logo

Yelp Inc.

Q42022

2/9/2023

speaker
Operator

Good afternoon. Thank you for attending today's Yelp fourth quarter and full year 2022 earnings conference call. My name is Megan and I'll be your moderator for today's call. All lines will be muted during the presentation portion of the call with an opportunity for questions and answers at the end. If you would like to ask a question, please press star one on your telephone keypad. I would now like to pass the conference over to James Milne, Senior Vice President of Finance and Investor Relations. James, please go ahead.

speaker
Megan

Good afternoon, everyone, and thanks for joining us on Yelp's fourth quarter and full year 2022 earnings conference call. Joining me today are Yelp's Chief Executive Officer, Jeremy Stoppelman, Chief Financial Officer, David Schwarzbach, and Chief Operating Officer, Jed Nockman. We published the shareholder letter on our investor relations website and with the SEC and hope everyone had a chance to read it. We'll provide some brief opening comments and then turn to your questions. Now I'll read our safe harbor statement. We'll make certain statements today that are forward-looking and involve a number of risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially. Please note that these forward-looking statements reflect our opinions only as of the date of this call, and we undertake no obligation to revise or publicly release the results of any revision to these forward-looking statements in light of new information or future events. In addition, we are subject to a number of risks that may significantly impact our business and financial results. Please refer to our SEC filings as well as our shareholder letter for a more detailed description of the risk factors that may affect our results. During our call today, we'll discuss adjusted EBITDA and adjusted EBITDA margin, which are non-GAAP financial measures. These measures should not be considered in isolation from or as a substitute for financial information prepared in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles. In our shareholder letter released this afternoon and our filings with the SEC, each of which is posted on our website, you will find additional disclosures regarding these non-GAAP financial measures, as well as historical reconciliations of GAAP net income to both adjusted EBITDA and adjusted EBITDA margin. And with that, I will turn the call over to Jeremy.

speaker
Jeremy Stoppelman

Thanks James and welcome everyone. Yelp delivered one of the strongest revenue growth performances among our advertising and marketplace peers in 2022. Our performance ad products and high intent audience generated robust advertiser demand across a broad range of categories, both on and off Yelp. Net revenue increased by 16% year over year to a record $1.2 billion in 2022. We delivered this performance with net income of $36 million and adjusted EBITDA of $270 million. These results demonstrate the strength and durability of Yelp's ad platform and the ability of our team to execute under a range of difficult conditions to deliver excellent results. Underlying our record top line, our product-led strategy drove a number of other record results in 2022. We achieved record paying advertising locations and average revenue per location for the year. In services, we succeeded in differentiating the product experience and increasing monetization and lead quality, resulting in greater value to service pros. We believe Yelp gained market share in 2022 as advertising revenue from services businesses grew 14% year over year to a record $694 million. The home services category was particularly strong, with year over year growth of approximately 20%. Since 2019, revenue from this category has compounded at an annual growth rate of nearly 20%. Advertising revenues from restaurants, retail, and other businesses increased by 17% year over year to $441 million, driven by growth in paying advertising locations. We continue to deliver value to advertisers in these categories by enhancing our suite of ad products designed to deliver high intent clicks both up and down the funnel and on and off Yelp. On the consumer side of our business, traffic remained below pre-pandemic levels as the macro environment contributed to softer consumer demand. App unique devices of 33 million were flat compared to 2021. Despite this backdrop, we made early progress on the consumer focused initiative we announced at the beginning of 2022. We reduced friction from the review writing process, which helped our trustworthy content grow by 21 million new reviews in 2022. This resulted in more than 265 million cumulative reviews as of December 31st, up 9% from 2021. In addition, our early work with large language models suggests there are a number of near-term applications that we can leverage to enhance the consumer experience on Yelp. We deliver value to our advertisers through our sophisticated ad system. This best-in-class technology is able to respond dynamically to changes in supply and demand to efficiently match consumers with advertisers. While ad clicks for the year declined by 8% from 2021, a year that had benefited from reopening tailwind and elevated consumer spending, Advertiser demand remained robust as we executed against our roadmap of ad system improvements and average CPC increased by 27% year over year. We also made progress on our initiative to drive sales through the most efficient channels. Self-serve and multi-location channels each grew approximately 25% year over year to record levels in 2022. Together, these channels represented approximately 48% of advertising revenue in 2022 up four percentage points from 21. Looking back over the last year, the Yelp team has made tremendous progress across all of our strategic initiatives. Our investments in product have not only delivered record revenue, but also strengthened Yelp's position as a leader in local with trusted content and sophisticated ad tech. As a result, we plan to expand upon each of our initiatives to drive profitable growth in 2023 and over the long term by continuing to invest in growing quality leads and monetization in services, driving sales through the most efficient channels, delivering more value to advertisers, and enhancing the consumer experience. At their core, these initiatives aim to continue to differentiate Yelp from peers in bringing increased value to local consumers and advertisers. We believe that our consistent execution in these areas in 2022 has positioned Yelp better than ever to drive long-term profitable growth. With that, I'd like to turn it over to David.

speaker
James

Thanks for the recap of our strong 2022 performance, Jeremy. I will now turn to our fourth quarter results. Fourth quarter net revenue increased by 13% year over year to $309 million, near the high end of our outlook range. Net income decreased by 13% year over year to $20 million, largely due to a significant increase in our effective gap tax rate. Adjusted EBITDA grew by 18%, year-over-year to $80 million, which is at the midpoint of our outlook range. Paying advertising locations increased by 3% year-over-year to $545,000 in the fourth quarter, while average revenue per location reached a quarterly record. Advertising revenue from services businesses increased by 13% year-over-year to $178 million in the fourth quarter. Our efforts to drive high-quality leads to service pros have clearly resonated with advertisers in these categories. Average revenue per location and services reached a record and increased for the 10th quarter in a row. Advertising revenue from restaurants, retail, and other businesses increased by 11% year-over-year to $116 million. As anticipated in our fourth quarter business outlook, advertiser demand was more muted in the 2022 holiday season than in prior years particularly among multi-location advertisers. This contributed to softer year-over-year growth in paying advertising locations in these categories. Turning to expenses, since significantly decreasing our headcount in 2020, we have made prudent investments in our product-led strategy to drive profitable growth over the long term. We have increased the size of our product development and multi-location sales organizations while holding local sales headcount relatively flat. As a result, we ended the year with a total headcount of approximately 4,900 people, representing an increase of 11% year over year, but still 18% below 2019, while full year net revenue increased by 16% and 18% over the same periods. We are pleased with this progress and currently plan to maintain approximately the same total headcount in 2023. We believe our sales channel makeshift product-led strategy and reduced real estate footprint will be sources of leverage and margin improvement over the long term. In addition, we are committed to reducing stock-based compensation as a percentage of revenue. In 2022, we decrease this percentage by approximately two percentage points and expect to drive an additional decrease of one percentage point in 2023. Looking ahead, we believe we can lower stock-based compensation to less than 8% of revenue by the end of 2025. driven by revenue growth, as well as by continuing to optimize our location and compensation mix, particularly within product development. Returning capital to shareholders through share repurchases remains an important element of our overall capital allocation strategy. In 2022, we repurchased $200 million worth of shares at an average purchase price of $32.28. At the end of the year, we had $282 million remaining under our existing repurchase authorizations. We plan to continue repurchasing shares in 2023 subject to market and economic conditions. Turning to our outlook, as we enter 2023, we continue to believe in the significant long-term opportunities ahead and our team's ability to capture them. However, the macro environment remains challenging. We expect net revenue will be in the range of $300 million to $310 million for the first quarter, reflecting typical seasonality. For the third year, we expect net revenue will be in the range of $1.29 billion to $1.31 billion as our initiatives continue to drive growth against the backdrop of ongoing macro uncertainties. Turning to margin, we expect expenses to increase from the fourth quarter to the first quarter, reflecting our hiring efforts in 2022, as well as a seasonal increase in expense, primarily driven by payroll taxes. As a result, we anticipate first quarter adjusted EBITDA to be in the range of $40 million to $50 million. For the full year, we expect expenses to increase modestly year over year as we maintain approximately the same total headcount compared to the end of 2022. As such, we anticipate adjusted EBITDA to be in the range of $290 million to $310 million for the full year. We also currently expect our effective gap tax rate for 2023 to be in the range of 32% to 38%, largely due to the requirement to amortize certain research and development expenses under the 2017 US Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. In closing, Yelp delivered one of the strongest revenue growth performances among our advertising and marketplace peers in 2022. Our broad-based local ad platform has proven its durability, and our team has continued to execute against our initiative, driving excellent results. While the macro environment remains uncertain, we've built a strong foundation for the future and are confident in Yelp's path to delivering profitable growth along with shareholder value over the long term. With that, operator, please open up the line for questions.

speaker
Operator

Thank you. If you would like to ask a question, please press star followed by one on your telephone keypad. If for any reason you would like to remove that question, please press star followed by two. Again, to ask a question, press star one. If you have any follow-up questions, you are more than welcome to rejoin the queue. As a reminder, if you're using a speakerphone, please remember to pick up your handset before asking your question. We will pause here briefly as questions are registered.

speaker
David

Our first question comes from the line of Colin Sebastian with Baird.

speaker
Operator

Your line is now open.

speaker
spk02

Great. Thanks. Good afternoon. Thanks for taking my questions. I guess two for me. First, regarding some of the expense outlook, I think keeping product development roughly flattish, adding headcount to sales, just curious about the thought process behind that. It sounds like you have what you need from a product development or product developer standpoint, but just a little more detail on the sales strategy. And then secondly, given the strength you saw during the year, I'm just curious in terms of how we should think about it. You talked about the roadmap, but continuing growth beyond this year, the ad pricing is still going up, clicks down. Maybe there's a flip there where it shifts more to more ad click growth. Just curious on some of the metrics, how you see that playing out.

speaker
Jed

Thank you.

speaker
David

Thanks for the question, Colin.

speaker
James

With regard to headcount on the expense side, just to clarify, in 2022, we added to product and engineering. We also added to our multi-location sales team. Our local sales headcount, which is still down substantially from 2019, was modestly higher, but in line with what we shared with you in the past about being in the range of about half of what it had previously been. That's really around 2022. For 2023, we plan to keep headcount overall approximately flat. And that's true across all of the functional areas, whether it's product and engineering, sales and marketing, or general and administrative. So no shift in mix expected in terms of headcount in 2023.

speaker
David

And Colin, this is Jeremy. I'll take the second question there. You know, thinking about the roadmap for the year and beyond, we feel really great.

speaker
Jeremy Stoppelman

You know, despite all of the macro uncertainty you know the team's execution on the product and engineering side the rest of the company too but specifically on the product and engineering side has been you know really clean um you know we continue to have a deep portfolio of uh projects you know leading into ads continuing to improve our ad stack stack that are matching request a quote you know driving up uh both the number of projects as well as you know the quality of leads uh obviously makes a difference We've turned more towards the consumer recently. In 22, we started that pivot. We're starting to see some benefits there. You may have noticed reviews grew 3% year over year. So starting to see some of those wins stack up. And then from a go-to-market perspective, we've been leaning into self-serve and multi-location. Continues to go well. We continue to see really great progress there. And then for farther afield, we've started to try and share a little bit more color about why we have conviction that we can grow for a considerable amount of time into the future. One example that we cite in the letter is looking at SEM for services traffic. There's a big pool of quality leads out there, and we currently don't participate in that area really at all. And so if you go and you look back at What we've built, you know, with request to quote, nearby jobs, matching technology, like we've been slowly assembling the pieces necessary to play uniquely in that space. And I think if you look at the strength of Yelp's brand, and then also its value to consumers beyond a single job, I think that gives you some sense of like why we think we can take, you know, considerable share in that space over time. We haven't baked anything, you know, into this year. It's really, this year is about product development and experimentation in that area. But I think in the out years, that's a really interesting area. And then I would just point you to off Yelp as just another area of investment and opportunity for us. It wasn't that long ago that Yelp syndication and Yelp audiences didn't really exist. You know, that's been innovation that we've built in house, you know, and now it's, it's a rapidly growing, a considerable business for us. It's taking a very unique, you know, down funnel intent that we see from consumers on Yelp, and then it's reaching out to those consumers as they travel across the web, providing even more value to our advertisers. So, you know, if you look across the whole host of portfolio, you get, as we do, high confidence that there's growth opportunities in the future and over the long term.

speaker
David

Great. Thanks, guys. Appreciate that.

speaker
David

Sure.

speaker
Operator

Thank you. Our next question comes from the line of Shweta Kajuria with Evercore ISI. Your line is now open.

speaker
Shweta Kajuria

Thank you for taking my questions. I have a couple, please. So you talked about services revenue and you gained share in the industry versus peers. It sounds like you want to maintain the 25% monetized fees based on the shareholder letter.

speaker
Operator

Would you

speaker
Shweta Kajuria

Specifically, double-click on what your plans are for the year in terms of driving quality of leads and improving the experience to drive services revenue growth. That's question one. And the second question is, David, if you could please talk about the cadence of EBITDA. So sequentially, you had some comments in the prepared remarks as well as in the letter. But how should we think about cadence of EBITDA for the rest of the year to get to your full year guide? Thank you.

speaker
David

Hi, Shweta. This is Jeremy. I can touch on maybe the first one within services and monetize leads.

speaker
Jeremy Stoppelman

Really happy to see the growth there, particularly the growth in home services. I believe that was 20% year over year. Great to see all that activity happening on Yelp. We have a whole host of continued improvements within, request a quote, One project in particular launching soon will really leverage Yelp's brand to help give consumers the confidence to engage with requested quote in particular. So we do see a really healthy portfolio within our product development sphere there. On the monetized leads question, 25% monetized leads, that has come up a lot over the years. We do think obviously there's considerable headroom to keep making improvements there. But, you know, there's trade-offs like we could certainly move that number up, but if the quality isn't there from a lead perspective, then that value isn't felt on the advertiser side. And given the really high demand from advertisers right now, we want to make sure that they're getting a lead that is actionable, that works for them, where they feel like there's an opportunity to drive ROI. So we're not rushing to drive that number up immediately. We're focused on quality as we were last year, but we do believe that over time that will continue to go up.

speaker
James

Shweta, just addressing your question on the cadence of EBITDA through the year. Once again, in the first quarter, we do see significantly higher expense due to payroll taxes. There's also a bit of layering in the additional expense of headcount that we hired in the first half of 2022. So we would expect EBITDA to increase over the course of the year. and for expenses to moderate down from the first quarter as we also move through the year. So that's the profile that we expect in order to deliver the 300 to 310 for, excuse me, yeah, the 290 to 310 for 2023.

speaker
Shweta Kajuria

Okay, thanks, David. Thanks, Jeremy. Just a quick follow-up though. So David, any help with Just for modeling purposes, in terms of seasonality, should we follow a particular year? Is it more representative of 2019 versus perhaps 2022? Any thoughts there?

speaker
James

Shweta, I don't, off the top of my head, have a thought in terms of that seasonality for a year to compare to. We'll go back and take a look at that. What I can say again is tier one is meaningfully higher because of this payroll tax and that we do actually expect for expenses to moderate down as we move through the year in order to deliver the overall adjusted EBITDA for the year. But let us take a look and see what we think is a comparable year. in terms of profile. As you know, things have changed considerably through 19, 20, and 21. It makes it a little harder to do comparisons. And the other thing I would just point out is we are not seeing large movements in headcount in 23, or we don't anticipate large movements in headcount in 23. So that's also just a very different profile compared to prior years.

speaker
Shweta Kajuria

Okay. Appreciate it. Thanks, David.

speaker
David

Thank you.

speaker
Operator

Our next question comes from the line of Eric Sheridan with Goldman Sachs. Your line is now open.

speaker
Eric Sheridan

Thanks so much for taking the questions, maybe two if I can. Coming back to the comments on the macro, we'd love to get as much detail as you're willing to give about what sort of headwind that might have created to Q4, the beginning of Q1, just so we could better size out X the macro. How are you thinking about the underlying performance of the business of things within your control versus outside of your control. And then coming back to the mix shift towards self-serve and multi-location, are there any elements you can give us in terms of targets or frameworks of thinking about mix shift towards those elements of the ad business as we move through 23 and think about an exit velocity into 2024? Thanks so much.

speaker
Jed

Hi, Eric.

speaker
Eric

This is Jed. I can take both questions. You know, in terms of the Q4 revenue and macro visibility, you know, we remain really pleased with the overall resilience of the business thus far. We've, you know, in the past experienced, you know, periods of uncertainty and the business has remained solid. We have a diverse and really high quality revenue base by both channel and category, you know, with down funnel performance-based ads. Our most efficient channels, as you mentioned, self-serving multi-local, both grew at a 25% rate year over year in 2022. You know, and at the edges, we did see some increased caution from the multi-location advertisers in Q4, which resulted in a more muted holiday spend than in previous years. These businesses have obviously been dealing with a number of macro issues from labor supply to rising input costs. But our relationships with the multi-local businesses remain really, really strong today. And we believe that multi-location channel has room to run. And on the SMB side, our advertiser base is comprised of really high quality local SMBs, which has demonstrated that resilience in the past. We're focused on what's in our control right now and executing against those initiatives. And in terms of the mix between self-serve and multi-location, we've increased four points year over year in terms of the total out of those two channels between self-serve and multi-location. up to 48% of our revenue. And, you know, you have over approximately 50% of our revenue growing at a 25% clip. So we're really pleased with those two channels. We've continued to make improvements on the multi-location product portfolio, spotlight ads, Yelp audiences, sponsored collections, which are really resonating in the marketplace. And on the self-serve side, you know, continuing to make improvements in terms of, you know, what we're giving our local advertisers in terms of customer insights and an improved message center and really matching the most important leads with our advertisers. So from a mix shift perspective, we're going to continue to lean into both of those channels and believe they both have had room to run.

speaker
Jed

Thanks so much.

speaker
David

Thank you.

speaker
Operator

Our next question comes from the line of Corey Carpenter with JP Morgan. Your line is now open.

speaker
Corey Carpenter

Hey, thank you. I have two. I want to try one more in macro, just maybe more specifically, have you seen improvement in the multi-location advertiser base coming out of the holiday season, or would you characterize it as kind of staying steady perhaps at those lower levels? And then secondly, on the consumer demand, I think, Jeremy, you mentioned that it remains

speaker
Eric

little below pre-pandemic levels curious what you attribute that to um and then you know you call that app unique devices are lower but you know what about engagement per user um and how that's trending thank you i can take another shot at the at the macro in terms of multi-location trends um you know obviously we saw that muted spend in the fourth quarter um but we were really pleased with the way we were able to kind of um continue conversations with all those multi-location advertisers and we feel like we're really well positioned going into 2023. Ultimately in this type of environment, you know, we have a really down funnel lead, you know, and are strong from, you know, in times of macro uncertainty, folks want to spend their money in a place where they think they're yielding ROI and, you know, based in, we have attribution solutions as an example that are able to really, really prove that out. And whether it's our YSV, which is our first party data, um you know derived from yelp and or third parties that we use in order to to kind of showcase that attribution um that's in a in a really good spot right now of course there are our macro uncertainties that are they're out of our control um but we feel well positioned um relative to the competition as we head into 2023 there um and so yeah that's what i would say on the multi-location side hi corey jeremy gunn

speaker
Jeremy Stoppelman

talking about consumer engagement and looking at the app, it's kind of flat year over year. I think the contributing factor, you know, obviously macro and, you know, how much consumers are getting out there and transacting. But, you know, we're not Just kind of sitting around, we have, you know, pivoted a lot of resources towards consumer. You know, we did see contributions, you know, rise 3% year over year. So I think that's early signs of success from the efforts there. We have a deep, you know, roadmap that we'll be executing on in 23 that's focused on, you know, some of these things you mentioned, you know, improving the Android experience, like improving engagement. We've got a new home feed that we're going to keep iterating on You know, you may have also noticed there's new technology out there, you know, large language models. We've already booked our first win within search from leveraging LLM. So I think there's a lot of opportunity. We're just gearing up, you know, last year was kind of our first effort starting to stack wins. And so I think we'll see that continue also with noting, you know, mobile web was up as well. And so with the product and engineering investment that is now quite significant, you know, I think we feel confident And then also return to marketing spend. One of the things we pulled back on, especially during the early pandemic timeframe, was installs and driving installs from a paid perspective. And so that's something that we've returned to. And so that provides some audience upside as well.

speaker
Corey Carpenter

And maybe one more, if I can, just for Jed. I thought it was interesting you called out local sales productivity. I think you said new customer acquisition was the best you've seen in two years. Curious what you attribute that to. if there's something maybe specifically that you've changed or that you're doing that you would call out as working well.

speaker
Eric

Thank you. Yeah, thanks for the question. We have been really pleased with our local channel, which includes both kind of the self-serve as well as our reps sold business. From a Salesforce perspective, certainly we feel there are benefits in our remote posture and being able to retain our top performing reps um, you know, who are now distributed across the country. And, um, that's been a real boon for us in terms of making sure that we have the right people in the seats. Um, and you know, as that Salesforce ages, you're going to get more productivity out of them. Um, and, uh, and you know, ultimately we're also given a more product to sell too, which is really, really important as you've watched the product portfolio evolve over the past few years and the confidence level, um, with which they can talk to local businesses. We know we're delivering more value than we ever have, and that's been really an important part of the success on the local sales team.

speaker
Jed

Awesome. Thank you both.

speaker
Operator

Thank you. Our next question comes from the line of John Kalantwani with Jefferies. Your line is now open.

speaker
John Kalantwani

Hi, this is Chris Ducecki on for John. Thanks for taking the question. So we think we picked up on an uptick in ad loads across the Yelp app, particularly in the services category. Was this just some testing we picked up on, or are you able to talk about if you've made a permanent adjustment to the services ad load, and then maybe just some comments on how you're thinking about greater ad load could impact consumer experience and then lead monetization? Thank you.

speaker
David

Hi, Chris. This is Jeremy.

speaker
Jeremy Stoppelman

We're constantly running experiments that are very good, the search experience. And so nothing to report there as far as something massively different than historicals. I do think a lot of the activity within services, it's important to note, is within request to quote. And so a lot of what's happening within request to quote is fully or near fully monetized. And it's a great consumer experience. because you're telling us more about your project and then you're hearing from people that can actually fulfill that and ideally within a reasonable timeframe. So, you know, we see it as kind of a win all around in that, you know, the pro gets valuable leads and an opportunity to engage with the consumer. The consumer gets responsive businesses and Yelp facilitates that and gets paid.

speaker
Jed

So that's where a lot of the focus is and a lot of the value is within services. Got it. Thanks so much.

speaker
Operator

Thank you. Our next question comes from the line of Brian Fitzgerald with Wells Fargo. Your line is now open.

speaker
Brian Fitzgerald

Hey, guys. Thanks for taking the questions. Last quarter, you guys called out some interesting, almost counter-cyclical trends in services. I think it was roofers maybe increasing ad spend even as they saw demand cool. So you noted home services was up 20%. year-over-year this quarter. So maybe it looks like that trend's continued. I'm curious if there's anything else you'd call out there or any other services categories, especially weak or strong.

speaker
Jeremy Stoppelman

Brian, this is Jeremy. Don't remember the specific on, you know, recruiters. I'm not sure about that. But, you know, we have seen services demands from advertisers remain robust and home services even more so. You know, what's going on there? I think, you know, hard to fully unpack given the, you know, strange, call it macro environment. But I think, you know, part of it is as business has slowed down, let's say a great, you know, boom time year of 21, businesses did have, you know, continue to have cash to spend on keeping their trucks rolling and keeping themselves busy. And so they're looking for reliable channels in which to invest and get a return on their investment from a leads perspective. And I think that's why so many have turned to Yelp is because we're a reliable source of high quality leads. And it's also very convenient. They can turn it on and off as needed. They can test it out and see for themselves whether we're delivering. And from our perspective, we've been working really hard on making requests to quote Work for these businesses, driving quality leads, you know, quality over quantity was a big theme last year. We weren't as focused on driving up the percentage of monetized leads. We're really focused on that lead quality. I think that's coming through. And then if you look at the opportunity off the up, we're taking that consumer demand when someone comes to us with one of these longer tail infrequent service requests, we're able to reach them when they hit, you know, maybe the New York Times or somewhere else on the web. um through yelp syndication and so that's a powerful tool as well so i think everything's coming together to deliver valuable leads to these local businesses and they're continuing to spend with us which is great awesome thank you thank you

speaker
Operator

There are no additional questions waiting at this time, so I will now conclude the Yelp fourth quarter and full year 2022 earnings conference call. Thank you for your participation. You have a wonderful day.

Disclaimer

This conference call transcript was computer generated and almost certianly contains errors. This transcript is provided for information purposes only.EarningsCall, LLC makes no representation about the accuracy of the aforementioned transcript, and you are cautioned not to place undue reliance on the information provided by the transcript.

-

-