover beautifully designed one-of-a-kind items. We operate in a $129 billion market, which is in the early stages of online adoption. We're excited about the opportunity ahead of us. In addition to the continued secular shift to digital, we have numerous growth levers we are investing in. Luxury design lovers are everywhere, but luxury design isn't. Before First Dibs, if you didn't live in a design center like New York, Paris, or Milan, much of our supply would be inaccessible. For buyers, First Dibs eliminates the constraints of geography, unlocking unique global supply and making luxury design more accessible. For example, Last year, the average distance between buyers and sellers on confirmed orders was nearly 2,500 miles. Similarly, we provide sellers with access to a global community of well-qualified buyers and a platform to facilitate e-commerce at scale. Trust is the foundation of our marketplace and our most valuable asset, enabling highly considered purchases. For example, in the second quarter, a seller based in Rome, sold a 7.2-carat diamond ring for over $250,000 through our platform to a private client buyer in the state of Georgia. While we have earned the trust to sell rare and valuable items at high price points online, the majority of our listings are within reach of the mass affluent buyer. In 2020, our average order value was $2,500,000, but our median order value was $1,200. This trust, backed by the first DIBS promise, our comprehensive buyer protection program, enables us to expand our marketplace and our TAM. There have been two important business model transitions since our founding. First, in 2016, we shifted from a listings-based model in which all communication between buyer and seller was up to and including the transaction itself, occurred off-platform to a full e-commerce model where both communication and orders occur on-platform. This aligned our incentives with our sellers and buyers and better matched our revenue growth to our GMV growth. Second, we expanded beyond vintage and antique furniture, our initial category, to art, jewelry, fashion, and new and custom furniture. In the second quarter, About 50% of our new buyer orders came from new categories. This morning, we added our latest vertical, NFTs, which I'll touch on below. In 2020, our focus shifted from business model transition and vertical expansion to managing through COVID and supporting our sellers in that difficult period. We enter the second half of 2021 as a well-capitalized public company focused on growth. We have more growth initiatives in process and on the roadmap than at any point in our history, and we believe that each major initiative represents a non-incremental GMV opportunity. For example, this morning we launched our NFT platform, which we launched as a blockchain-native auction. Initially, the platform will feature bi-monthly exhibitions. The debut collection, titled Portals, is a series of work featuring 11 recognized digital artists curated by the notable artist Metageist. We believe that the blockchain in general, and NFTs in particular, are a game-changing technology for the art world, that digital art will become a significant market in its own right, and that the trust we've gained with consumers and artists places NFTs squarely within our right to win. Our NFT launch illustrates the extensibility of the technology platform and capabilities that we have spent the last 10 years building. Our tech platform and associated commercial capabilities enable us to unlock potentially large GMV opportunities in a capital-efficient manner. In this case, we were able to conceptualize the NFT opportunity, build the capability, and launch within a short amount of time with an investment of less than $1 million to date. We're still in the early stages of realizing our market opportunity. The NFT platform is the first of several new initiatives we plan to launch over the next year. Another example is international expansion and product localization, a strategic priority of ours. While there is significant international demand for our listings, our product is currently only available in English. In 2020, 19% of our buyers and 33% of our traffic came from outside the US, despite the fact that we do no local language marketing. Additionally, our conversion rate from international buyers was about half that of US buyers. In addition to vertical expansion and international growth, we see opportunities to grow our buyer base by testing and scaling into new paid marketing channels, improving buyer engagement through product optimizations, introducing new purchase formats, encouraging cross-vertical buying and growing supply. Turning to second quarter initiatives, we continued to expand our marketing channels. For example, in early May, we launched a partnership with American Express for their Centurion Black Card members. We worked with American Express to develop a comprehensive integrated marketing campaign, and the partnership was successful in attracting new, potentially high lifetime value buyers. Additionally, we continue to ramp programmatic prospecting, which we began testing in December 2020 and started testing connected video in July. We also continue to enhance our product. For example, we launched an iPad app in May, improved our jewelry shopping experience by adding structured data like ring size, lab reports, and customization, and continue to add item videos to product pages. In the second quarter, About 20% of our new jewelry listings included a video. Alongside product, we are focused on scaling sales and service. For example, in April, we ramped up a chat customer support feature, allowing us to respond to inquiries from this channel in a matter of seconds, improving customer satisfaction. Today, over 20% of our inbound support volume is chat. Lastly, we continued scaling our facilitated shipping program and in May launched sea freight as a new shipping option. For orders between Europe and the U.S., the sea freight option is 38% cheaper on average versus air. Two, our CFO is going to walk through second quarter numbers in more detail, but I'll quickly share some context and highlights. Overall, Q2 was a very healthy quarter for demand. GMV grew 34% year-over-year and revenue grew 29% year-over-year. Additionally, our two-year stacked GMV growth rate, which normalizes the COVID impact, remained strong at 48%. We closed the second quarter with roughly 69,000 active buyers, 50% higher than where we ended 2019. 2020 was a record year for new buyer acquisition. we now have relationships with these buyers that we plan to grow over time. Last year, as we know, COVID-19 brought on a period of rapid behavior change, which we began to lap in the second quarter. The reopening of the economy has very different impacts on our two primary customer segments. Interior designers were negatively impacted by COVID-related restrictions last year. Now, as the economy reopens, they're busier than ever. Trade GMV growth in the second quarter benefited from continued strength in the real estate market and new and resuming projects. June trade GMV hit an all-time monthly record. While trade GMV grew throughout the quarter, consumer GMV growth slowed, particularly in June. We believe this consumer trend was largely macro-driven as vaccinations became readily available and the economy reopened. Nevertheless, our two-year stack for consumer GMV was a healthy 55%. As we lapped the pandemic-related lockdowns and the associated rapid change in consumer behavior, our fundamentals remained strong and our long-term thesis is unchanged. Looking at the entire business, gross margins expanded and AOV and conversion rates increased year over year. Cohort behavior was stable. Encouragingly, buyers who made their first purchase between May and July of 2020 continue to have higher engagement and purchase frequency than our pre-COVID cohorts. Post-pandemic, we expect consumer buyers to drive the majority of our growth due to the relative size of the consumer market as compared to the professional market, as well as the fact that all of our verticals are available to consumers, while naturally, trade buyers only buy in the furniture and art verticals. As we look to the future, it is important to remember that not only are we still early in the online adoption curve of our industry, but we are early in the development of our own company. Despite the fact that we have a 21-year-old brand, the First Dibs business model is just five years old. and I believe that we will see as much change over the next five years as we have seen in the prior five. I'll now turn it over to Tu to discuss second quarter financial results and outlook.
spk01: Thanks, David. Good evening, everyone. The IPO is a major milestone for the company, and I am proud of the First Stips team for staying focused and delivering strong results during the second quarter, which I will review along with providing a third quarter outlook. Second quarter GMV was $107 million, up 34% year-over-year, with traffic, conversion, and average order value all increasing year-on-year. On a two-year stack, GMV growth was 48%. New buyer conversion continues to rise year-over-year, and average order value benefited from the rebound in trade. We are hearing that the trade has never been busier. Designers are benefiting from home sales and renovations. And as David mentioned, June trade GMV hit an all-time high. Consumer GMV growth slowed relative to the first quarter, particularly in June, as biotraffic growth slowed. While reopenings could impact near-term consumer behavior, our fundamentals are strong and we are confident in our long-term opportunity. On a two-year stack, consumer GMV growth was 55% and trade GMV growth was 43%. Please note that when we reference trade GMV or consumer GMV, we are speaking of the subsets of on-platform GMV attributable to each of these buyer groups. From a vertical perspective, fashion and new and custom furniture led growth, with fashion GMV growth accelerating. Buyers who shopped in two or more verticals continue to make up a growing percentage of our GMV mix. Our newer verticals, which we defined as art, jewelry, and new and custom furniture, represented 46% of our on-platform GMV. These verticals allow us to reach a wider audience with about 50% of new buyer orders in the second quarter coming from newer verticals. We see a long runway here and expect these verticals to account for the majority of our GMV looking ahead. Turning to marketplace metrics. There were nearly 69,000 active buyers in the second quarter, representing growth of 39% year-over-year. As a reminder, active buyers is a trailing 12-month metric. Order volume grew 28%, and AOV increased 6% year-over-year, driven by trade buyers. Total net revenue of $24.7 million grew 29% year-over-year, driven by GMV growth. As David mentioned earlier, in 2016, we transitioned to a full e-commerce model. Today, we generate the majority of our net revenue from seller marketplace services, which consists of transactions, subscriptions, and listings. Of these, transactions is the largest, accounting for about 70% of total net revenue. Growing GNV is our priority. As the marketplace expands, we expect revenue growth to approximate GMV growth. Additionally, we expect transactions revenue to account for a higher percentage of our net revenue over time. We've seen many opportunities to grow the First Dibs marketplace and cement our leadership position in online luxury design. As such, we are prioritizing investments in growing GMV in a disciplined manner. Given our asset-light business model, we expect to leverage our fixed cost base over time. Gross profit was $17.4 million, up 33% year-over-year, and gross profit margin was 70.4%, up from 68.2% a year ago. This margin improvement was driven by operational efficiency gains and lower depreciation. As a reminder, we account for all of our operations team's headcount costs in our cost of revenues. Sales and marketing expenses were $11.2 million, up 32% year-over-year, driven primarily by growth in performance marketing spend. In the second quarter, we launched a partnership with American Express Centurion Black Card members and continued to test and optimize our performance marketing efforts. For example, in June, we ramped the programmatic prospecting campaigns that we started testing in late 2020, and in July, we began testing connected video. We are in the early stages of developing our performance marketing capabilities and plan to accelerate our testing effort to identify new channels for growth. New bioacquisition and new vertical growth are priorities for the second half of the year. Sales and marketing as a percentage of revenue was 46% compared to 45% a year ago. As a reminder, in the second quarter of 2020, we pulled back on performance marketing activity due to COVID-19 disruptions. Technology and development expenses were $4.5 million, up 11% year-over-year. We continually enhanced our buyer and seller experience. For example, adding ring-sized filters and lab reports to jewelry. and launching an iPad app this quarter. In the second half of 2021, we'll be focused on optimizing the existing funnel, new bioactivation, and beginning product localization for international expansion. As a percentage of revenue, technology and development was 18% this quarter compared to 21% a year ago. Over the past decade, we have developed our core tech platform. Going forward, we will continue to build upon this platform by adding more personalization, increasing search relevancy, expanding purchase formats, and supporting new verticals. GNA expenses were $4.7 million, up 62% year-over-year. GNA expenses were 19% of revenue in the second quarter, up from 15% a year ago. The increase was driven by public company expenses, including D&O insurance and headcount costs. Lastly, provisions for transaction losses were $1.5 million, up 67% year-over-year, driven primarily by GMV growth and timing of losses. Provisions for transaction loss were 6% of revenue versus 5% a year ago. Adjusted EBITDA loss was $3 million compared to $2 million in the year-ago period. and adjusted EBITDA margin loss was 12.3% compared to 10.7% last year. While we expanded gross margin in the second quarter, we saw operating expenses as a percentage of revenue increase, driven by GNA, sales and marketing, and loss provision. Our adjusted EBITDA reflects continued investment in the growth opportunities we see ahead. With an asset-light business model and highly variable cost structure, Our near-term focus is investing in GMV growth in a disciplined manner. Over time, as we grow GMV and revenue, we expect to generate operating leverage and expand adjusted EBITDA margins. Moving on to the balance sheet, We ended the second quarter with a strong position of $176.1 million in cash and cash equivalents, including the IPO proceeds of $123 million. Now turning to our outlook, given the changing macroeconomic and public health conditions, we are only providing guidance for the third quarter at this time. We forecast third quarter GNV of $100 million to $104 million, equating to year-over-year growth between 15% and 19%. and a two-year stack of approximately 47% to 51%. Net revenue of 23.6 million to 24.3 million, equating to year-over-year growth between 13% and 16%, and a two-year stack of approximately 34% to 37%. Adjusted EBITDA margin loss of 21% to 18%. Given near-term uncertainties around COVID-19 and consumer behavior, we'd like to share some additional color on the assumptions underlying our third quarter guidance. We are assuming consumer GMV growth is stable at the levels we saw exiting June. Trade GMV year-over-year growth moderates relative to the second quarter but remains healthy, and no material GMV contribution from NFTs. While we are not providing guidance beyond the third quarter, We note that tougher year-over-year GMV growth comparisons will continue through the first quarter of 2022. We also note different recovery dynamics between consumer and trade buyers. While our consumer GMV growth started to improve in the second quarter of 2020, trade GMV growth didn't recover until the first quarter of 2021, as pandemic-related restrictions eased. We are excited about our future opportunities, including growing our new verticals, launching in adjacent categories like NFTs, expanding internationally, and adding new purchase formats. Most of these investments is expected to be in the form of increased headcount and marketing spend. We plan to continue to invest against our large market opportunity in a disciplined manner. In closing, while the pandemic continues to influence the near-term outlook, we are confident in our long-term opportunities. Over the past 21 years, we have earned sellers and buyer trust and built a scalable platform to transact rare and valuable items globally. We plan to continue investing in GMV growth and our long-term opportunity in a disciplined and thoughtful manner. Thank you for your time. I will now turn the call over to the operator to take your questions.
spk03: As a reminder, to ask a question, you will need to press star 1 on your touch-tone telephone. Again, that's star 1 on your touch-tone telephone to ask a question. To withdraw your question, press the pound key. We ask that you please ask one question and one follow-up and then re-queue. Please stand by while we compile the Q&A roster. Our first question comes from the line of Justin Post of Bank of America. Your question, please. Great.
spk08: Thank you for taking my question. I guess I'll ask about the NFT platform. David, how do you think about the market opportunity for that and maybe equally important, expanding auctions to other categories? And then, too, I know you're not guiding for the year or Q4, but we are seeing some sequential declines in GMV. How do you think about Q4 seasonality going back, you know, when you looked at financials pre-2000? Thank you.
spk04: Hey, Justin. So I'll take the first question on NFTs, and then I'll hand it over to Tu to talk about Q3 guidance and implications for performance thereafter. So in general, in terms of NFTs, this is not new news, of course, but we do believe that the blockchain is a once-in-a-generation technology. NFTs, which, of course, are enabled by it, we think will be an enduring art medium and will ultimately grow into a very large market. We also feel that creating a market for NFTs and participating in that is consistent with our overall mission, of course, which is to enrich lives with the extraordinary. and also our capabilities, and therefore falls squarely within our right to win. So specifically, why do I think that? You know, what I think is important in this market is curation, which is what we do, kind of guaranteeing authenticity, which is what we do. And, you know, we believe that we can support this market with editorial and all of the softer things that help us differentiate ourselves as a marketplace versus competitors and and offer real benefits to both collectors and artists. It's still relatively early in the rollout of this product, and there's some important pieces of functionality that are still on the roadmap that we'll follow. But again, I'm really happy that we were able to move very quickly, you know, within a matter of months, and importantly, to be able to launch this product with a relatively modest incremental investment we've spent you know, less than a million dollars on this first version, which, again, I think is a testament to the flexibility and the breadth of our platform. You know, in terms of expanding the auction format beyond NFTs, there's a good argument to do so. You know, we've got $11 billion worth of inventory, which means that, you know, just given the long sales cycle in this market, over $10 billion will not be sold this year. And, you know, I think auctions would be a logical way to help monetize that. That said, you know, we don't have a specific announcement to make yet, but, you know, it's clearly something that we are thinking about. Two, do you want to talk about the Q4?
spk01: Yep. Hey, Justin, this is Two, and thank you for the question. Before I talk about Q4, just some additional context as to historically what we have seen in Q4, right? So Q4 tends to be our biggest quarter in the year, mostly due to the holiday. We tend to see strength in the consumer segment, whereas the trade is relatively stable. in Q4 relative to the quarters that we have in the year. Also some additional context in terms of what we've seen in Q2 as well. So in terms of the fundamentals, we have seen that conversion rate continues to be very healthy. AOV grew year over year. What we saw in terms of the slowdown on the consumer side is a slight takedown on traffic, right, so across all cohorts that we've seen like a proportional takedown. And so when we look further into that, we've seen that there's been a shift between the traffic mix from desktop to mobile. And so that's not surprising given the reopening, and that's been very consistent with what we would have expected, what other e-commerce companies are seeing as well. And so obviously this is a very uncertain environment to continue to predict consumer behavior. No, there is no reason for us to believe that this quarter in Q4 would be any different from the seasonal impact that we have seen in the past.
spk08: Got it. Maybe one follow-up, just so we can think about reopening. Any way of quantifying your exposure to goods for the home versus other areas? How would you think about that?
spk01: Yeah, so I think what we've seen also is, you know, what we would have expected. So, you know, the trade continued to strengthen throughout the quarter. The trade, as you know, was impacted by COVID last year. We have heard that there were a lot of the projects that were delayed because of COVID. And we're seeing some of that demand coming back. And the trade mostly buy in furniture, right? So that's vintage and antique and new and custom. On the consumer side, what we have seen is, again, like even if we look at the volume of search for furniture through Google, we've seen that in the summer as a part of like start of the reopening, there's been a decline for search for furniture. We conversely have seen that fashion. which is an out-of-home category, has saw the biggest growth rate in Q2. So again, I think, you know, the good news is that we are very diversified in terms of our buyer segment. We have both the trade, which is benefiting from the reopening, and then we have some consumer, which again is, you know, I think that It's great that people are out and about, but in the near term, there could be some volatility in terms of consumer behavior with regards to furniture purchases.
spk08: Great. Great. Thank you.
spk01: Great.
spk03: Thank you. Our next question comes from Ross Sandler of Barclays. Your line is open.
spk07: Hey, guys. Thanks for the question. One of your competitors, Cherish, bought Pomono recently. Any thoughts on just overall level of competition that you're seeing in the space and that acquisition? Yeah, anything high level on that? Are things changing or pretty static on the competitive front? Thanks a lot.
spk04: Hey, Ross. Yeah, so Cherish, which is U.S.-focused, is merging with Pomono, which is a European-focused and European-based both of those companies are focused primarily on vintage and antique furniture. So listen, I mean, I actually think that it's a positive thing for a couple of reasons. One, in general, I think I'm a believer in competition. It both validates the market and also helps grow it. You know, hopefully there'll be more marketing dollars spent at raising awareness among consumers and so on. And But at the same time, I don't think it really changes anything. Both of those companies existed before. We were already competing with them. And I don't feel that the combination of the two of them materially changes the competitive landscape. And I have a high degree of confidence in our roadmap. And I believe that with or without consolidation, it's going to put us in a much stronger place as we begin to roll out some of the things that we're working on.
spk07: Got it. Okay. And, too, you just mentioned a little bit on the macro here in the third quarter, but the high end of the GMV guidance is a little bit below our number, and it's down sequentially from 2Q to 3Q. So anything else? It sounds like the furniture category is a little light right now, but anything else you'd call out as far as what you're seeing in the macro here in the third quarter? Thanks.
spk01: Yeah, so in terms of the guidance that we gave for Q3, again, I would just reiterate the assumptions that we have going into that guidance, right? It's that on the consumer side, we are expecting that the level of GMV that we're seeing on the consumer side is at the level we exited June. And then on the trade side, we expect that that level continues to be healthy, although, you know, we are comping bigger number for Q3 for the trade. And so Potentially, the growth rate there, we are assuming that that will moderate as well. And then lastly, no material contribution from MST, which is something that we launched today.
spk03: Thank you. Our next question comes from Ralph Sheckart of William Blair. Your line is open.
spk05: Good evening. Thanks for taking the question. First one, David, you talked about driving or converting more international buyers. I think you said about 19% of the base today was from international. Just curious, as you've tested some of the paid search or some of the other sort of factors that you laid out, what's the response been to some of those new strategies?
spk04: On international?
spk05: Yes, on international buyers.
spk04: Yeah, so just to clarify, we have not tested paid search in non-English language because In order to do that, we need a non-English language buyer experience, which we don't have yet. So, again, just to reiterate the opportunity, as you said, you know, the 19% number plus one-third of our traffic is from outside the U.S. and 40% of our supply is from the outside of the U.S. In spite of that, because we don't have a local language experience, conversion rates of non-U.S. buyers are roughly half that of U.S. buyers. So when you put all that together, we're pretty optimistic in the opportunity, and we have a team that's focused on building that out. Once we have that, then we can start to invest in local language paid advertising, along with editorial and all the other things that we use to drive demand.
spk05: Okay, sorry, I thought you had said that you were testing it. Just on any impact, if you could call out of the Delta issue, that we're seeing in the market. I'm sure it's kind of tough, but just sort of any thoughts on that. And then if I could just bolt one more on, maybe for two. I think you said the consumer trends that you saw in June, I guess, were sort of, you know, baked into the assumptions for Q3. But just any more updated thoughts on how July trended, I guess, and perhaps into August. Thank you.
spk01: Sure, and I can take both of that questions in one. I would say that while we're not commenting on quarter to date, and in particular July, what we are assuming is for Q3, the level of GMB that we're going to see is kind of similar on the consumer side exiting June. So in terms of what we saw in Q2, We thought there was a slowdown in consumer GNV starting in June. And when we looked at what was really driving that, that was all attributable to a slowdown in traffic. Conversion rate has been very healthy and AOV continued to grow on a year-over-year basis. So, again, you know, I think that because of the reopening, there has been that shift from desktop to mobile, and, you know, potentially people are not spending as much time in the home online, right? When we do have traffic coming into the site, given the conversion rate, like we are seeing that those people are buying at the same rate. and they are buying at the same AOV that we have seen historically. So, again, the quality of the buyers continue to be very strong. But, again, in terms of the near-term impact of Delta, Again, it is difficult to predict what's likely to happen, and that's why in terms of our assumption going for Q3, what we are assuming is that it's a similar environment as what we have observed in Q2. Any changes because of that obviously would impact potentially our consumer behavior and the way that they interact with us as well. What is encouraging, again, is that the fundamentals of the company continues to be healthy all across all of our cohort, and we continue to see that we are able to add new buyers at a very healthy rate.
spk05: Okay, that's helpful. Thanks, David. Thanks, Stu.
spk03: Thank you. Our next question comes from Mark Mahaney of ISI. Your line is open. Okay.
spk09: Okay, two questions, please, on the local language, international local language rollout. Can you lay down some expectations for how long that'll take and which languages will be first?
spk04: Yeah, we're not, hey, Mark, we're not in a position to offer a specific direction on that. In terms of how we would prioritize markets, you know, I think we would start with the largest markets and the ones where we have the highest existing demand. with the English language experience, and then as quickly as possible thereafter expand to every market where we have buyers.
spk09: Okay. And then if you could talk a little bit, David, about performance marketing channels and what lessons you've learned so far. And it sounds like this is just very early days for the company as a whole in terms of leaning into performance marketing. Just talk about how big that has been so far. Is it too early to draw any lessons? Do you find that the performance marketing channels are highly competitive in terms of what bids you need with bid prices? Any interesting color around where you are in terms of the learnings, how competitive those channels are?
spk04: Yeah, so, I mean, in general, I think a bit of context is helpful here. You know, keep in mind, we only switched our business model to e-commerce officially five years ago, and it was only after that that we introduced our kind of V1 paid marketing programs. We started with Google Search AdWords and, you know, since then have expanded into other channels. It is still early days, so we only launched programmatic display in December on a test basis. We're still testing, although that's been highly productive, and we've expanded that since then. We only in July began testing video via connected TV and, you know, one or two other platforms. So, again, I think it is early days. We've been very disciplined on paid and have stuck to the kind of cost-per-new return threshold. that we feel is, that we talked about in the roadshow and is, you know, accretive. And, again, we feel like there are, you know, additional channels ahead of us, both existing ones like programmatic and video and brand new ones. The other ones, the other point I would make is that, you know, the Black Card, the Centurion Black Card promotion was very effective for us. The way we think about that, though, is we make that compete. with other acquisition channels. And so, again, you know, we feel like that is, we sort of consider that yet another paid channel alongside search display via programmatic video and then, you know, potentially other channels that we're not in today.
spk09: Okay. Thank you very much.
spk04: Sure.
spk03: Thank you. Our next question comes from Aaron Kessler of Raymond James. Your question, please.
spk10: Thanks, guys. A couple of questions, maybe just on the consumer side, maybe for Q2. Specifically, was there any categories you would highlight for strength or weakness, or was it really more across the board, slowdown in terms of traffic? And just with the NFT, what's your kind of strategy for marketing that, given it's a pretty new business? And in terms of the auction format, any thoughts on expanding the auction format to other core business as well? Thank you.
spk04: Let me start with the latter two questions and I'll kick it over to two. So first of all, in terms of NFT marketing strategy, you know, I think what's interesting about NFTs from a marketing point of view is, you know, most of the activity is on platforms like Twitter and Discord. And it's important to us that we enter this market as a kind of authentic member of the community. So fortunately, you know, we were able to partner with an artist who's very well known called Metageist. Metageist is curating the initial set of artists that we're offering. And so we're very much working with him and other influencers in the community and establishing our presence on both Twitter and Discord. So that's our approach to NFTs. In terms of auctions, You know, again, I talked about this a little bit earlier, but I do feel like the opportunity for the auction format is significant. Again, we've got $11 billion worth of products on the marketplace. You know, 90-plus percent of that will not sell through this year, and auctions would present, I think, a kind of efficient way to monetize that as well as creating urgency and, you know, other things that we lack today on the platform. But we're not in a position to announce any details in terms of timing or specific plans or anything like that.
spk01: Yeah, and in terms of the trend by vertical that we saw in Q2, so I think I mentioned that fashion, which is the out-of-the-home category, has accelerated throughout the quarter. We saw, obviously, we have the trade that is performing very well for us in Q2 as well, and the trade mainly by furniture. And we've seen that trend mostly, I guess, in both new and custom and vintage and antique markets. I just want to mention also that we have made a push into continuing to cross-sell existing verticals into our existing buyers as well. Notably, we have seen that the share of GMV coming from buyers who buy cross-vertical has increased. And one data point that I gave during the prepared remarks is that, you know, 50% of our new buyers in Q2 were brought on in a newer voter pool, right? So we are seeing a lot of different pools in the marketplace, but again, it's very consistent with what we have expected, which is the out-of-the-home category are performing well.
spk02: Great. Thank you. And Lateef, could we take one more question?
spk03: Yes, sir. Our next question comes from Ron Josie of GMP Securities. Your line is open.
spk06: Great. Thanks for taking the question here. And maybe, David, I don't want to go back and harp on performance or what have you, but I did want to talk about new buyer acquisition. And I think, too, you mentioned that as a core growth priority in the back half of the year. And so I know you're testing a bunch of different paths to acquire. We did see pretty good new buyer acquisition in terms of growth this quarter. So Just talk about the strategy that makes it a top priority in the back half. I know you talked about video, but anything else specifically that we can look for? You talked about the Amex partnership, but anything that makes it the growth priority so we can look for sort of traffic gains?
spk04: Thank you. Yeah. So, you know, I think, again, let's start with some data points that illustrate the opportunity. We have 3.5 million registered buyers – or, sorry, registered users of the site – We had 69,000 buyers in the trailing 12 months. So that presents a very good opportunity for us, and it is something that is a core focus. I think there are sort of a couple of different ways we think about it. First of all, we have an always-on effort to improve conversion and improve the user experience. So as an example, in Q2, we introduced our first iPad app. We also introduced a filter for ring size. Again, you know, as has been described by others, improving conversion is a ground game. And so that's something that, again, for us is an always-on effort. Beyond that, though, I think there are lots of opportunities on both the supply and the demand side. You know, we've talked about a couple of them on the demand side. Certainly international is a big one. Again, conversion rates from non-U.S. Visitors are roughly half that of U.S. New order formats, which we've talked about. Similarly, I think on the supply side, we have an opportunity to grow our rate of supply acquisition faster than we have historically. So that's something that is in process that we're taking a look at. And then beyond that, again, we have a funnel that has more steps in it than a conventional e-commerce experience. And we think that there's an opportunity to improve conversion at each step of that funnel. So that would include things like more videos on product pages, right? Product pages with video have a much higher conversion rate than those without, so that's a focus. Giving potentially more context to pricing, which is another thing that we're working on. Improving personalization. as well as top of funnel, you know, paid, which I talked about, as well as SEO. So, again, I think sort of across the board, both operationally and also strategically, and at each stage of the funnel, we do have real levers that we can pull and that we're working on pulling to improve activation and conversion. That's great. Thank you, David.
spk03: Thank you. And at this time, I'd like to turn the call back over to CEO David Rosenblatt for closing remarks. Sir?
spk04: Great. So I'd just like to thank everyone who joined the call. I'm proud of what we accomplished in our first quarter as a public company, and I'm also proud of the pipeline that we've established, which will produce good things in the future. Thank you very much.
spk03: And this concludes today's conference call. Thank you for participating.
Disclaimer