This conference call transcript was computer generated and almost certianly contains errors. This transcript is provided for information purposes only.EarningsCall, LLC makes no representation about the accuracy of the aforementioned transcript, and you are cautioned not to place undue reliance on the information provided by the transcript.
Operator
Welcome to 2Cal's 4th Quarter 2023 Management Commentary. We have pre-recorded prepared remarks regarding the quarter and outlook for the company. A 2Cal's generated transcript of these remarks, with relevant links, is also available on the company's website. In lieu of a live question and answer period following these remarks, shareholders, analysts, and prospective investors are invited to submit questions to 2Cows Management. Please submit questions via email to ir at 2cows.com until Thursday, February 29th. Management will either address your questions directly or provide a recorded audio response and transcript that will be posted to the 2Cows website on Tuesday, March 12th at approximately 4 p.m. Eastern Time. We would also like to advise that the updated 2COWS quarterly KPI summary, which provides key metrics for all of our businesses for the last eight quarters, as well as for full years 2021, 2022, and 2023, and also includes historical financial results, is available in the investor section of the website, along with the updated TingBuild scorecard and investor presentation. Now for management's prepared remarks. On Thursday, February 22nd, 2Cows issued a news release reporting its financial results for the fourth quarter ended December 31st, 2023. That news release and the company's financial statements are available on the company's website at 2cows.com under the Investors section. Please note that the following discussion may include forward-looking statements, which are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially. These risk factors are described in detail in the company's documents filed with the SEC, specifically the most recent reports on the Forms 10-K and 10-Q. The company urges you to read its security filings for a full description of the risk factors applicable to its business. I would now like to turn the call over to 2COWS President and Chief Executive Officer, Elliot Noss. Go ahead, Elliot.
Elliot Noss
Thanks, Monica. We finished 2023 with positive momentum in all of our businesses. 2COWS adjusted EBITDA for 2023 outside of Ting was $59.6 million and with Ting was $15.5 million at the higher end of our annual guidance range. This was driven by robust growth from WaveLo and consistent performance of 2COW's domains and offset by our continued investment in Ting. 2COW's consolidated revenue grew 10% year over year, and a strong finish to the year helped drive 2COW's operating cash flow to $9 million in the fourth quarter, up from $2.9 million in Q4 of last year. We also repaid a further $11.5 million on the balance of the non-Ting syndicated loan this quarter, which takes us to $28 million paid down in 2023. Now that we've continued deleveraging and are squarely focused on addressing the financing challenges of the Ting business, which spilled over to TCX, we are more and more getting back to two cows being a cash-generating machine. which is the right place to be in today's macroeconomic environment. Again this year, we've authorized a buyback program for up to $40 million in 2COW stock. We do this every year, whether or not we can foresee using it at the time we do the authorization. This is a formality. Now we'll hear from the heads of each business, as well as from our CFO, Dave Singh, who will cover our financial results in detail. The first speaker is Dave Warrick, Chief Executive Officer, Two Cows Domains. Go ahead, Dave.
Monica
Thanks, Elliot. As we close out our fiscal 2023, I'm particularly pleased that Two Cows Domains grew revenue and gross margin on a quarter-over-quarter basis through successive quarters of 2023. Our core business is healthy, and we're rolling out new products for our resellers. And importantly, 2COW's domains continues to generate cash for the company that is being used to pay down the debt and build the runway for 2COW's long-term growth. In Q4, we saw slight gains across all our top-level metrics, including domains under management and transactions. Revenue for domain services for the fourth quarter was $61.8 million. up 2.5% from $60.3 million for the same quarter last year. Gross margin was $18.9 million, also up 2.5% from the same quarter last year. and domain services adjusted EBITDA, which was 10.8 million in the fourth quarter, was up 2% from Q4 of last year, as we continue to be attentive to managing expenses. The results were driven by an increase in the number of transactions in Q4, up 2%, and domains under management that were up slightly year over year. I would like to highlight that within our industry, there is a range in the quality of new domains being registered. and our growth continues to be concentrated in higher quality and legitimate domain registrations. Looking at the results from the segments of our business, in our wholesale channel, revenue for Q4 was up 2% compared to Q4 of last year, and gross margin was essentially unchanged year over year. Within the wholesale channel, domain services gross margin was up 4% in Q4 compared to the same period last year, while value-added services gross margin was down 8%. I'll note that the decline in the domains aftermarket that I covered in the last couple of quarters is no longer a factor for value-added services. The Q4 decline in value-added services was actually a result of something we periodically do at the reseller's request, which is to move their customers from the wholesale business to our retail business, which shifts the associated revenues and margin from value-added services to retail. In our retail channel, revenue was up 4.5% and gross margin was up 8% year over year. The outsized retail margin was a result of the shift of customers I mentioned, which started in Q4 and will impact retail margin numbers over the course of 12 months. Our combined overall renewal rate at 76.5% in Q4 across all 2COWS domains brands remains within our historical range and above the industry average. I also have a short update and further background on the new billing and provisioning service and the automation tools that enable resellers to transition to cloud hosting. We have these in the hands of a number of resellers who are providing us feedback and helping us iterate. If you would like more detail on these new services, please refer to my comments last quarter. And as a reminder, we've developed these new products within our existing cost structure, which means we're able to prove the concept with investment that is invisible to investors and improve it along the way without major cost impacts. It is the margin of these new products that is so compelling to us. Two cows domains has been generating about 75 million in gross margin for several years in a mature and competitive industry with limited prospects for growth. We've been very comfortable operating with the razor thin margins of our current domains business. In fact, as many of you know, we have successfully turned this into a moat around the business. However, the margins from these two new opportunities are significantly higher than our typical domain name margins. Deploying higher margin products is critical for us to meaningfully get beyond the $75 million gross margin range. I am optimistic about the potential for these new services, and I will keep you apprised of their progress. Now, over to Justin Riley, CEO of Wavela.
Elliot
Thanks, Dave. 2023 marks Wavelow's second full year as an independent business. A year ago, and at Investor Day, I shared how pleased I was with the foundation laid to generate $25 to $30 million in revenue. As we sit here today, Wavelow generated $38.7 million in revenue in 2023, averaging north of a 50% compound annual growth rate over the last two years. while other B2B SaaS companies' growth rates nearly halved over the same period. Gross margin for the full year 2023 was 36 million, up from 21.4 million in 2022. Adjusted EBITDA was $10.6 million, outperforming our upgraded guidance of $4-6 million and up from $3.9 million last year. This full-year performance represents what this business can be when its customers reach a level of scale on the platform. That said, I want to be clear that we expect growth to come in much lower in 2024 as we invest in new customers and battle an increasingly competitive software market. This is in the context of a startup macro environment that is in the midst of a flight to quality. Remember, our slight step back in profitability is everyone else's cash burn. In the quarter, Wavelow's revenues were $9.5 million, down 13.8% from Q3 and up 113% from Q4 2022. Gross margin was $9.2 million in Q4, down 12.3% from Q3 and up 142% year over year. Adjusted EBITDA for Q4 was $2.6 million, down 38% from Q3 and up 328% year over year. The quarter-over-quarter trend represents a couple things. First, we recognize extra deferred revenue from DISH every year in Q3, which provides a bump across all metrics in the third quarter. And second, dishes shift in focus from prepaid to postpaid as those subscriber bases haven't yet stabilized. In addition, the adjusted EBITDA trend quarter over quarter reflects an increased investment in our growth teams to support the coming years. The Wavelow story is yet another chapter in a 30-year history of two cows leveraging existing assets, competencies, and relationships in service of customer and shareholder value. This was true in OpenSRS, it was true in both Ting businesses, and it is now true in WaveLo. An intense focus on simplicity, efficiency, and customer experience drives our day-to-day operations, as well as our long-term view of the opportunity in telecom software. It is at the heart of that opportunity that I'm happy to announce that since I last reported, we've added three new customers to the WaveLo family. These represent a mix of net new logos and cloud upgrades that I discussed last quarter, further reinforcing the strong appetite for telecoms to move to the cloud and shift towards more customer-centric software. As I shared at Investor Day, we are seeing solid traction with small to mid-size ISPs with a focus on automating end-to-end billing and provisioning, as well as adding mobile as a value-added service. Unlike MNOs, These operators are on their first re-platform and have a tremendous opportunity to leapfrog the legacy software pitfalls in telecom. In the quarter, the team continued the trend of adding new qualified opportunities to the pipeline. With this steady pipeline, our focus is on building a machine that elegantly closes and onboards customers without all of the pain that is all too common in these implementations. We have a busy year ahead of us navigating the laborious procurement cycles that telecom is famous for. I'll remind investors that our sales and marketing team is small but mighty, representing a much smaller spend as a percentage of revenue than our competitors. In 2024, we expect to grow the team in service of growing the pipeline while focusing on efficiency and staying well below the market on spend. Thanks for listening. And now over to Elliot.
Elliot Noss
Thanks, Justin. Q4 was another very strong quarter of construction for Ting, resulting in 27% year-over-year growth of completed serviceable addresses, taking us to 121,300 serviceable addresses for Ting-owned infrastructure. Our partner markets are also ramping up with 54% growth in addresses year-over-year, This brings us to 150,700 total serviceable addresses across all Ting footprints. Ting subscribers grew 26% year over year in the fourth quarter, taking us to over 43,000 in total. Revenue for Q4 grew 21% year over year to $13.8 million, and gross margin grew 9.3% year over year to $7.9 million. Adjusted EBITDA came in negative $12.4 million. As I have previously stated, this number is too high. We have started to address it this quarter and will continue to until we are in a more appropriate position. Our fibre capex has increased from Q3 of 2023, but at $18 million for Q4 is still lower than our spends earlier in the year. In Q3, that was mostly a reflection of our transition to a new microtrenching vendor in Alexandria. In Q4 and into 2024, you will see us a little more considered as the fiber market continues to evolve. Heading into 2024, the coax to fiber transition is coming into sharper relief. We are now well into this process. We have always talked about every fiber market as having the same three ingredients of capital, construction, and ISP operation. We have always identified the strategic element of those three for us as the ISP. Any financial sponsor, be it private equity, infra fund, or family office, see capital as their strategic element. Our mid-market fiber colleagues all have existing financial sponsors, thus are much more focused on fully integrated operations. We see larger and larger pools of capital focus on the infrastructure side of the market, and we do not see many others focusing on being partner ISPs. As we look at Ting in 2024, we see this clearly. The two largest markets for us will be Colorado Springs and Memphis, two of the top 40 cities in the U.S., and both partner markets. In 2024, we expect more additional opportunities to come in the partner space relative to building organically. That does not take away from the organic build plan that we have, but we are following the money as the very biggest pools of capital are attracted to the partner space. We also continue to watch the first wave of companies who were externally funded in this coax to fiber cycle having to come back to the market and not finding it as receptive as when the original financings were done. 2024 promises to be interesting in this regard. Our years of experience with partner markets has taught us that their biggest drawback is inconsistent delivery. Over the years, this has led to us wasting significant amounts of operating dollars on marketing and other operations. At the same time, we have developed real competency in our construction operations. We have started investigating how we can use our construction skills to help with better partner delivery. The good news here is that partners are very open to these discussions. Over time, we also expect to get more involved in creating new opportunities and choosing markets with selected partners. As part of our increased focus on partner opportunities, loading our current networks, and building out our current footprints, we looked closely at the underlying operations. we saw that Ting's business needs have evolved and are ultimately different today than when we first started 10 years ago. We spent a decade building a large, complicated business. We are now moving from building core business functions to being able to run and operate them efficiently. We've realized that some business functions have changed and some are not as material as we originally envisioned. Because of this, we made the decision to reduce the Ting workforce to match the current operational priorities of the business. This impacted 72 employees, approximately 13% of Ting's workforce. As well, we've made the decision to cease activity related to our partner market in Mesa, Arizona, and to reprioritize resources on other opportunities. Since we announced Mesa last March, we've been working with our infrastructure partner to talk through issues of competition and overbuilding. We continue to prefer markets with only one fiber overbuilder. We recently announced a new organic build in Thornton, Colorado, which will add approximately 60,000 serviceable addresses to our Denver footprint. Construction will start in the next few months and service is expected to be live later this year. Although our largest opportunities will be with partner markets, we will continue to thoughtfully add organic builds in existing footprints where economics and logistics work. For example, If we're in the back half of an organic build in a nearby market, the new market is essentially a market expansion that utilizes our existing local operation. We're excited about Thornton as the city has been highly engaged and is eager to facilitate a fiber build out there. Now we'll hear from 2Cow CFO Dave Singh, who will discuss our financial results in detail.
Justin
Thanks, Elliot. Total revenue for the fourth quarter of 2023 increased 10.2% to $87 million compared to $78.9 million for the fourth quarter of 2022. When looking across the different businesses, Ting had revenue gains of 21% year-over-year, increasing to $13.8 million in Q4 2023 from $11.5 million in Q4 2022. We have those revenues increased 113% to $9.5 million in Q4 2023 from $4.5 million in Q4 2022. And the revenue for two-house domains for Q4 was up 2.6% increasing to $61.8 million from $60.3 million in Q4 2022. There was a small offset to the revenue gains of the three businesses by a decline in corporate segment revenues of 34% year-over-year from $2.7 million in Q4 2022 to $1.8 million in Q4 2023. The decline was primarily driven by lower revenues from legacy mobile subscribers retained in the sale of Ting mobile subscribers to DISH, as well as higher intercompany eliminations. Gross profit before network costs for the fourth quarter increased 19.5% year-over-year to $35.5 million from $29.7 million in Q4 2022. As a percentage of revenue, gross profit before network costs increased this quarter to 41% compared to 38% for Q4 2022. Breaking down gross profit by business, 2K's domains gross profit for the fourth quarter of 2023 increased 2.5% from Q4 last year to $18.9 million from $18.4 million. As a percentage of revenue, gross margin for 2K's domains remained unchanged year-over-year at 31% for Q4 2023. Waveless gross profit increased by 142% to $9.2 million this quarter from $3.8 million for Q4 2022 as Waveless finished its second quarter with fully loaded Boost subscribers. As a percentage of revenue, gross margin for Wavelow was 97% this quarter, which is up from 85% in Q4 of last year. The increased margin is a reflection of Wavelow's increased efficiency from the fully migrated DISH subscriber base. Ting gross profit for Q4 increased 9.3% year-over-year to $7.9 million from $7.2 million for the same period of last year. As a percentage of revenue, gross margin for Ting was 57% in the fourth quarter of 2023, down from 63% in Q4 of last year. Network expenses for Q4 increased 39% to $17.6 million from $12.7 million for the same period last year. This increase continues to be driven primarily by higher depreciation of our expanding fiber network assets, up 19.5% year-over-year, as well as pupil costs of managing our expanding network. Total operating expenses for the fourth quarter of 2023 increased 13% to $33.9 million from $30 million for the same period last year. The increase is primarily the result of expansion of the Ting and WaveLo businesses, specifically in the following call centers. People costs were up $2.2 million, with increased workforce costs to support business expansion related to the growth of Ting and WaveLo. Marketing costs increased $1.7 million year-over-year, mainly driven by increased investments in the Ting Internet business expansion. Third-party contractor costs, professional fees, travel, and facilities costs were up $2 million. There were offsets to the operating expense decreases, including stock-based compensation decreased $1.6 million, primarily from sizable subsidiary grants in Q4 2022. Foreign exchange gains reduced expenses by $0.2 million this quarter. And finally, impact from depreciation of property and equipment and amortization of intangible assets is down $0.2 million. I will also note that on February 7th, 2024, Ting undertook a reduction in workforce to reflect ongoing operational prioritizations of the Ting business and to lower the company's year-over-year operating expenses. We estimate incurring non-recurring charges of approximately $4 million, primarily consisting of severance payments, notice pay, employee benefits contributions, and outplacement costs. We expect that the implementation of the headcount reductions, majority of the restructuring charges, and cash payments will be incurred in the first quarter of fiscal 2024. As a percentage of revenue, year-over-year operating expenses were relatively stable at just under 39% for Q4 of this year and 38% for the same period last year. We reported a net loss for the fourth quarter of 2023 of $23.4 million, or a loss of $2.14 per share, compared with a net loss of $13.5 or $1.25 per share for the fourth quarter of 2022. The net loss is primarily the result of the ongoing investment in construction of Ting's fiber networks and scaling up of the associated operations, higher network depreciation, and higher interest expenses from both higher interest rates and increased debt. Please note that our tax expense reflects our geographic mix with taxes payable in Canada and our legacy domains business. Adjusted EBITDA for Q4 was $2.6 million, down 62% from $6.7 million for Q4 2022. Primarily driven by our investment in the Ting business, the total breaks down amongst our three businesses as follows. Adjusted EBITDA for Duke House Domains was $10.8 million, up 2.1% from Q4 of last year. Adjusted EBITDA for Wavela was $2.6 million, an increase of $3.7 million from a loss of $1.1 million last year. Adjusted EBITDA for Ting was negative $12.4 million compared with negative $6 million in Q4 2022 as we continue to invest in our fiber network expansion. And finally, the corporate category had adjusted EBITDA of $1.5 million this quarter down from $3.3 million in Q4 last year. The decrease is primarily driven by lower contribution from the legacy mobile base and higher intercompany eliminations. Turning to our balance sheet, cash and cash equivalents at the end of Q4 were 92.7 million, compared with 110.7 million at the end of the third quarter of 2023, and 23.5 million at the end of the fourth quarter of 2022. In addition to the $92.7 million, we have $12.3 million classified as restricted cash as part of the ABS transaction last May. As a reminder, of the $12.3 million of restricted cash, $8.7 will sit in a trust account for the duration of the ABS notes. The remaining $3.6 million reflects the cash collections from the securitized assets and is distributed monthly as interest to note holders, fees to third parties, and with the remaining funds coming back to Ting. I'll also note that we generated $1.3 million in interest income this quarter. During the quarter, we had $9 million in cash from operations compared with $2.9 million in Q4 last year, with the increase driven primarily by working capital timing and efficiency and a timing reset of quarterly syndicated interest payments into the first week of the following quarter. We invested $14.6 million in property and equipment primarily for the continued build-out of the Ting Fiber Network in addition to the continued investment in the Wavelo platform. Note that this number reflects the actual cash paid for capital assets in the quarter on a cash flow statement and includes capitalized cash interest. As of December 31st, 2023, our syndicated loan balance for covenant calculation purposes was a net $205 million when factoring in letters of credit and cash on hand of up to $7.5 million, which resulted in a leverage ratio of 3.42 times. This is the third consecutive quarter we have reduced the leverage ratio. be repaid a net $11.5 million on the balance of the loan this quarter and expect quarterly repayments to continue. Finally, deferred revenue at the end of Q4 was $148 million, down from $150 million for the third quarter of 2023, but up from $145 million for the fourth quarter of last year. This is primarily due to the stabilization of domain revenues now that the pandemic impacts have normalized. That concludes my remarks and I'll now turn it back to Elliot.
Elliot Noss
Thanks, Dave. Let me start with guidance for our businesses for 2024. For 2COW's domains, we're giving adjusted EBITDA guidance of $43 million. For Wavelow, we're giving guidance of $8 to $10 million. And for our corporate segment, $2 to $4 million for a total of $53 to $57 million. Even the recent changes at Ting, we're working through a more refined guidance estimate for that business, which we will share with you when we have it but in no event later than next quarter's results and with an intention of reducing the EBITDA loss. As I start to look out over 2024, I see clear paths for all three businesses. For 2COW's domains, turn the new offerings into real contributors. For Wavelo, generate a pipeline of new customers. For Ting, clean up the balance sheet and load the network. With Ting, I find myself thinking about time and timing. Time in the sense of the pace of the coax to fiber transition in the U.S. Timing in the sense that when one engages in anything dealing with the balance sheet or the cap table, when is often more important than what. And timing of the coax to fiber transition is one arc, while macroeconomic conditions are another. Let's call those micro and macro. fiber and the general economy. We feel very good about where we are in the fiber arc. We and the industry are now comfortably into the execution phase of this cycle. We see a lot of building activity across the country. We believe the industry is 18 to 36 months away from most footprints that will be part of this cycle being commenced. There will still be three to five years of building after that, but in our view, it is too late for new entrants and it will shortly be too late for new footprints. We are well positioned in the first tier of middle market players. While we have capital to take us through the next leg of our build, I have been clear that this level of EBITDA losses and this level of debt are not acceptable. This is primarily because we do not want to risk being in a position of need in this macro environment. That means we are looking to strengthen our balance sheet. As I have said numerous times over numerous earnings calls, we are lucky to have lots of different arrows in the quiver. We are not, however, in the best macro environment to be dealing with this. There are two thoughts I want to be clear about, and these two thoughts are the reason I have presented this story to this point. First, the micro arc dominates the macro arc. By that, I mean that making sure that Ting is in position to benefit from this generational transition to infrastructure purpose-built for the internet is the most important thing. The fiber to the home business takes a lot of capital, effort, and patience. It makes money slowly and for a long time. Second, strengthening the balance sheet is a means to an end. Whatever we do in the nearer term will simply be putting us in a position to create long-term value for shareholders for a long time to come. If we would have sat down in 2014 and shown ourselves the future in 2024, we would have been very pleased. We would have seen a strong and growing fiber footprint, a fascinating evolution of the structural separation between ownership of infrastructure and operating an ISP. And most importantly, we would have seen Ting as an ISP with industry-leading take rate, churn, and customer satisfaction. all of which is a recipe for long-term success. And with that, I look forward to your written questions and exploring areas that interest you in greater detail. Again, please send your questions to ir2cows.com by February 29th and look for our recorded Q&A audio response and transcript to this call to be posted to the 2Cows website on Tuesday, March 12th at approximately 4 p.m. Eastern Time. Thank you.
Disclaimer