Cabot Corporation

Q2 2023 Earnings Conference Call

5/9/2023

spk07: 23 earnings conference call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. After the speaker presentation, there will be a question and answer session. To ask a question during the session, you will need to press star 1-1 on your telephone. To remove yourself from the question queue, press star 1-1 again. I would now like to hand the call over to Vice President, Treasurer, Investor Relations, Steve Delat. Please go ahead.
spk09: Good morning. I would like to welcome you to the Catholic Corporation Earnings Teleconference. With me today are Sean Cohane, CEO and President, and Erica McLaughlin, Executive Vice President and CFO. Last night, we released results for our second quarter of fiscal year 2023, copies of which are posted in the investor relations section of our website. The slide deck that accompanies this call is also available in the investor relations portion of our website and will be available in conjunction with the replay of the call. During this conference call, we will make forward-looking statements about our expected future operational and financial performance. Each forward-looking statement is subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from those projected in such statements. Additional information regarding these factors appears in the press release we issued last night and in our 10-K for the fiscal year ended September 30, 2022. and in subsequent filings we make with the SEC, all of which are also available on the company's website. In order to provide greater transparency regarding our operating performance, we refer to certain non-GAAP financial measures that involve adjustments to GAAP results. The non-GAAP financial measures referenced on this call are reconciled to the most directly comparable GAAP financial measure in a table at the end of our earnings release issued last night and available in the investor section of our website. I will now turn the call over to Sean, who will discuss the second quarter highlights, including progress against our sustainability strategy and an update on our battery material business. Eric will review the company and business segment results along with some corporate financial details. Following this, Sean will provide a strategic summary and closing comments and open the floor to questions. Sean?
spk05: Thank you, Steve. Good morning, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to our call today. I am pleased with results in the second quarter and the tremendous effort of the Cabot team to execute against the challenging macroeconomic backdrop. In the second fiscal quarter, we delivered adjusted earnings per share of $1.33 in line with our expectations and up 35% sequentially. Reinforcement materials delivered a record quarter with EBIT up 21% year over year. The outlook for this business remains strong, driven by our leading market position, the long-term resilience of the replacement tire market, and favorable structural dynamics in this business. The performance chemical segment had a challenging quarter, as we experienced lower demand in China due to significant levels of COVID outbreak, softness in key end markets, and continued inventory destocking. As expected, cash flow was strong in the quarter, with operating cash flow of $162 million and free cash flow of $111 million, of which we returned $37 million to shareholders through dividends and share repurchases. Given the strength of our underlying business fundamentals and conviction in the long-term cash flow generation of our portfolio, yesterday we announced an 8% increase in our quarterly dividends. Cabot has a long history of growing the dividend, and it would be our expectation to continue increasing the dividend over time as the earnings and cash flow of our business grow. On the strategic front, we continue to make important long-term progress in battery materials, with volumes growing 45% in the quarter despite a sharp sequential slowdown in electric vehicle sales in the March quarter. Additionally, we secured another key customer win in the quarter, and now have sales to nine of the top 10 global battery manufacturers. Diving a bit deeper into battery materials, the electrification of mobility represents a significant growth opportunity for Cabot, and we continue to invest behind this macro trend. While we believe the long-term trend of electric vehicle penetration is undeniable, market developments from quarter to quarter can be uneven. This is certainly what the electric vehicle sector experienced in the March quarter. Electric vehicle sales declined sequentially by 27% in the March quarter, driven principally by COVID impacts in China and a sharp decline in prices of key raw materials for batteries, such as lithium carbonate, which drove a sharp destocking across the industry value chain. While Cabot's volumes for battery materials continue to reflect strong year-over-year growth of 45%, sequential sales volumes decreased by 11%. We expect these impacts to be short-term in nature and anticipate sequential improvement in the coming quarters in line with the Bloomberg EV forecast. So far through April, our volumes are aligned with this improving trend. The temporary loss of market momentum sequentially in the second quarter and the projection for recovery of EV sales over the next two quarters puts us behind where we expected to be year to date in sales volumes for battery materials. Additionally, we are seeing some delays in battery production scale-up of a key U.S. auto OEM. Based on these factors and our continued investment profile to support long-term growth, We now anticipate fiscal year 2023 EBITDA to be in the range of 30 to 35 million for battery materials. We continue to believe that electrification will transform the mobility sector and are very pleased with our commercial progress to date. We've been qualified and are selling commercially to nine of the top 10 battery producers and are well positioned with key auto OEMs as they build out battery production capability. Cabot's value proposition, built on our unique product breadth, global footprint, and ability to scale capacity to meet the industry's regionalization needs is resonating with customers. While the growth pathway may be uneven at times, we are investing to win over the long term and remain confident in our investor day projections of 50% plus EBIT growth between 2021 and 2024. Sustainability is at the core of our purpose and our Creating for Tomorrow strategy, and during the quarter, we made important progress on several strategic fronts. At the recent Tire Technology Expo in Hanover, Germany, we launched our Evolve Sustainable Solutions technology platform, which is focused on advancing sustainable reinforcing carbons. Our goal through this technology platform is to develop products for our customers that offer sustainable content with reliable performance and importantly, at industrial scale. We plan to do this by leveraging circular value chains and materials recovered from end-of-life tires, using renewable or bio-based materials, and enabling processes that reduce greenhouse gas emissions. As part of the Evolve platform, we also launched Cabot's first ISCC Plus certified solutions. which are enabling our tire customers to bring demonstration products to the market made from circular materials. Our market leadership, global footprint, and broad Evolve and E2C technology platforms position Cabot to partner and win with leading customers as the mobility sector transitions to meet society's sustainability demands. In addition, last week we announced the launch of our new Entera Aerogel Particles portfolio. Interra aerogel particles are a thermal insulation additive targeted for thermal barrier solutions for electric vehicle lithium ion batteries. We believe thermal management will be an important design feature of safe batteries and expect there will be a variety of application forms that serve this market. Cabot's aerogel products provide customers with formulation flexibility to develop very thin forms, including blankets, pads, sheets, films, foams, and coatings. Over time, we believe that aerogel solutions can develop into a meaningful addition to our battery materials addressable market and further position Cabot as a critical material supplier to support the global transition to vehicle electrification. And finally, our sustainability leadership continues to gain recognition from leading ESG rating services. Most recently, Cabot received a platinum rating from EcoVedas. the highest recognition available for the third consecutive year. The platinum rating recognizes Cabot's environmental, social, and governance efforts and places Cabot among the top 1% of companies assessed by EcoVedas. EcoVedas is one of the world's leading sustainability ratings platforms and one that many of our customers rely on to evaluate their supply chains. I'll now turn the call over to Erika to discuss the segment and financial performance. Erika?
spk16: Thanks, Sean. I will start with discussing results for the company and then review the segment results. Adjusted EPS for the second quarter of fiscal 2023 was $1.33 compared to $1.69 in the second quarter of fiscal 2022, with growth in the reinforcement materials segment offset by declines in the performance chemical segment. The quarter was also impacted by higher net interest expense of $7 million year-over-year and unfavorable foreign currency exchange impacts of $7 million. Year-to-date impacts from increases in net interest expenses are 14 million, and our expectation for the fiscal year is unchanged from last quarter at approximately 20 million. Year-to-date unfavorable impacts from foreign currency exchange were 19 million, and we expect the year-over-year impacts to be somewhat minimal going forward for the second half of the year. Discretionary free cash flow in the quarter was $76 million, and we ended the quarter with $205 million of cash. Cash flow from operations was $162 million, which included a reduction in networking capital in the quarter of $59 million. The reduction was in line with what I highlighted in our expectation last quarter, and looking ahead, we expect a further reduction in networking capital in excess of $50 million over the two remaining quarters of the fiscal year. based on the current future expectation for oil prices. CapEx in the quarter was $51 million, and we expect full year CapEx to be between $250 and $300 million. The balance sheet remains strong with total liquidity of $1.2 billion and net debt to EBITDA of 1.8 times as of March 31st. Our operating tax rate was 25% for the quarter, and we anticipate the fiscal year rate will be between 24% and 26%. Now moving to reinforcement materials. During the second quarter, EBIT for reinforcement materials increased by $21 million as compared to the same period in the prior year, to a record EBIT of $122 million. The increase was driven by improved unit margins from higher pricing and product mix in our 2023 calendar year customer agreements, partially offset by 7% lower volumes and higher fixed costs. Globally, volumes were down in all regions in the second quarter as compared to the same period of the prior year, with declines of 2% in the Americas, 2% in Europe, and 12% in Asia. Lower volumes in Asia were driven by the effects from the COVID outbreaks in China. Looking to the third quarter of fiscal 2023, we expect the reinforcement materials EBIT to increase sequentially, as volumes are expected to improve, particularly in Asia as demand strengthens after the impact from the COVID-19 outbreak. Year-over-year volumes in the third quarter are expected to be slightly down as compared to the prior year, aligned with external market expectations. We also anticipate margins to be maintained as pricing in our calendar year agreements are set for the rest of the year. On a fiscal year basis, we continue to expect strong double-digit EBIT growth as compared to last year, largely due to the improved unit margins from higher pricing and product mix in our 2023 calendar year customer agreement. Now turning to performance chemicals, EBIT decreased by $42 million in the second fiscal quarter as compared to the same period in fiscal 2022. The decrease was principally driven by our few metal oxides product line, where we experienced a 22% volume decline year over year and lower unit margins. Lower volumes were driven by weaker demand in silicones applications and the impact from the COVID outbreaks in China. Lower margins were driven by the comparison to the prior year, where we experienced temporary margin expansion from pricing ahead of raw materials last year. In addition, the segment also experienced lower volumes in our specialty carbons product line, as well as the negative impact from unabsorbed costs as we reduced inventory levels and unfavorable foreign exchange impacts. In summary, year over year, the decline was driven by $18 million of lower volumes, $15 million of lower unit margins, $4 million from the impact of reducing inventory levels, and $4 million of unfavorable foreign currency impacts. Looking ahead to the third quarter of fiscal 2023, we expect EBIT to be up sequentially due to higher volumes across all of our product lines as demand in our TN markets improves and margins remain relatively stable. We have seen improvement in segment volumes month to month as we move through the second quarter. We have also reduced costs across the segment given the weaker demand environment, which we expect will help improve EBIT levels in the second half of the year. I will now turn the call back over to Sean.
spk05: Thanks, Erica. Moving to the 2023 outlook, I feel very good about the continued progress we are making as a company despite the short-term macroeconomic headwinds. At a strategic level, the key drivers of earnings growth remain unchanged. The impact from our calendar year 2023 reinforcement materials customer agreements is driving the record second quarter EBIT in this segment, and the replacement nature of the tire market provides a certain resilience in this business. We expect volumes to pick up in the second half of the year with regional supply-demand dynamics expected to remain tight, all of which drives our expectation for another year of strong double-digit EBIT growth in the reinforcement materials segment. And while performance chemicals has been impacted by the weak external demand environment in the first half of our fiscal year, we expect volumes in all product lines to pick up in the second half of the year. We also expect our growth vectors to be strong contributors to the segment recovery in the second half of the year as sequential volumes improve in battery materials and inkjet volumes accelerate driven by penetration in our targeted growth applications. However, given the slower than expected recovery across our performance chemicals and markets, particularly in China, and a temporary slowdown of sequential momentum in battery materials, We're adjusting our full year guidance to be in the range of $6.10 to $6.50. The midpoint of our guidance would imply modest growth of adjusted earnings per share for the fiscal year, which for us, given our fiscal year, includes a very weak December destocking quarter. As we think about the quarterly shape of earnings for the full fiscal year, we expect a significant step up in the second half relative to the first half. providing strong momentum heading into fiscal year 2024. As the earnings increase in the second half of our fiscal year, and based on the anticipated working capital release, we expect operating cash flow and free cash flow to be very strong. In closing, we are confident in our strategic position and believe that CAPIT offers a unique growth opportunity. Reinforcement Materials is a structurally improved business with strong earnings and cash flow generation. Performance Chemicals is comprised of industry-leading positions with exposure to long-term macro tailwinds. Battery Materials offers the potential for breakout growth, and we have the conviction and the balance sheet to invest behind this transformational shift in mobility. Our portfolio has strong cash flow characteristics, which can fund our advantage growth investments and return cash to shareholders. And finally, we are a recognized leader in sustainability, and this strength underpins our purpose and our Creating for Tomorrow strategy. With these value drivers firmly in place, we remain on track to achieve the targets outlined in our December 2021 Investor Day. Thank you very much for joining us today, and I'll now turn the call over for our Q&A session.
spk07: As a reminder, to ask a question, you will need to press star 11 on your telephone. Again, that's star 11 on your telephone to ask a question. Please stand by while we compile the Q&A roster.
spk22: Our first question comes from the line of John Roberts of Credit Suisse.
spk07: Your question, please, John.
spk19: Thank you. In reinforcement, I assume you've got more price in the U.S. than elsewhere. Could you at least give us a qualitative discussion of the regional price trends?
spk05: Sure, John. I would say the pricing trends across the western market, the western regions were pretty consistent, actually. And that lines up with, you know, the the pretty consistent structural dynamics in the regions in terms of supply demand, you know, growth in entire production, the importance of regionalization of the supply chain, all those factors. So I would say they're actually quite consistent across the western markets.
spk19: And then within the performance segment, could you talk about master batch versus fume metal oxides. And within fume metal oxides, I didn't hear any discussion about the semiconductor market weakness.
spk05: Yeah. So let me touch on the fume metal oxides first, because that's certainly the single biggest driver of the weakness in performance chemicals. Now, the fume metal oxides market serves principally applications in the silicone space. This is by far the largest volume space in the market. And silicones were down very, very sharply in this quarter. You know, there were several public company comps in this silicone space, and you can see that their results were down sharply. So I think our dynamic is similar to the overall market. And as Erica said, volumes were down 22%. Uh, year over year in this, uh, in this product line, and as you might recall from from the past or investor day, this, uh, this product line is the highest margin business in the in the segment. So, when you combine that with the high operating leverage in the business, it's a pretty, it's, it's pretty significant. Now, there are, uh, there are also silica sales, fume silica sales into the semiconductor space. Those have diminished over time as next-generation nodes have moved to other forms of abrasive particle, either colloidal silica or seria, so products that we don't participate in. That being said, we do still have a meaningful legacy tail of silica into the CMP or semiconductor space, and that, too, was declining, but the largest driver here, John, was the contraction or the lower demand in the overall silicones space.
spk22: Thank you.
spk07: Again, to ask a question, press star 11. Our next question. comes from the line of Josh Spector, UBS. Your question, please, Josh.
spk10: Yeah, hi. Thanks for taking my question. In your slides, you have a comment on performance chems that margins are expected to remain stable from 2Q23 levels. I wanted to really understand that more. I mean, your margins were about 9% in the quarter. You talked about cost savings. You talked about improvements. Do you mean that they're going to be stable at that level or they're going to improve from those levels?
spk05: What we mean, Josh, is that the unit margin, so price minus variable cost, will remain stable. Obviously, the EBITDA margins will improve over the quarter as we get higher volumes and more coverage of the cost base and then some of the cost actions that we're talking about. flow through. So when we say margins, we're talking about that sort of price minus raw spread. That's what we mean.
spk10: Okay, got it. That makes sense. And just, you know, on your battery materials business, where you talk about the new wind, where you're now serving nine of the 10 largest producers, I was wondering if you can give some context around there. Are any of those exclusive are you supplying the majority of the conductive carbons into those formulations or are you more qualified for that platform so how much of that materializes into sales specifically for cabot versus giving you the optionality to do so yeah so the way it typically works in battery materials is you get qualified into a battery program or a battery platform
spk05: And then as that platform grows and proliferates, then you grow with it. So that's typically how it works. So, for example, legacy platforms that Cabot may not have been in, typically those don't get switched out. It has much more to do with winning new programs. So as the program ramps, then we would expect our sales volumes to ramp up with that. Now, typically, because these are going into automotive applications, there's usually a primary and a secondary supplier to a program because the auto OEs require that sort of supply redundancy. But it's really program driven, Josh, and so as the program ramps, assuming the success that the customer you know, intends, then we would see the flow through of that.
spk22: Okay. Thanks, Sean. Thank you.
spk07: Our next question comes from the line of Jeff Zakowskis of JPMorgan. Your line is open, Jeff.
spk13: Hi, morning. This is Lydia on for Jeff. It seems like contract renegotiation for rubber black has started early this year.
spk11: What are you seeing across different regions?
spk05: Sorry, Lydia, could you just say that again? I said something about contracts and regions. Sorry.
spk13: Yeah, it's just we've heard that the contract renegotiation for rubber black has started early this year. So, just wondering, what are you seeing for pricing across different regions?
spk05: Yeah, so it is early in the process. So, normally the contract discussions begin over the course of the summer and then progress into the fall period. And so, you know, certain customers have approached us to start negotiations for 2024. I think there are a lot of moving parts. However, I think what happens as the Russia sanction date nears in 2024 and and how to China feedstock economics as potential replacement for the Russian material. For example, in Europe, you know, these are important dynamics to watch. So I would say it's early in the process here. I would remind you that we did close some negotiations in 2023 that were multi-year agreements with incremental pricing in 2024. So I think this does give us some momentum heading into 2024, and it does set a market reference, but I would say while certain conversations have begun, it's early in the process. That said, I would say the structural supply-demand dynamics in the Western markets remain unchanged and favorable, and so we expect that to continue.
spk13: Thank you. And your cash flow from operations this quarter is higher than for your full year last year. So can you talk about the changes here and maybe talk more about your expectation for the rest of the year?
spk16: Sure. So operating cash flow was strong this quarter. As the EBITDA improved from earlier in the year, that's part of it. And then I would say it's really working capital. And so last year, we had increasing raw material costs that caused increasing levels of investment into the working capital. We see that those raw material costs are coming down this year. And so you see a positive contribution or source of cash from working capital in the second quarter. We expect that to continue as we move through the year. So that goes to the comments I made where we would think another in excess of 50 million would be released at a working capital in the back half of the year. And so expect continued very strong cash flow from operations as we go through the rest of 2023. Thank you.
spk22: Thank you.
spk07: Our next question comes from the line of Lawrence Alexander of Jefferies. Please go ahead, Lawrence.
spk18: Hi, it's Dan Roswell for Lawrence. You mentioned the circular tires, the new product. I was just wondering how we should think about the growth within that product. Is it going to be something, I assume not, but is the same growth trajectory as battery materials? Could there be something of that magnitude, or will there be maybe a longer timeline?
spk05: Yeah, you're referring to the Evolve Sustainable Solutions product technology launch, Dan? Yeah, that's correct. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, the technology platform that we launched, our goal here is to develop products that offer sustainable content with reliable performance. And I think most importantly, at industrial scale. And I think we're in a great position to do that. And so we'll be leveraging the circular value chains and materials that are recovered from end-of-life tires. as well as any renewable or bio-based material options, feedstock options, and processes that can reduce the greenhouse gas emissions. So these are the levers that we're pulling under the EVOLVE platform. And so if you think about over time how this should develop, we anticipate driving revenue starting in this year. and we expect to see a material impact from the evolved sustainable solutions over a five to 10-year period is how you ought to think about it. This is driven by the speed of adoption of new technologies in the rubber industry, as well as how our tire customers' greenhouse gas goals set up between here and 2050 carbon neutrality, which they all have goals for that, but how exactly their interim goals in 2030 and between 2030 and 2050, how those line out will drive things too. But I would think about this as a longer-term play that's really getting at the sustainability needs of our customers and, frankly, society's pressures around sustainability. So we're excited about it because we think we bring an ability to develop and commercialize these technologies and do it at scale, which there are startups and the like that play in this space but can't really bring things to market at scale the way we can. So that's how I would think about it, Dan. All right.
spk18: Thank you. And then you mentioned or it was mentioned that there was an improvement in working capital because of the drop in oil prices. I was wondering if there's a rule of thumb with oil and its relation to working capital, such as a $10 movement in oil translates into an X movement in working capital or how we should think about that.
spk16: Sure, Dan. So I can answer that. The general rule of thumb is about a $1 change in oil is about $5 million in in working capital, and so it does usually happen over really two quarters usually, as you'll see the inventory reprice quickly and then the accounts receivable might move into the following quarter, but that's the rule of thumb.
spk12: Thank you very much.
spk07: Thank you. Once again, to ask a question, please press star 11 on your telephone. Our next question comes from the line of Chris Kapsch of Loop Capital. Please go ahead, Chris. Good morning.
spk02: So if I think about the – morning, Dan. So if I think about the guidance, the modest guidance reduction, it sounds like it's predominantly attributable to trends in the performance chemical segment. And you mentioned fume silicones into the silicones industry is the biggest. I don't know if that he can rank order the other contributors, maybe especially carbons. Maybe there's a residual destock there. I don't know if that's second, but then the slower momentum is released temporarily in battery materials. You also mentioned, though, I'm curious if that's kind of the right way to think in terms of order of magnitude, but also just you mentioned improving demand trends for this segment on a monthly basis. Just wondering if you could characterize if that's if that's characteristic of each of those different businesses and how it's persisted, how those trends have persisted thus far into the third quarter through April.
spk05: Maybe on the first question, Erica will take that, and then I'll come back on the second one, Chris.
spk16: Yeah, Chris, I think if you think of the impact in the quarter, fuel metal oxide is by far the largest and majority of the decline. Next, I would say it would be our specialty carbons business. Volumes are down about 5% in that business, which drove a reduction. And most of the inventory or unabsorbed costs because of the inventory reductions is also in carbons. So that would probably be secondary. And then as Sean talked about battery materials, the temporary decline here in EV sales in Q2, was also impactful. So I would probably say it's in that order. As we think about the volume recovery, I'd say it's through Q2 a pretty broad base in terms of month-to-month improvement as we move through the quarter. I would say battery materials also improved in April. So from the exit in Q2 into April, volumes and battery materials have improved. So I think that's good. In some of the other businesses, I'd say April was a bit weaker than March, but I would characterize it as stronger than kind of the January, February run rate. So that's what we've seen in April. And then I'd say the order book for May looks pretty strong across the businesses. And so that's what, you know, our outlook takes into consideration.
spk05: Okay. And then, yeah, and maybe Chris, just a couple of additional comments there. So, again, the, the, the mid point of the range is, you know, would be roughly flat to fiscal 22. but that that was a record and up 25% over fiscal 21. And so a couple of things here. One is that would be a result after offsetting about 50 cents EPS headwind from interest and unfavorable FX. And then also important to remember that given our fiscal year end of September 30, we're pulling in that very weak December quarter. So when you look at second half momentum,
spk02: uh i i think that um that that's an important picture to look at there i think the the monthly trends erica erica touched on well i don't have anything uh more to add on that one got it and then my follow-up is focused on the battery material space and a key theme here has been you know more broadly than just the security of supply concerns for really a variety of battery materials and And to the extent that you're having tremendous success, nine out of the top ten lithium-ion battery producers globally and partnering with them, supplying them, I'm just curious how that theme plays into your relationships with those customers. And obviously you're supplying those now, but do they have expectations for you to partner with them globally? How is that playing out? Do you have visibility to what their demand requirements are going to be? you know, in different regions? And is that, you know, is that starting to play into your, you know, your growth capital plan? Thank you. Yeah, sure.
spk05: Well, certainly, I think a couple of things are going on in the battery market. It's been principally a China market up until now is, you know, well, I think some 75-ish percent batteries, I think, are made in China. So outside of China, it's relatively small. But there are significant battery investments that are being constructed as we speak and coming online over the next two, three years and out into the end of the decade. And so I think a couple of things are going to happen, Chris. First of all, you're seeing a lot of non- Chinese battery players building outside of China. And I think you'll probably see some sort of a bifurcation between a battery market for China and then a rest of world. And so certainly the customers that we're working with in Europe and the U.S., really value regional supply. And so, you know, I think the ability to provide that to them is very important. Now, typically what happens here is that you get qualified in a program with a given battery maker, and then as that particular program or platform proliferates, then you grow with that. So as you get qualified and begin to win, there's a ramp schedule, sometimes hard to predict. That's why I think there can be some unevenness in the way this market develops. But that's how you want to think about it. And I think Cabot's global scale, our footprint, our ability to build out capacity regionally for these customers as this market bifurcates. And I think that's, I think, an advantage for Cabot. And so we're investing behind that and are building out capacity to meet that.
spk21: Thank you.
spk22: Thank you. At this time, I would like to turn the conference back to Sean Cohen for closing remarks.
spk07: Sir?
spk05: Great. Well, thank you very much for joining today. Thank you for your continued support of Cabot Corporation, and I hope you have a safe day. Be well.
spk07: Now, this concludes today's conference call. Thank you for participating. You may now disconnect. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
spk17: Thank you. We'll be right back. you Thank you.
spk07: Thank you for standing by and welcome to Cabot's second quarter 2023 earnings conference call. At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode. After the speaker presentation, there will be a question and answer session. To ask a question during the session, you will need to press star 1-1 on your telephone. To remove yourself from the question queue, press star 1-1 again. I would now like to hand the call over to Vice President, Treasurer, Investor Relations, Steve Delaunt. Please go ahead.
spk09: Good morning. I would like to welcome you to the Cabot Corporation Earnings Teleconference. With me today are Sean Cohane, CEO and President, and Erica McLaughlin, Executive Vice President and CFO. Last night, we released results for our second quarter of fiscal year 2023, copies of which are posted in the Investor Relations section of our website. The slide deck that accompanies this call is also available in the investor relations portion of our website and will be available in conjunction with the replay of the call. During this conference call, we will make forward-looking statements about our expected future operational and financial performance. Each forward-looking statement is subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from those projected in such statements. Additional information regarding these factors appears in the press release we issued last night and in our 10-K for the fiscal year ended September 30, 2022, and in subsequent filings we make with the SEC, all of which are also available on the company's website. In order to provide greater transparency regarding our operating performance, we refer to certain non-GAAP financial measures that involve adjustments to GAAP results. The non-GAAP financial measures referenced on this call are reconciled to the most directly comparable GAAP financial measure in a table at the end of our earnings release issued last night and available in the investors section of our website. I will now turn the call over to Sean, who will discuss the second quarter highlights, including progress against our sustainability strategy and an update on our battery material business. Eric will review the company and business segment results along with some corporate financial details. Following this, Sean will provide a strategic summary and closing comments and open the floor to questions. Sean?
spk05: Thank you, Steve. Good morning, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to our call today. I am pleased with results in the second quarter and the tremendous effort of the Cabot team to execute against the challenging macroeconomic backdrop. In the second fiscal quarter, we delivered adjusted earnings per share of $1.33 in line with our expectations and up 35% sequentially. Reinforcement materials delivered a record quarter with EBIT up 21% year over year. The outlook for this business remains strong, driven by our leading market position, the long-term resilience of the replacement tire market, and favorable structural dynamics in this business. The performance chemical segment had a challenging quarter as we experienced lower demand in China due to significant levels of COVID outbreak, softness in key end markets, and continued inventory destocking. As expected, cash flow was strong in the quarter with operating cash flow of $162 million and free cash flow of $111 million, of which we returned $37 million to shareholders through dividends and share repurchases. Given the strength of our underlying business fundamentals and conviction in the long-term cash flow generation of our portfolio, yesterday we announced an 8% increase in our quarterly dividends. Cabot has a long history of growing the dividend, and it would be our expectation to continue increasing the dividend over time as the earnings and cash flow of our business grow. On the strategic front, we continue to make important long-term progress in battery materials, with volumes growing 45% in the quarter despite a sharp sequential slowdown in electric vehicle sales in the March quarter. Additionally, we secured another key customer win in the quarter and now have sales to nine of the top 10 global battery manufacturers. Diving a bit deeper into battery materials, the electrification of mobility represents a significant growth opportunity for Cabot, and we continue to invest behind this macro trend. While we believe the long-term trend of electric vehicle penetration is undeniable, market developments from quarter to quarter can be uneven. This is certainly what the electric vehicle sector experienced in the March quarter. Electric vehicle sales declined sequentially by 27% in the March quarter, driven principally by COVID impacts in China and a sharp decline in prices of key raw materials for batteries, such as lithium carbonate, which drove a sharp destocking across the industry value chain. While Cabot's volumes for battery materials continue to reflect strong year-over-year growth of 45%, sequential sales volumes decreased by 11%. We expect these impacts to be short-term in nature and anticipate sequential improvement in the coming quarters in line with the Bloomberg EV forecast. So far through April, our volumes are aligned with this improving trend. The temporary loss of market momentum sequentially in the second quarter and the projection for recovery of EV sales over the next two quarters puts us behind where we expected to be year to date in sales volumes for battery materials. Additionally, we are seeing some delays in battery production scale up of a key U.S. auto OEM. Based on these factors and our continued investment profile to support long-term growth, We now anticipate fiscal year 2023 EBITDA to be in the range of 30 to 35 million for battery materials. We continue to believe that electrification will transform the mobility sector and are very pleased with our commercial progress to date. We've been qualified and are selling commercially to nine of the top 10 battery producers and are well positioned with key auto OEMs as they build out battery production capability. Cabot's value proposition, built on our unique product breadth, global footprint, and ability to scale capacity to meet the industry's regionalization needs is resonating with customers. While the growth pathway may be uneven at times, we are investing to win over the long term and remain confident in our investor day projections of 50% plus EBIT growth between 2021 and 2024. Sustainability is at the core of our purpose and our Creating for Tomorrow strategy, and during the quarter, we made important progress on several strategic fronts. At the recent Tire Technology Expo in Hanover, Germany, we launched our Evolve Sustainable Solutions technology platform, which is focused on advancing sustainable reinforcing carbons. Our goal through this technology platform is to develop products for our customers that offer sustainable content with reliable performance and importantly, at industrial scale. We plan to do this by leveraging circular value chains and materials recovered from end-of-life tires, using renewable or bio-based materials, and enabling processes that reduce greenhouse gas emissions. As part of the Evolve platform, we also launched Cabot's first ISCC Plus certified solutions. which are enabling our tire customers to bring demonstration products to the market made from circular materials. Our market leadership, global footprint, and broad evolve in E2C technology platforms position Cabot to partner and win with leading customers as the mobility sector transitions to meet society's sustainability demands. In addition, last week we announced the launch of our new Entera Aerogel Particles Portfolio. Interra aerogel particles are a thermal insulation additive targeted for thermal barrier solutions for electric vehicle lithium ion batteries. We believe thermal management will be an important design feature of safe batteries and expect there will be a variety of application forms that serve this market. Cabot's aerogel products provide customers with formulation flexibility to develop very thin forms, including blankets, pads, sheets, films, foams, and coatings. Over time, we believe that aerogel solutions can develop into a meaningful addition to our battery materials addressable market and further position Cabot as a critical material supplier to support the global transition to vehicle electrification. And finally, our sustainability leadership continues to gain recognition from leading ESG rating services. Most recently, Cabot received a platinum rating from EcoVedas. the highest recognition available for the third consecutive year. The platinum rating recognizes Cabot's environmental, social, and governance efforts and places Cabot among the top 1% of companies assessed by EcoVedas. EcoVedas is one of the world's leading sustainability ratings platforms and one that many of our customers rely on to evaluate their supply chains. I'll now turn the call over to Erika to discuss the segment and financial performance. Erika?
spk16: Thanks, Sean. I will start with discussing results for the company and then review the segment results. Adjusted EPS for the second quarter of fiscal 2023 was $1.33 compared to $1.69 in the second quarter of fiscal 2022, with growth in the reinforcement materials segment offset by declines in the performance chemical segment. The quarter was also impacted by higher net interest expense of $7 million year-over-year and unfavorable foreign currency exchange impacts of $7 million. Year-to-date impacts from increases in net interest expenses are 14 million, and our expectation for the fiscal year is unchanged from last quarter at approximately 20 million. Year-to-date unfavorable impacts from foreign currency exchange were 19 million, and we expect the year-over-year impacts to be somewhat minimal going forward for the second half of the year. Discretionary free cash flow in the quarter was $76 million, and we ended the quarter with $205 million of cash. Cash flow from operations was $162 million, which included a reduction in networking capital in the quarter of $59 million. The reduction was in line with what I highlighted in our expectation last quarter, and looking ahead, we expect a further reduction in networking capital in excess of $50 million over the two remaining quarters of the fiscal year. based on the current future expectation for oil prices. CapEx in the quarter was 51 million and we expect full year CapEx to be between 250 and 300 million. The balance sheet remains strong with total liquidity of 1.2 billion and net debt to EBITDA of 1.8 times as of March 31st. Our operating tax rate was 25% for the quarter and we anticipate the fiscal year rate will be between 24 and 26%. Now moving to reinforcement materials. During the second quarter, EBIT for reinforcement materials increased by $21 million as compared to the same period in the prior year, to a record EBIT of $122 million. The increase was driven by improved unit margins from higher pricing and product mix in our 2023 calendar year customer agreements, partially offset by 7% lower volumes and higher fixed costs. Globally, volumes were down in all regions in the second quarter as compared to the same period of the prior year, with declines of 2% in the Americas, 2% in Europe, and 12% in Asia. Lower volumes in Asia were driven by the effects from the COVID outbreaks in China. Looking to the third quarter of fiscal 2023, we expect the reinforcement materials EBIT to increase sequentially, as volumes are expected to improve, particularly in Asia as demand strengthens after the impact from the COVID-19 outbreak. Year-over-year volumes in the third quarter are expected to be slightly down as compared to the prior year, aligned with external market expectations. We also anticipate margins to be maintained as pricing in our calendar year agreements are set for the rest of the year. On a fiscal year basis, we continue to expect strong double-digit EBIT growth as compared to last year, largely due to the improved unit margins from higher pricing and product mix in our 2023 calendar year customer agreement. Now turning to performance chemicals, EBIT decreased by $42 million in the second fiscal quarter as compared to the same period in fiscal 2022. The decrease was principally driven by our few metal oxides product line, where we experienced a 22% volume decline year over year and lower unit margins. Lower volumes were driven by weaker demand in silicones applications and the impact from the COVID outbreaks in China. Lower margins were driven by the comparison to the prior year, where we experienced temporary margin expansion from pricing ahead of raw materials last year. In addition, the segment also experienced lower volumes in our specialty carbons product line, as well as the negative impact from unabsorbed costs as we reduced inventory levels and unfavorable foreign exchange impact. In summary, year over year, the decline was driven by $18 million of lower volumes, $15 million of lower unit margins, $4 million from the impact of reducing inventory levels, and $4 million of unfavorable foreign currency impacts. Looking ahead to the third quarter of fiscal 2023, we expect EBIT to be up sequentially due to higher volumes across all of our product lines as demand in our key end markets improves and margins remain relatively stable. We have seen improvement in segment volumes month to month as we move through the second quarter. We have also reduced costs across the segment given the weaker demand environment, which we expect will help improve EBIT levels in the second half of the year. I will now turn the call back over to Sean.
spk05: Thanks, Erica. Moving to the 2023 outlook, I feel very good about the continued progress we are making as a company despite the short-term macroeconomic headwinds. At a strategic level, the key drivers of earnings growth remain unchanged. The impact from our calendar year 2023 reinforcement materials customer agreements is driving the record second quarter EBIT in this segment, and the replacement nature of the tire market provides a certain resilience in this business. We expect volumes to pick up in the second half of the year with regional supply-demand dynamics expected to remain tight, all of which drives our expectation for another year of strong double-digit EBIT growth in the reinforcement materials segment. And while performance chemicals has been impacted by the weak external demand environment in the first half of our fiscal year, we expect volumes in all product lines to pick up in the second half of the year. We also expect our growth vectors to be strong contributors to the segment recovery in the second half of the year as sequential volumes improve in battery materials and inkjet volumes accelerate driven by penetration in our targeted growth applications. However, given the slower than expected recovery across our performance chemicals and markets, particularly in China, and a temporary slowdown of sequential momentum in battery materials, We're adjusting our full year guidance to be in the range of $6.10 to $6.50. The midpoint of our guidance would imply modest growth of adjusted earnings per share for the fiscal year, which for us, given our fiscal year, includes a very weak December destocking quarter. As we think about the quarterly shape of earnings for the full fiscal year, we expect a significant step up in the second half relative to the first half. providing strong momentum heading into fiscal year 2024. As the earnings increase in the second half of our fiscal year, and based on the anticipated working capital release, we expect operating cash flow and free cash flow to be very strong. In closing, we are confident in our strategic position and believe that CAPIT offers a unique growth opportunity. Reinforcement Materials is a structurally improved business with strong earnings and cash flow generation. Performance Chemicals is comprised of industry-leading positions with exposure to long-term macro tailwinds. Battery Materials offers the potential for breakout growth, and we have the conviction and the balance sheet to invest behind this transformational shift in mobility. Our portfolio has strong cash flow characteristics, which can fund our advantage growth investments and return cash to shareholders. And finally, we are a recognized leader in sustainability, and this strength underpins our purpose and our Creating for Tomorrow strategy. With these value drivers firmly in place, we remain on track to achieve the targets outlined in our December 2021 Investor Day. Thank you very much for joining us today, and I'll now turn the call over for our Q&A session.
spk07: As a reminder, to ask a question, you will need to press star 11 on your telephone. Again, that's star 11 on your telephone to ask a question. Please stand by while we compile the Q&A roster.
spk22: Our first question comes from the line of John Roberts of Credit Suisse.
spk07: Your question, please, John.
spk19: Thank you. In reinforcement, I assume you've got more price in the U.S. than elsewhere. Could you at least give us a qualitative discussion of the regional price trends?
spk05: Sure, John. I would say the pricing trends across the western market, the western regions, were pretty consistent, actually. And that lines up with the the pretty consistent structural dynamics in the regions in terms of supply-demand, you know, growth in entire production, the importance of regionalization of the supply chain, all those factors. So I would say they're actually quite consistent across the Western markets.
spk19: And then within the performance segment, could you talk about master batch?
spk05: versus few metal oxides in within few metal oxides i didn't hear any discussion about the semiconductor market weakness yeah so uh let me let me touch on uh the few metal oxides uh first because that's certainly the single biggest driver of the weakness in performance chemicals now uh this uh the few metal oxides market uh serves principally uh applications in the silicone space this is by far the largest volume space in the market. And silicones were down very, very sharply in this quarter. You know, there were several public company comps in this silicone space, and you can see that their results were down sharply. So I think our dynamic is similar to the overall market. And as Erica said, volumes were down 22% year over year in this product line. And As you might recall from the past or investor day, this product line is the highest margin business in the segment. So when you combine that with the high operating leverage in the business, it's pretty significant. Now, there are also silica sales, fume silica sales into the semiconductor space. Those have diminished over time as next-generation nodes have moved to other forms of abrasive particle, either colloidal silica or seria, so products that we don't participate in. That being said, we do still have a meaningful legacy tail of silica into the CMP or semiconductor space, and that, too, was declining, but the largest driver here, John, was the contraction or the lower demand in the overall silicones space.
spk22: Thank you. Again, to ask a question, press star 11.
spk07: Our next question. comes from the line of Josh Spector, UBS. Your question, please, Josh.
spk10: Yeah, hi. Thanks for taking my question. In your slides, you have a comment on performance chems that margins are expected to remain stable from 2Q23 levels. I wanted to really understand that more. I mean, your margins were about 9% in the quarter. You talked about cost savings. You talked about improvements. Do you mean that they're going to be stable at that level or they're going to improve from those levels?
spk05: What we mean, Josh, is that the unit margin, so price minus variable cost, will remain stable. Obviously, the EBITDA margins will improve over the quarter as we get higher volumes and more coverage of the cost base and then some of the cost actions that we're talking about. flow through. So when we say margins, we're talking about that sort of price minus raw spread. That's what we mean.
spk10: Okay, got it. That makes sense. And just, you know, on your battery materials business, where you talk about the new wind, where you're now serving nine of the 10 largest producers, I was wondering if you can give some context around there. Are any of those exclusive are you supplying the majority of the conductive carbons into those formulations or are you more qualified for that platform so how much of this materializes into sales specifically for cabot versus giving you the optionality to do so yeah so the way it typically works in battery materials is you get qualified into a battery program or a battery platform
spk05: uh and then as that platform grows and proliferates then you grow with it uh so that's typically how it how it works so for example legacy platforms that cabot may not have been in uh typically those uh don't get switched out it has much more to do with winning new programs so as the program ramps uh then uh we would expect our uh our our sales volumes to uh to ramp up with that uh now typically because these are going into automotive applications uh there's usually a primary and a secondary supplier to a program because the auto oes require that sort of supply redundancy um but it's really program driven uh josh and so as the program ramps uh assuming the success that the customer um you know, intends, then we would see the flow through of that.
spk22: Okay. Thanks, Sean. Thank you.
spk07: Our next question comes from the line of Jeff Zakowskis of JPMorgan. Your line is open, Jeff.
spk13: Hi, morning. This is Lydia on for Jeff. It seems like contract renegotiation for rubber black has started early this year.
spk11: What are you seeing across different regions?
spk05: Sorry, Lydia, could you just say that again? I said something about contracts and regions. Sorry.
spk13: Yeah, it's just we've heard that the contract renegotiation for rubber black has started early this year. So, just wondering, what are you seeing for pricing across different regions?
spk05: Yeah, so it is early in the process. So, normally the contract discussions begin over the course of the summer and then progress into the fall period. And so, you know, certain customers have approached us to start negotiations for 2024. I think there are a lot of moving parts. However, I think what happens as the Russia sanction date nears in 2024 and how the China feedstock economics as potential replacement for the Russian material, for example, in Europe, you know, these are important dynamics to watch. So I would say it's early in the process here. I would remind you that we did close some negotiations in 2023. There were multi-year agreements with incremental pricing in 2024, so I think this does give us some momentum heading into 2024, and it does set a market reference. But I would say while certain conversations have begun, it's early in the process. That said, I would say the structural supply-demand dynamics in the western markets remain unchanged and favorable, and so we expect that to continue.
spk13: Thank you. And your cash flow from operations this quarter is higher than for your full year last year. So can you talk about the changes here and maybe talk more about your expectation for the rest of the year?
spk16: Sure. So operating cash flow was strong this quarter. As the EBITDA improved from earlier in the year, that's part of it. And then I would say it's really working capital and so last year we had increasing raw material costs that cause increasing levels of investment into the working capital. We see that those raw material costs are coming down this year. And so you see a positive contribution or source of cash. from working capital in the second quarter. We expect that to continue as we move through the year. So that goes to the comments I made where we would think another in excess of 50 million would be released out of working capital in the back half of the year. And so expect continued very strong cash flow from operations as we go through the rest of 2023. Thank you.
spk22: Thank you.
spk07: Our next question comes from the line of Lawrence Alexander of Jefferies. Please go ahead, Lawrence.
spk18: Hi, it's Dan Rizwan for Lawrence. You mentioned the circular tires, the new product. I was just wondering how we should think about the growth within that product. Is it going to be something, I assume not, but is the same growth trajectory as battery materials? Could there be something of that magnitude or
spk05: will be maybe a longer timeline yeah you're referring to the evolve sustainable solutions product uh uh technology launch uh dan yeah that's correct yeah yeah yeah the uh the technology platform that we launched our goal here is to develop products that offer sustainable content with reliable performance. And I think most importantly, at industrial scale. And I think we're in a great position to do that. And so we'll be leveraging the circular value chains and materials that are recovered from end-of-life tires, as well as any renewable or bio-based material options, feedstock options, and processes that can reduce the greenhouse gas emissions. So these are the levers that we're pulling under the evolved uh, platform. And so if you think about, uh, over time, uh, how this should develop, we anticipate driving revenue starting in this year. Uh, and we expect to see, uh, a material impact from the evolved sustainable solutions over a five to 10 year period is how you ought to think about it. This is driven by the speed of adoption of new technologies in the rubber industry, uh, as well as how our tire customers, greenhouse gas goals set up between here and 2050 carbon neutrality, which they all have goals for that. But how exactly their interim goals in 2030 and between 2030 and 2050, how those line out will drive things too. But I would think about this as a longer term play that's really getting at uh the sustainability needs of our customers and frankly society's uh pressures around uh around sustainability so we're excited about it uh because uh we think we bring uh you know an ability to to commercialize uh develop and commercialize these technologies and do it at scale which uh you know there are startups and the like that play in this space but can't really bring things to market at scale the way we can. So that's how I would think about it, Dan. All right.
spk18: Thank you. And then it was mentioned that there was an improvement in working capital because of the drop in oil prices. I was wondering if there's a rule of thumb with oil and its relation to working capital, such as a $10 movement in oil translates into an X movement in working capital or how we should think about that.
spk16: Sure, Dan. So I can answer that. The general rule of thumb is about a $1 change in oil is about $5 million in working capital. And so it does usually happen over really two quarters usually, as you'll see the inventory repriced quickly and then the accounts receivable might move into the following quarter. But that's the rule of thumb.
spk12: Thank you very much.
spk07: Thank you. Once again, to ask a question, please press star 1-1 on your telephone. Our next question comes from the line of Chris Katsch of Loop Capital. Please go ahead, Chris. Good morning.
spk02: So, if I think about the – morning, Dan. So, if I think about the guidance uh the modest guidance reduction it sounds like it's predominantly attributable to trends in the performance chemical segment and you mentioned um team silica's into the silicon industry is the biggest i don't know if if you can rank order the other contributors that especially maybe especially carbons maybe there's a residual d stock there i don't know if that's second but then the slower momentum is released temporarily in battery materials You also mentioned, though, I'm curious if that's kind of the right way to think in terms of order of magnitude, but also just you mentioned, you know, improving demand trends for this segment on a monthly basis. Just wondering if you could characterize if that's characteristic of each of those different businesses and how it's persisted, how those trends have persisted thus far into the third quarter through April.
spk05: Maybe on the first question, Erica will take that, and then I'll come back on the second one. Chris?
spk16: Yeah, Chris, I think if you think of the impact in the quarter, fuel metal oxide is by far the largest and majority of the decline. Next, I would say it would be our specialty carbons business. Volumes are down about 5% in that business, which drove a reduction in most of the inventory or unabsorbed costs. because of the inventory reductions is also in carbon. So that would probably be secondary. And then as Sean talked about battery materials, the temporary decline here in EV sales in Q2 was also impactful. So I would probably say it's in that order. As we think about the volume recovery, I'd say it's through Q2 a pretty broad base in terms of month-to-month improvement. As we move through the quarter, I would say battery materials also improved in April. So from the exit in Q2 into April, volumes in battery materials have improved. So I think that's good. In some of the other businesses, I'd say April was a bit weaker than March, but I would characterize it as stronger than kind of the January, February run rate. So that's what we've seen in April. And then I'd say the order book for May looks pretty strong across the businesses. And so that's what, you know, our outlook takes into consideration.
spk05: Okay. And then. Yeah. And maybe, Chris, just a couple of additional comments there. So, again, the midpoint of the range is, you know, would be roughly flat to fiscal 22. But that was a record and up 25% over fiscal 21. And so a couple of things here. One is that would be a result after offsetting about 50 cents EPS headwind from interest and unfavorable FX. And then also important to remember that given our fiscal year end of September 30, we're pulling in that very weak December quarter. So when you look at second half momentum, I think that's an important picture to look at there. I think the monthly trends, Erica touched on well. I don't have anything more to add on that one.
spk02: Got it. And then my follow-up is focused on the battery material space. And a key theme here has been, you know, more broadly has been just the security of supply concerns for really a variety of battery materials. And I'm And to the extent that you're having tremendous success, nine out of the top ten lithium ion battery producers globally and partnering with them, supplying them, I'm just curious how that theme plays into your relationships with those customers. And obviously you're supplying those now, but do they have expectations for you to partner with them globally? How is that playing out? Do you have visibility to what their demand requirements are going to be you know, in different regions? And is that, you know, is that starting to play into your, you know, your growth capital plan? Thank you. Yeah, sure.
spk05: Well, certainly, I think a couple of things are going on in the battery market. It's been principally a China market up until now, as you know, well, I think some 75-ish percent of batteries, I think, are made in China. So outside of China is relatively small, but there are significant battery investments that are being constructed as we speak and coming online over the next, you know, two, three years and out into the end of the decade. And so I think a couple of things are going to happen. Chris, first of all, you're seeing a lot of non Chinese battery players building outside of China. And I think you'll probably see some sort of a bifurcation between a battery market for China and then a rest of world. And so certainly the customers that we're working with in Europe and the U.S., really value regional supply. And so, you know, I think the ability to provide that to them is very important. Now, typically what happens here is that you get qualified in a program with a given battery maker, and then as that particular program or platform proliferates, then you grow with that. So as you get qualified and begin to win, there's a ramp schedule, sometimes hard to predict. That's why I think there can be some unevenness in the way this market develops. But that's how you want to think about it. And I think Cabot's global scale, our footprint, our ability to build out capacity regionally for these customers as this market bifurcates. And I think that's, I think, an advantage for Cabot. And so we're investing behind that and are building out capacity to meet that.
spk22: Thank you. Thank you. At this time, I would like to turn the conference back to Sean Cohen for closing remarks.
spk07: Sir?
spk05: Great. Well, thank you very much for joining today. Thank you for your continued support of Cabot Corporation, and I hope you have a safe day. Be well.
spk07: This concludes today's conference call. Thank you for participating. You may now disconnect.
Disclaimer

This conference call transcript was computer generated and almost certianly contains errors. This transcript is provided for information purposes only.EarningsCall, LLC makes no representation about the accuracy of the aforementioned transcript, and you are cautioned not to place undue reliance on the information provided by the transcript.

-

-