This conference call transcript was computer generated and almost certianly contains errors. This transcript is provided for information purposes only.EarningsCall, LLC makes no representation about the accuracy of the aforementioned transcript, and you are cautioned not to place undue reliance on the information provided by the transcript.

8x8 Inc
2/4/2025
8 x 8 Inc. earnings conference call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. After the speaker's presentation, and there will be a question and answer session. To participate, you will need to press star 1-1 on your telephone. You will then hear a message advising your hand is raised. To withdraw your question, simply press star 1-1 again. Please be advised that today's conference is being recorded. Now it's my pleasure to turn the call over to the Vice President of Investor Relations, Kate Patterson. Please proceed.
Thank you. Good afternoon, everyone. Today's agenda will include a review of our results for the third quarter of fiscal 2025 with Samuel Wilson, our Chief Executive Officer, and Kevin Krauss, our Chief Financial Officer. Following our prepared remarks, there will be a question and answer session. Before we get started, let me remind you that our discussion today includes forward-looking statements about future financial performance, including investments and innovation and our focus on profitability and cash flow, as well as statements regarding our business, products, and growth strategies. We caution you not to put undue reliance on these forward-looking statements, as they involve risks and uncertainties that may cause actual results to vary materially from forward-looking statements, as described in our risk factors in our reports filed with the SEC. Any forward-looking statements made on this call and in the presentation slides reflect our analysis as of today, and we have no plans or obligations to update them. All financial metrics that will be discussed on this call are non-GAAP, unless otherwise noted. These non-GAAP metrics, together with -over-year comparisons in some cases, were not prepared in accordance with U.S. generally accepted accounting principles, or GAAP. A reconciliation of these non-GAAP metrics to the closest comparable GAAP metric is provided in our earnings release and the earnings presentation slides, which are available on 8x8's Investor Relations website at .8x8.com. With that, I'll turn the call over to Samuel Wilson.
Good afternoon, everyone, and thank you for joining us on today's third quarter fiscal 2025 earnings call. It's my pleasure to share our results, progress, and vision for the future. Our third quarter story is one of continued transformation. We delivered solid results and made strides in executing our broader strategic initiatives. We achieved service revenue above the midpoint of our guidance range, even with an FX headwind of more than $2 million from last quarter. Operating margin was also above the midpoint. The quality of the earnings remained high, and we generated record cash flow from operations. We used the excess cash to further reduce our debt by 33 million in the quarter, and another 15 million in early January. Our results for the quarter show both resilience and opportunity as we navigate a rapidly evolving landscape. Signs of our progress on our CX transformation journey were evident in various operational metrics as well. New product MRR increased more than 60% year over year, reflecting strong growth in AI-based intelligent customer assistance, secure payments, and video elevation, our video-enabled solution for field service organizations. The number of customers with three or more products continued to increase. The average monthly recurring revenue of customers with three or more products is more than three times the MRR of two product customers and retention is higher. For these reasons, we've made cross-sell a high priority at 8x8. We continue to expand our presence internationally, especially in Asia-Pac region, as we expand our platform as a service offerings. The region even booked its largest deal ever with a well-known auto manufacturer. We closed the largest follow-on deal in our history when a major US retailer chose 8x8 for their new contact center and expanded their UCAS commitment. This customer is in the process of evaluating additional products. Customer satisfaction remains high. This is reflected in our own customer satisfaction surveys, which shows CSAT scores in the mid to high 90% range for our targeted enterprise customers. Finally, our platform and our reputation as an innovator in CX are rapidly gaining increased visibility with customers and industry analysts. Our peer review scores on Gartner's insights reflect our strong product portfolio and continue to increase as the number of reviews have grown. Our UC and CC score are now both 4.4 on a scale of one to five. Also, as our market presence continues to grow, we are frequently included on the short list of companies to watch. For example, in an article in CX Today, Liz Miller of Constellation Research and Zia Karavala of ZK Research named 8x8 as one of 10 innovative global vendors differentiating within the contact center as a service space. Our platform as a service API offerings are also receiving accolades. In a Channel Futures article of the top 20 CPAS vendors to know, Forrester's Craig LeCarre counted 8x8 among its top pure play CPAS players. We continue to receive more formal awards and recognition as well, which we included in our earnings presentation. This quarter, I wanna call out our inclusion in Newsweek's annual Excellence 1000 Index. Inclusion is based on wide ranging criteria from employee and customer reviews, the R&D spending, to governance and ethical impact. We are honored to be included as a company that balances strategic growth with a deep commitment to ethics, social responsibility and sustainability. All in all, these results and awards highlight our disciplined execution and progress towards our strategic initiatives. We outlined a bold plan to transform 8x8 into a CX leader and have made huge progress. Our acquisition of FUSE played a key role in jumpstarting our journey. We have also made substantial headway with FUSE integration during the quarter and have a clear path to platform shutdown. Priority number one was fixing the financial model and building a strong balance sheet. We reduced our costs, increased our cash flow and returned value to our investors through debt reduction. We have now been generating cash for 16 quarters and have made 10 debt repayments, reducing our total debt, including convertible debt, from a peak of 548 million in August 2022 to approximately 354 million today, 35% less in just over two years. Priority number two was accelerate innovation. As a technology company, this is the only way to drive durable growth. We increased investment in R&D and sharpened our focus to designing a CX platform for small and medium-sized enterprises. This doesn't mean we can't handle thousands of concurrent users in our contact center and we have customers that size. But this is the market segment where we can differentiate the most by delivering on simplicity, eliminating complexity and reducing technology risk. We set our sights on going beyond core contact center functionality to a flexible CX platform with plug and play tools that reduce customers' integration burden. Based on our feedback from agents, supervisors and system administrators, we prioritized investments in reliability, ease of use, security and compliance and seamless multi-channel communication. We also embedded artificial intelligence across the platform to enhance data analytics, call transcription, meaning summarizations and a host of other core platform services. We began building an ecosystem of carefully curated technology partners for -in-class solutions, applied AI solutions that are tightly integrated with our platform to deliver native-like user experience. Our R&D organization's exceptional work, delivering hundreds of releases per month, has allowed us to enhance our platform, substantially over the past few years. These enhancements have significantly improved usability, leveraged AI-driven automation, increased security and directly addressed our customers' most pressing pain points. We deliver better outcomes, allowing our customers to achieve their business goals. A few of our recent platform announcements in our winter software release included self-service or agent-assisted secure payments, integrated directly into the contact center, AI-powered directory to quickly route calls using a natural sounding voice bot that supports over 50 languages and 91 accent variants and AI-based tools to help agents quickly assess and share knowledge-based content. We continue to expand our technology partner ecosystem, giving customers the flexibility to choose the best add-ons for their use cases. Call Cabinet, a leader in compliance, call recording and analytics, is the most recent addition to our cell width tier. With direct integration across 8x8 work and 8x8 contact center, Call Cabinet becomes the only compliant call recording add-on within the 8x8 ecosystem for Microsoft Teams Operator Connect offering. Our platform approach is resonating with customers. For example, a world leader in flooring and sports surfaces chose 8x8 unified platform for CX over several competitors shown in the leaders quadrant of the Gardner MQ for CCAS. A Canadian-based leader in insurance and benefit consulting chose 8x8 platform for CX, including UC, CC, and Engage for its high quality service, upgrade flexibility, and French language support. A leading fintech company delivering secure and innovative payment solutions chose 8x8 SMS and WhatsApp business solutions to power multi-channel customer engagement, deciding factors were our global reach, built-in security and compliance, and a dedicated support team with deep platform as a service expertise. In addition to highlighting the strength of our product portfolio, these multi-product wins show significant progress we've made transforming our -to-market strategies. As the green shoots of increased platform sales and multi-product adoption multiply, we are investing in selectively ramping our sales capabilities and launching new marketing programs to raise our visibility. In November, we unveiled the next evolution of our brand. More than a refreshed look and feel, this brand signals the next chapter in 8x8 CX transformation. The response from customers, partners, and industry influence has been overwhelmingly positive. We've included a sampling of social posts and feedback in the earnings presentation. A solid financial foundation and a powerful CX platform designed to deliver business impact for our customers, the building box are in place. As we approach fiscal 26, our focus is clear, accelerate our transformation. To do this, we plan to, one, improve our sales execution, two, scale our proven successes, three, differentiate our solutions, four, continue to optimize our cost structures, and five, shut down the Fuse platform by the end of the calendar year. Executing transformations of this magnitude are seldom linear, and we know there will be bumps along the way. We are still working through the revenue headwinds to diffuse customer upgrades to our platform, and the market dynamics are fluid, especially in UCAS. While this winds the range of near-term outcomes, I remain confident in our future success. As I visit our offices, customers, and partners around the world, I see a powerful new energy at 8x8, fueled by a common vision and a strategy aligned on our mission, solve customer problems. It is an exciting time for us, and I want to express my gratitude and appreciation to all of our employees, partners, and investors for our progress so far. I look forward to sharing our future success with all of you. I now turn the call over to Kevin.
Thanks, Sam. Good afternoon, everyone, and thank you for joining us today for our fiscal third quarter earnings call. This quarter marked another period of strong execution across our business, including record communications platform usage revenue, solid profit margins, and record cash flow from operations. Fiscal Q325 represents our 16th consecutive quarter of positive cash flow from operations and non-GAAP operating profit. We continued our disciplined approach to debt reduction, repaying $33 million of our term loan debt during the quarter and an additional $15 million in January 2025 during our fiscal fourth quarter. Including this latest prepayment, we have now reduced the principal value of our debt by over $194 million, or approximately 35% since the peak in August 2022. The press release and trended financial results on our investor relations website provide a detailed view of our performance, but I will highlight a few key points on today's call. Before continuing, I would like to remind you that unless otherwise noted, I will be discussing non-GAAP metrics, except for revenue and cash flow. For the third quarter of fiscal 2025, total revenue was $178.9 million near the midpoint of our guidance range. Service revenue totaled $173.5 million, exceeding the midpoint of our guidance by $1 million. Subscription and usage-based service revenue on the 8x8 platform continued to grow both sequentially and year over year. Growth was offset by the anticipated decline in revenue from customers still on the FUSE platform. During Q3, we made continued progress upgrading FUSE customers to the 8x8 platform, reducing the remaining FUSE base to approximately 5% of service revenue, compared to 7% in the prior quarter and 11% in Q3-24. We've been made on track to complete these upgrades by the end of calendar year 2025, which will simplify our operations and strengthen customer engagement. Our multi-product strategy continues to drive results with committed monthly recurring revenue from customers using three or more products increasing over 10% since the start of the fiscal year. This growth highlights the effectiveness of our strategy to deepen customer engagement by offering a comprehensive suite of solutions, fostering stronger customer relationships, improving retention, and unlocking additional value for both our customers and our business. These results underscore the resilience of our underlying business, despite facing approximately $2.2 million in foreign exchange headwinds relative to our expectations at the beginning of the quarter. Without this FX headwind, total revenue would have been near the high end of our guidance range, and service revenue would have exceeded it. Gross margin for the quarter was 69.5%. Within our guidance range and impacted by the revenue mix as lower margin platform usage revenue was approximately 13% of total revenue up sequentially and year over year. The underlying gross margin of our subscription-based business remained healthy and consistent with recent quarters. Operationally, our spending levels remained consistent with earlier quarters, and our business model continues to benefit from a natural FX hedge, where the impact of foreign exchange on revenue is largely offset by a corresponding opposite impact on expenses. As a result, we delivered an operating margin of .7% during the quarter, slightly above the midpoint of our guidance. Stock-based compensation expense for Q3 was .3% of total revenue, near the multi-year low of .2% recorded last quarter. This reflects our commitment to managing this expense responsibly and reducing shareholder dilution over time. Our continued focus in this area has allowed us to achieve gap operating profitability for the second consecutive quarter, a milestone that underscores our financial discipline. As part of this effort, we have shifted toward primarily cash compensation for the majority of employees, which is reflected in our non-gap operating income. Turning to the balance sheet and cash flow, we ended Q3 with $104.6 million in cash, cash equivalents, and restricted cash, down approximately 13 million from Q2 due to the $33 million term loan repayment I mentioned earlier. The Q3 balance sheet includes $16.5 million in current term loan liability, net of unamortized discounts and issuance costs. This represents a principal balance of $17 million, the minimum required payments for the next 12 months. With the $15 million prepayment we just made in January, our remaining current liability is effectively $2 million. Our net debt to trailing 12 months EBITDA ratio has decreased to approximately 2.6 times, down from over six times in fiscal Q2-23, giving us greater flexibility to pursue strategic opportunities. Additionally, stockholders' equity increased for the third consecutive quarter, reflecting continued progress in strengthening our financial position. Our remaining performance obligation remains steady at $800 million, representing a -over-year increase of 4.6%. This growth reflects the strength of our multi-year customer contract backlog and provides a strong foundation for future revenue visibility. We are particularly proud of generating $27.2 million in operating cash flow this quarter, a record for us. This achievement demonstrates our ability to generate strong returns while maintaining a disciplined and efficient operating model. However, while this milestone reflects our strong execution and operational efficiency, it is important to recognize that cash flow performance does fluctuate due to market dynamics, investment timing, and other factors. We remain committed to prudent financial management to sustain long-term growth and value creation. As we look ahead, our cost structure remains stable and we continue to invest in innovation and customer success. We believe our target cost structure with R&D at approximately 15% of revenue, sales and marketing between 33 and 34% of revenue, and G&A between 10 and 11% of revenue provides the right balance of investment to drive growth while maintaining profitability. With this context, we are providing the following guidance for fiscal Q4 2025. Service revenue is expected to be in the range of 170 million to $175 million. Total revenue is expected to be between $175 million and $181 million. Please note that the total revenue and service revenue reduction due to foreign exchange rates since we gave our prior guidance is approximately $2.3 million. This means that on a constant currency basis, our service revenue guidance midpoint remains about the same as the guidance midpoint we provided last quarter. Operating margin is expected to be in the range of 9% to 10%. Please remember that our fiscal fourth quarter includes seasonally higher expenses as certain employer taxes and benefits restart in January. For the full fiscal year 2025, we are guiding as follows. Service revenue is expected to be between $691.3 million and $696.3 million. Total revenue is anticipated to be between $713 million and $719 million. Please note that the total revenue and service revenue reduction due to foreign exchange rate changes since we gave our prior guidance is approximately $4.5 million. This means that on a constant currency basis, our full year service revenue guidance midpoint remains about the same as the guidance midpoint we provided last quarter. Full year operating margin is projected between .7% and 11%, translating to non-GAAP operating income of approximately $77.5 million at the midpoint of our full year revenue and operating margin guidance. We expect interest expense, including amortization of debt issuance costs, to be about $5.3 million in Q4, based upon current interest rates and our outstanding debt balance. We expect cash paid for interest to be approximately $7 million in Q4-25, as cash interest on the 2028 convertible debt is due semi-annually. These interest amounts assume approximately .3% on the term loan, or SOFR plus 3%. Putting all of this together, we expect fully diluted non-GAAP earnings per share to be in the range of 35 cents to 37 cents for the year. We anticipate full year cash flow from operations to be between $61 million and $65 million, an increased range compared to our prior comments. Note that cash flow from operations typically decreases in fiscal Q4 due to the timing of seasonally increased employer expenses and cash paid for interest. While we are not providing guidance for fiscal 2026, I want to point out that we plan to make strategic investments that support our go-to market initiatives in the next fiscal year. While these investments are expected to result in a lower non-GAAP operating margin compared to fiscal 2025, they are essential to strengthening our market position and accelerating long-term revenue expansion. We believe that by enhancing our commercial capabilities, we will be well positioned to capture new opportunities, improve customer relationships, and drive growth over time. In closing, I remain confident in our vision and strategy as we navigate the path to sustainable profitable growth. While challenges may arise along the way, the progress we continue to make reinforces my belief that we are taking the right steps to achieve our long-term goals. I am deeply grateful to the 8x18 for their hard work and dedication in delivering these strong results, and I look forward to sharing our progress in the quarters ahead. Operator, we are now ready to take questions.
Thank you so much, and as a reminder, to ask the question, simply press star 11 on your telephone and wait for your name to be announced. To remove yourself, press star 11 again. One moment for our first question. And he's from the line of Josh Nichols with B. Riley. Please proceed.
Yeah, thanks for taking my question. Great to see the record operating cash flow, and it looks like the company is making some good progress towards getting back to growth. On that front, I just had a question. If you take out the FX impact, it looks like, with service revenue been up quarter over quarter, but also year over year, and then looking at the four-queue service revenue guide, is that it'd be effectively flat year over year, maybe up a little bit? I assume that that also includes a little bit of FX headwinds, if you exclude that, it would maybe be up a little bit more of a material now. Is that accurate?
Hey, Josh, yeah, this is Kevin. We do see 2.3 million or so of FX headwind in our Q4 relative to what we guided last quarter. So that would imply a roughly, a raise to guidance for the full year, by the way, and kind of flat quarter over quarter, as you say.
Got it, and then just touching a little bit on some of the AI and other offerings, very good growth, you're seeing, I think you mentioned like 60% growth there. Any opportunity to quantify? I know that was still relatively low base, low, mid, single digits. Is that beginning to ramp up, and when you think about next fiscal year without talking about guidance specifically, is that position you in the situation, combined with the runoff of the remaining FUSE business, to get back to service revenue growth that's pretty consistent throughout the year, maybe accelerating towards the back half?
All right, Josh, I think it's a great question. The new product revenue, the AI stuff, still single digit millions for the quarter. It's growing very rapidly, but it's still not quite enough to move the needle overall. Our goal next year is growth at some point throughout the year. There are a lot of moving pieces. I've been surprised by the FX kind of tailwind, headwind, tailwind, headwind phenomena we've been dealing with a little bit, that's causing a little bit of the rounding errors and some of the things going on around that, along with just the industry dynamics in general. So it's certainly our goal to return to growth without getting into guidance and all those other things. It'll be a combination of new product growth, multi-product customers having higher retention rates, and continuing to just add new customers into the mix.
Thanks, and then last question for me. I think you talked about before at some conferences, it's just like ex-fuse that the company would be getting to maybe load mid-single digit growth. It seems like that transition and runoff continues to be on track for the end of this calendar year. What else has to be done overall? Any potential thoughts on also the savings when you're not running two platforms parallel to each other anymore?
Yeah, so okay, I'm sorry, you asked me that last question, I didn't really do a good job of answering it, so I apologize. Yes, we're still on track to run down fuse. I think we're down to 5% of revenue, and you can see the trend, we're really pushing hard to get that done. It is absolutely our objective to shut down the fuse platform at the end of this fiscal year. My mandate to the teams is 1159 on PM on 1231, we turn off the fuse platform. In terms of savings, hard savings, probably mid-single digit millions of dollars, there's an intangible savings that's a little bit harder to measure, which is maintaining security compliance, maintaining HIPAA qualifications, maintaining software upgrades and OS upgrades and all those kinds of things, that are a little bit harder to quantify other than just the cost savings of AWS for running the platform or whatever the case may be. And so, I don't know, if you wanna take a rough guess, I'd probably double that in my mind, in terms of hard cost savings. It comes once fuse is behind us. And I think running off the fuse platform will definitely help in terms of getting to growth next year.
Appreciate the context, thanks.
Thanks Josh. Thank you, one moment for our next question. And it's from the line of Ryan Coons with Needham and Company, please proceed.
Hi, great, Sam, you mentioned in your prepared comments, just some turbulence in the UC space, can you expand on that, kind of where you feel like we are in saturation, kind of where pricing's been headed and what the competitive environment's been like? Thanks.
Yeah, so I think last quarter on UC, I'm gonna broaden your question here in a second, but on UC, we did see a little bit of aggressiveness on pricing, not unheard of, I would say it's pretty typical in the fourth quarter, calendar quarter of the year, because some of the companies have fiscal year ends and they can always get a little bit more aggressive at the end of the year. Obviously, this is something the industry analysts, you the financial analysts have been talking about for a while, so I wouldn't say it was anything bizarre or crazy. I think for us, I just wanna switch, broaden the question slightly for us, because you asked about the market, but for us, I think what matters a lot more is we saw more deals last quarter that were contact center led, that really are viewing UC as just an add-on or a condiment, if you will, to the CX sale. Our CX messaging is really resonating, we're seeing us land with more platform wins, I consider platform win three plus products, and UC is typically one of those, to deal with those, and we've got to engage in those other things, and so I think we're really well positioned to deal with anything around pricing around UC in that area. I think I gave a good answer, and if I didn't, ask me a follow-up.
That was great. Can you comment briefly on the international opportunity, how you size that up these days, what your thoughts are?
Man, I love the international opportunity eight by eight. We see the CPAS business doing fantastic, the platform usage business doing fantastic, and we've been bringing that around the world. Our presence in Europe is growing, and I really love that, and honestly, there's just less, I don't wanna be struggling for words here, Ryan, for a second, there's less irrational behavior, because we don't have this post-COVID, we raised a bunch of money, we're some startup, and we're just gonna willy-nilly throw pricing or free professional services or contract buyouts, or any of that other ridiculous stuff that we typically see sometimes in the United States.
Yeah, and Western Europe is still an area you plan to expand in?
Yes, sir.
All right, thanks, Jim.
Thank you so much, one moment for our next question. And it's from the line of City Panigari with Mizuho. Please proceed.
Hey, thanks, it's Chad on for City. Just wondering if you can talk about what you're hearing from customers in their appetite for AI products, and if that's differing sort of at the low end versus the high end, and any updates you can share around whether these guys are using AI to complement existing agent functions or starting to see any reduction in the human agent? Thank you.
Okay, Chad, quite a big question there. So I may ask a couple of small follow-ups along the way. So when you talk low end versus high end, I presume you mean customers, or by customer size, or sort of where you're at. And so, okay, what I would say is like our target market is that upper small business to low end enterprise. And what they love is that we give best in breed AI capabilities. We're talking Gartner Magic Quadrant leading bots, which most of our competitors do not offer, natively integrated into our contact center space, natively integrated into our UC, natively integrated into Gage, so it works absolutely fantastic. And we're really focused on solving those CX problems, and when you do that, AI plays a pretty pivotal role inside of that. In terms of the low end, so let's say small businesses, those kinds of things, I don't see it as much. Where we see a lot of interest, and I'm gonna be a little bit cautious here, there's a little bit of overlap between the things. Where we see a lot of interest is around things like digital messaging, SMS, two way communications with the contact center using WhatsApp, appointment reminders, those kinds of things. Now where all the overlap starts to occur is when you start looking things like at our appointment management for healthcare, remote fix, where you're starting to bring multiple solutions together. So I mentioned, you know, I've been talking about bots a little bit, but our voice bot is just on fire. I mean, it's been amazing at how fast that's grown. And it can speak 50 plus languages and 91 accents, I think I said in my prepared remarks. And I think that's super important because that's a little bit where we're starting to see a little overlap between large businesses and small businesses, when we start getting into self-service and those kinds of things, particularly around contact center. So we're doing some amazing stuff around self-service payments, highly secure payments where you can do Apple Pay, 100% self-service, those kinds of things, PCI compliance through a voice bot, dealing with an agent if there's a problem in the payment, those kinds of things. Those solutions really, really, really across the board, horizontally, high demand for. Oh, other question, what's about agent counts? Okay, and I get asked this question a lot, and I'm gonna tell you a little bit of what I see and a little bit of what I think. What I see is, it's hard to see. I mean, people just ask this for X number of agents, for contact center, how many of our agents they have, et cetera. And so in real time today, do I see AI replacing agents here, there, and everywhere? Man, a few select cases, sure, but nothing major, no big trend. I absolutely believe that AI will replace some agent capability over time. It's what technology's done well in my entire career, which is to replace human labor with machines effectively. And I so absolutely think that's gonna case. However, the reason we've built the company the way we have is our average revenue per customer at the places they deploy AI, at the places they deploy these next generation technologies is actually up substantially, even if our per seat count is flat, even down a few.
That's super helpful, I'll pass it on. Thank you.
Thanks, Chad. Thank you. Our next question is from the line of Peter Levine with Evercore.
Great, thanks guys for taking my questions. A few, maybe I'll start with you, Kev. Your last question around the margin outlook for fiscal 26, calendar 26, sorry. What would be lower given some of the strategic opportunities you guys are investing from on the -to-market front? Can you maybe just maybe help us understand what that trends like to the top line? Is there a calculated ROI that you're expecting? And then can you maybe just caveat that with what you think that will translate to growth?
Yeah, so I'll take the first part of that. Kevin will put in some finer points. Because to be fair, I'm gonna dodge part of your question because I really don't want to give guidance out an entire year in front of when I'm supposed to. And also it's not quite as clean as maybe it looks in a spreadsheet. So do we have an ROI to our operating income investments or operating investments? Absolutely. Am I gonna share that with you? No, I am not. Because if I share with you, I'm sharing it with every competitor currently listening on this call right now and I'm not doing that. I'm not a nice guy. And so what I'll tell you is yes, there's a calculation. We monitor it very carefully. The hard part, and I know you have a ton of experience with this Peter, is the timing aspect of the investments is always the difficult thing for the financial model in sort of what we're going through, right? So if you go back in time, you go back to fiscal 23 and 24, we really focused on ramping up cash flows, paying off debt. We've paid off 35% of the debt. We've made 10 separate payments to pay off debt. We've really been focused on that. I am, you know, our EBITDA and net debt ratio is fine. The banks are happy, everyone's happy. And so we're really focused now getting kind of back on offense and driving more growth. And we are making selective investments. Definitely the right thing to do given the market opportunity, our competitive position, really impressed where the innovation is right now, those kinds of things. How quickly and exactly to three decimal places, that much sales or bookings or revenue that'll lead, we'll keep that internal to us right now. Kevin, anything you wanna add about? Yeah,
I will say that it's not just about investment and we're doing various things, but we're also focused on improving the efficiency of our investments as well. So yes, we're gonna do more things, which we won't divulge in the call as Sam said, but we're also focused on our operational excellence internally in the company. So that is also another lever for growth over the long term. So I'll, you know, that's the color. Yeah, and actually,
Kevin raises a really great point, just to put a fine point out. We are investing in AI to use internally. I think, you know, we tend to see it in these calls, we get viewed as a company that sells AI, which we absolutely do across the platform growing very rapidly. We're also buyer of AI to actually improve how we provide CX, how we engage with the customer, how efficient we can be internally. That's some investments we're making internally to our company also, and that costs us a few dollars.
Well, great for the color. You know, last question, you know, Sam, you mentioned in your remarks, like customers of three products versus customers of two, the uplift to the ARR number. I forgot like the exact metric you said, but can you maybe talk about like, what products are they buying? Meaning like, what's driving that massive uptick from like two to three product customers? And then maybe just outline what is that? Yeah, so,
yeah, no problem. So I think exactly what I said was, if you look at the cohort of customers that have two products and the cohort of customers that have three products, the cohort of customers that have three products is? The average deal
size is three times as
large. The average deal size is three times as large. So it sort of translates. Okay, what do they buy? I'd love to tell you it's really simple. I'm gonna put in a couple buckets. What really works is when you sell on business outcomes and you do some of those things, you start to see it's easier to cross out products. So they almost all have UC and CC in sort of bucket categories. After that, the key add-ons in my mind are Engage, which is kind of a contact center for not agents, fantastic product, proactive outreach or digital messaging of all sorts and kinds and shapes, and the bots, the intelligent assistants, voice and digital bots. And then of course there's workforce management. There's all kinds of other little add-ons. But those are, I'd say the big three. I think what's key though, I really want you to think about is, it's really about solving customer problems and the use cases associated with it. If we do something like field service management, we end up selling digital messaging, we sell a bot, we sell video elevation in the contact center, we sell contact center, we sell UC, we sell Engage. They rapidly turn into multi-product customers very quickly. And it's just a nice way to wrap up solving the customer problems. I think the thing I wanna leave you with is when we sell those multi-products, of course we get a higher GRR, we get a higher NRR, financial numbers are better. But really it's about we solve customer problems better. And when we solve customer problems better, everything else sort of takes care of itself.
Thank you guys.
Thank you. Thank you. Our next question is from the line of Katharine Trepnik with Ross and Blatt. Please proceed.
Hi, thanks for taking my question. You know, Sam, have you tweaked the -to-market at all? You've done really well with the three products versus the two. Anything else we should look at that you've fine-tuned in terms of your partners or your -to-market motions or what your messaging is in the channel?
Katharine, you know, that's such a loaded question because I know what I think what you're getting at. Yes, there was a couple things we're doing overall. Number one is yes, we continue to evolve in terms of our sales organization. If you guys are regular purveyors of LinkedIn, you will see that some people have come and gone from our company over time for various reasons. A lot of that is driven by the fact that we're looking more for consultative solution sellers versus, you know, to use an industry vernacular circuit slingers, et cetera. So that continues to evolve. I cannot speak highly enough about the work the marketing department has done around rebranding and really branding us as a CX company. And the thing is it's not just paint on the outside of an old building. This really is as we've launched the products and as we have these solutions, we are a CX company. And this is about highlighting what we truly are to the marketplace that will continue to evolve as we drive more sort of capabilities around that, et cetera. And then on the partner side, I think that's more of an evolution. We continue to invest in our partners. We are a channel-centric company. We do a majority of our business through channels. And so, I mean, a majority of our new business through channels, to be fair. And so we'll continue to do that. And we continue to evolve in terms of the right tools and capabilities and those kinds of things that support our channel partners and their success.
All right, and then you added a transformational leader to the team and any organization that you can specifically look at in detail. Can you give us some details on that?
Yeah, so I had a chance. I've known Joel for several years now. And, you know, I... So if you're familiar with Joel's work, I'm just gonna assume for everybody for a second you're familiar with Joel's work and try to fill in what he does. But he is a phenomenal leader. He's a former military guy like me. So we speak a common language. But the big thing for me is he brings a lot of AI skills and capabilities into the company. And this is about using intelligence, artificial intelligence inside of ourselves to drive more insights and better decision making inside of our company. And Joel is really heading that up to transform as a company how we deliver our products and services, how we build our products and services to our customers. Super important. And Kate pinged me, but I should use this forum because it's the right thing to do. I'd really like to call out Michelle Payditch for being recognized as a channel chief by CRM Magazine. She is phenomenal. And so, as Kate pings me, I get a chance to use your question to highlight what a wonderful channel chief she is.
Yeah, I know. She started last year. I think I met her at Channel Partners.
Thanks. Yeah, she came to us, I think from Twilio, if memory serves me, where I hired her out of. And she's been absolutely phenomenal for us as a channel team.
All right,
thanks, Sam. Thank you. Oh, for all the competitors, you can't hire her. That's a no.
Thank you. And our next question is from Meta Marshall with Morgan Stanley. Please proceed.
Great, thanks. Maybe first, you commented on CPAS being strong internationally. I just wanted to get a sense of an attraction that you were getting in the US or where you were kind of finding markets that were more attractive there. And then second, over time, you've commented on kind of customers wanting more kind of -a-cart kind of packages put together. Just wondering if you're kind of seeing any, you know, consistency form around like whether people want more consumption-based pricing or whether they're kind of kind of want -a-cart or whether we'll stick to this kind of per se model that we've been in. That's it.
Okay, so Meta, thank you for the question. So yes, so last quarter, the quarter before we ran Productive Outreach in the United States, we've got our first customers. These are regular CPAS customers in the United States now. We're still having a few growing pains as we ramp our CPAS business in the United States, but I'm pretty happy where it's at. And this is regular SMS, WhatsApp, voice, all those kinds of capabilities in the US. Still really small. I mean, it's not a huge number of customers, but we've got them. The bugs are working out. They're happy. They're referenceable, good CSAT scores, those kinds of things. So steps in the right direction. In terms of the evolution of pricing and packaging, it's a great question, and it's certainly one that we spend a lot of time thinking about. I fundamentally believe if you look at a lot of the AI technologies and even the CPAS technologies, these are all sold on a consumption basis, right? So if you look at how OpenAI can charge some stuff, they charge for tokenization. For our bots, we charge per interaction. For digital messaging, we charge per message, those kinds of things. I think certainly those types of pricing models will continue to grow. I'm not sure that it'll ever work on sort of a per agent basis. I know that some people have tried contact center on a per interaction basis, and the feedback I've heard from customers is pretty universally negative. And so there are some fine line there. I think the key is building the products and the underlying systems that can kind of support a multitude of models that meet the customer where they are, not where we want them to be, if that makes any sense.
Yeah, no, that makes sense. Appreciate it.
Thank you, Amita.
Thank you. One moment for our next question, please. And it's from the line, Orion McWilliams with Bartleys. Please proceed.
Hey, Ryan. Hey, Sam. Sam, for the record, for an earlier question, I think you're a nice guy. You're gonna say yourself short. Just on the macro, since the election, any differences by smaller or larger customers since the presidential election, or any differences by geo in terms of customer purchasing?
It's funny you asked me this. I was hoping I wasn't gonna get this question. And the reason I was hoping I was gonna get this asked question is I don't have a good answer right this second. So let me tell you a bit of what we're seeing, and you guys can be smarter than me and draw some conclusions. If you look at 2024, I think there was a record number of bankruptcies in the United States, or at least, sorry, 14-year high in the number of bankruptcies in the United States, sorry, not a record. Because that 08 probably was the record. But 14-year high in the number of bankruptcies. And we have seen some customers have to move to things like cash revenue recognition, because they're currently going through bankruptcy proceedings and those kinds of things. So it's not like we're untouched. It's not a material number. I'm not fazed by it, but it's clear what I think. Now, on the other hand, I've talked about this in the past, is one of the numbers I use is our credit card default rates as a really sensitive indicator that there's something going on in the small business space and sort of those basic mom and pop economics. And so far there, it's been steady as she goes, no real unusual stuff around credit card default rates, et cetera. So it feels like the interest rate stuff that the Fed did bit a little bit, but a bit in larger businesses, maybe because they were more indebted, more sensitive to interest rates than some of the smaller businesses, which were probably more cash driven. And so I'd say it's a bit of a tale of two cities, hence the reason I really didn't want the question. In the European markets, we see a little bit more selectivity by specific verticals. So for example, in the UK, some state and local has seen a reduction in spending, why NHS has seen an increase in spending, those kinds of things. And so I think it's a little bit of vertical by vertical. And in the US, I think it's a little bit large versus small. That's my best guess.
Just a quick point of clarification on credit card. We were talking about decline rates from our customers. We got a lot of credit card customers. It's not the default rate of the industry. Yeah, sorry, the credit card, yeah, the ones where they turn
off the credit cards.
No, I appreciate the color. And then Sam, how do you view Salesforce as a potential partner and competitor in the customer service space? Like do you think- Well, I'm currently on the
fifth floor and Salesforce is on the first floor right now. So they're a partner. They're a really good partner of ours. Yeah, but we're just alongside each
other. Like do you just live inside each other or, okay. Like if you could elaborate on that, like how that would work with Agentforce?
Well, I don't want to reveal any future products, knock on wood, but those are technologies we're looking at, Agentforce, et cetera. We're a large Salesforce customer and partner. We use them extensively for things like our communities that we deal with customers and those kinds of things. And so I view Salesforce as a great partner and would like to do more with them in the future. I don't really view them as a competitor.
Great scholar, thanks guys.
Thank you.
Thank you so much. Our next question comes from the line of Michael Funk with Bank of America. Please proceed.
Hey, good evening guys. Thank you for the questions. First one's clarification. So of the 200 basis point reduction and few percentage of revenue going from seven to 5%, how much of that migrated over to your core platform? Was that all lost?
Some migrated. We do have a component of that that gets lost and there's timing effects as well on that, Michael. So the average, I'll say the average over time that we keep is 60 plus percent of our views based revenue. So that's kind of where we've been, where we expect to be.
And let me put a finer point on that because 60% sounds like a terrible number and you guys are gonna freak out. So let me put a finer point on that. What we see typically with Fuse customers is we see a step down when we migrate them and then their NRR is substantially above corporate average. So what generally ends up happening is they're going through a redeployment process. So they'll shrink it down to a smaller size, whatever they need and then they start adding back in really rapidly and it's not like we're losing 40% of the revenue to Fuse overnight.
And the other thing is to add to that, when we do that, we often and almost always extend the contract. So we keep that customer for longer. So in the long term, it's a better deal for eight by eight.
Got it, no thank you. Second one's for you, Sam, more philosophical. So the market is saying one thing. If we look at the pre-cash flow multiple, look at EV to EBITDA, it seems to me very different than what you are about stabilizing top line. Seems to me very different than the improvement in free cash flow, cash mop activity. Same thing very different than what I'm forecasting in my own model. So how are you thinking about addressing that? Number of levers you could pull, I guess, right? I mean, stock repurchase, strategic review. So how do you think about addressing what the market is telling us in your valuation, whether it's free cash flow or EV to EBITDA, and what you believe and I believe is the likely outcome?
Well, it's interesting, Michael, you bring this up, right? So there's obviously, having spent much time on Wall Street also, I could make some comments about Wall Street's predictive capability sometimes. But let me take a step back. I think at a very basic level, I've tried to be really crystal clear with investors. Our North Star was cash flow from operations per share. And the reason I think about it that way is it's the cash flow that we generate per equity holder. And I think that is, if you think about Graham and Dodd and the discounted cash flow and the present value of a business is the sum of its future cash flows, it's a very pure way to think about how a company should operate and the optionality of a company during uncertain times. So let me further elaborate on that a bit. If you go back two years when I started making the comments that that's our metrics, we've obviously done a lot of things. We've given a lot of cash flow, a record quarter for cash flow from operations. Our stock-based compensation is .3% of revenue, which I think is one third industry averages or our competitors or those kinds of things. And so we're very focused. You see it in the fact that some of my competitors have seen declining shareholder equity, shareholder equity, while I've seen increasing shareholder equity. So what I'm trying to drive is the right thing. Now, is the market rewarding me in any given moment? Maybe yes, maybe no. But what that does, and I wanna take this back into the market environment we've been in, what cash flow does is it buys me the maximum amount of optionality to run this business. I can invest in product development, I can buy other companies, I can buy my own equity, I can continue to pay off debt, which is primarily what I've chosen to do with all that excess cash flow, is reduce the debt, thereby further reducing the risk of the company and actually, if enterprise value stays unchanged, driving more value of those future cash flows to our equity holders. So what I've really thought about is the market we've been in coming out of COVID is one of increased risk, increased competition, startups, what's gonna happen, AI, what's the future, let's really focus on de-risking the company from a, you know, have a fortress balance sheet, drive cash flow, get debt out, et cetera. Let's invest in the right areas in innovation and those kinds of things. Now, as we look to the future, right, the company's massively reduced the amount of debt it has, it's massively reduced its leverage ratios, et cetera. It's much less risky. The innovation we've produced has these incredible green shoots in my eyes. What are those green shoots? We invested in it, we built it, it works, we have product market fit and we're now ramping and so it's actually okay to take some of that cash flow and now pour it back into growing revenues and growing future cash flows via revenue and those kinds of things. Your last part of your question is, is Wall Street gonna reward me for this? I think at some point they'll recognize it, they'll get around to it, they'll figure it out. You know, that's the hard part. I always go back to what Ben Graham said to Congress, right? When Congress asked Ben Graham, how does he know stocks are gonna go up when they have these type of characteristics? He said, just because they do. And so what I go back to is the fact that the street will reward us at some point, our stock, our capabilities, when they realize that owning a share of eight by eight is an incredibly valuable asset, it's gonna get you a stream of future cash flows, it gets you a very profitable business and it gets you all the right things that you want in the characteristic of an equity holder. My simple answer.
Very thorough, thank you for that Sam and thank you again Kevin for the clarification on the migration.
Thank you. Thanks.
Thank you, one moment for our next question please. It is from the line of Michael Turin with Wells Fargo. Please proceed.
Hi, this is Richard Poladon for Michael. Thanks for taking my question. So you noted the potential expanded range of near term outcomes around FUSE and you gave kind of the breadcrumb there around that 60%. Could you expand on what you hear from that base as they're going through that decision making process and what's kind of like the biggest pushback that you have to shifting over to the eight by eight platform, any color around that would be helpful.
Yeah, I think it's just been, so we're down to I think maybe around 100 customers left to migrate and it's only 5% of our revenue, you guys can do the track, so it's coming down. Those last 5%, don't wanna make the effort to move, not ready for it, can we, holding out for an extra price discount, will you take me to a sports game if I promise to migrate, it could be any of those things, right? So I really, it's really just the dogs and cats that are at the end, we are and we'll get through this, committed to migrating every single, upgrading every single customer onto the eight by eight platform and the most interesting is once they're there, they're incredibly happy, they have a full portfolio of new and exciting products and they're buying those once they get there. So it's really just a blocking and tackling of getting those last customers to move there and don't over rotate on the 60% number, it just happens to be, there's timing and pieces, et cetera, how to think about it and so I think Kevin just wants to be really sort of specific about it.
Okay, great, that's super helpful and then just another one from me, I understand not wanting to divulge too much around the ROI of some of those accelerated investments next year, but I guess is there any specific growth opportunities that you've kind of identified that you really wanna go after or is it just more generalized, hey, our foundations are in their place, we see potential to drive more growth going forward so we're gonna tap into that.
Okay, so I don't know how to invest in number two that you listed, I don't do general investments across whatever, right? We invest on specific projects with specific defined outcomes, that's absolutely the case, I absolutely see opportunities in front of us to make those investments and get compelling ROI which then drives future cash flows and then go back to Michael's answer I gave a couple minutes ago.
Okay, great, appreciate it.
Thanks, Rich. Thank you so much and as I see no further questions in queue, I will turn the call back to Samuel Wilson for final remarks.
Thank you so much, operator and thank you for a fantastic call today. In summary, the third quarter was a solid quarter for eight by eight. While the market dynamics remains challenging, we continue to face headwinds as our transition of fused customers to the eight by eight platform, our focus on disciplined execution, strategic differentiation, operational excellence positions us exceptionally well for the future. We're committed to delivering value to our customers, our partners, our shareholders as we drive innovation and transform business communications into intelligent customer experiences and lastly, thank you to you, the analysts who were on the call, thank you to our investors and thank you to my employees. I love each and every one of you. Thank you for your continued support.
And thank you and with that, we conclude today's conference call. Thank you all for participating and you may now disconnect.